Early comments on the PF | Page 5 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

Will Early Time Change Effect Forex Traders? 0 replies

Taking profits early, is this a sensible trading strategy? 14 replies

early USD Retail Sales news 1 reply

Start Trading Real Money Early 0 replies

Hi did the european markets close early today? 2 replies

Attachments: Early comments on the PF
Exit Attachments

Early comments on the PF

  • #81
  • Jan 19, 2006 9:05am Jan 19, 2006 9:05am
Quoting johns
Is that stating that only 39% of the people though it was a good value for the money.
Fiji has just given you some excellent advice, well worth heeding.

May I also suggest you consider taking a remedial mathematics course? The post did not say 39% satisfied. It said 39 people were satisfied and 0 (zero) people were not satistifed. That means all 39 people who voted were satisfied and that is 39 out of 39 which is 100% satisfied.

100% SATISFIED.
  • #82
  • Jan 19, 2006 5:01pm Jan 19, 2006 5:01pm
C'mon guys... Let's chill a bit!

Though I tend to agree quite a bit with Fiji's assessment, there's no need to become personal...

I am giving him the benefit of the doubt and assume the guy just mis-interpreted the data...

(BTW: I cannot afford the USD 99 right now either, but that is because part of my money is tied up in a trading account, and the monthly bills still need paying! I'll just bide my time until I do have the money to spend on the PF... If I do well, I'll earn back the money to pay for the next month(s), if not, I'll just return when I can... )
  • #83
  • Jan 19, 2006 6:07pm Jan 19, 2006 6:07pm
Quoting cici
Fiji has just given you some excellent advice, well worth heeding.

May I also suggest you consider taking a remedial mathematics course? The post did not say 39% satisfied. It said 39 people were satisfied and 0 (zero) people were not satistifed. That means all 39 people who voted were satisfied and that is 39 out of 39 which is 100% satisfied.

100% SATISFIED.
WOW thanks for the remedial mathematics course, but the thread he posted looks like 39%. It's not listed as 39 out of 39 but 39 out of 100%. With your attitude you should be hanging out over at moneytec. Thanks for the correction what do you do have stock in the PF?
  • #84
  • Jan 19, 2006 6:25pm Jan 19, 2006 6:25pm
Yup... let's do chill out a bit... Please be reminded that the objective of the PF is to help traders. and not make traders against each other...

I think the stress is just creeping in..

Take a break dudes.. Have a break.. Have a kit-kat..
  • #85
  • Jan 19, 2006 6:44pm Jan 19, 2006 6:44pm
here this might make it a ittle easier

the forum is good value for my money---------- 55 or 98.21% say yes

the forum is not good value for my money--------1 0r 1.79% say no

sorry for the confusion.
  • #86
  • Jan 20, 2006 11:10am Jan 20, 2006 11:10am
Quoting johns
WOW thanks for the remedial mathematics course, but the thread he posted looks like 39%. It's not listed as 39 out of 39 but 39 out of 100%. With your attitude you should be hanging out over at moneytec. Thanks for the correction what do you do have stock in the PF?
I'm sorry johns, you didn't deserve that. I was drunk when I wrote that, and when I'm in that state, I tend to be an asshole. Really.

Also, I had just finished reading the lies and false accusations on MoneyTec about the PF and it's instructors. I was in a pissed off mood from that and I happened to come on your post during that and so, perceiving your post as yet another attack, I posted the way I did. Still, none of that is an excuse.

In another vein, I see that James16 has updated the poll data and there is a single disatisfied customer. 1 out of 55. I know from the garbage thread on MT that some of the MT members are lurking here and then going back to MT to twist, distort and spew there trash. So I would imagine that those lurkers are now having a party, celebrating the single PF customer as *PROOF* that the PF is a scam and the instructors are all cheats. It is just like MT folks to totally ignore the 55 satisfied customers.

To be clear, I'm glad the MT'ers exists. We need someone to take money from....don't we?

BTW, I am not a member of the PF, nor do I have any interest in joining. But I do admire the instructors for what they are doing.
  • #87
  • Jan 20, 2006 12:17pm Jan 20, 2006 12:17pm
Quoting cici
I'm sorry johns, you didn't deserve that. I was drunk when I wrote that, and when I'm in that state, I tend to be an asshole. Really.

Also, I had just finished reading the lies and false accusations on MoneyTec about the PF and it's instructors. I was in a pissed off mood from that and I happened to come on your post during that and so, perceiving your post as yet another attack, I posted the way I did. Still, none of that is an excuse.

In another vein, I see that James16 has updated the poll data and there is a single disatisfied customer. 1 out of 55. I know from the garbage thread on MT that some of the MT members are lurking here and then going back to MT to twist, distort and spew there trash. So I would imagine that those lurkers are now having a party, celebrating the single PF customer as *PROOF* that the PF is a scam and the instructors are all cheats. It is just like MT folks to totally ignore the 55 satisfied customers.

To be clear, I'm glad the MT'ers exists. We need someone to take money from....don't we?

BTW, I am not a member of the PF, nor do I have any interest in joining. But I do admire the instructors for what they are doing.

your a nice person cici. if thats as mean as you get when your drunk then your way nicer than most people. jim
  • #88
  • Jan 20, 2006 1:00pm Jan 20, 2006 1:00pm
Quoting james16
your a nice person cici. if thats as mean as you get when your drunk then your way nicer than most people. jim

I never get drunk... B'cause I don't drink alcohol... (Don't smoke either, nor do drugs...)

Boring person, me... :

It *is* however a great way to ensure you're as little a bother to other people as possible.

If I did do either or all of the above, I might be able to get the money for the PF real quick by quitting tho, so there's the backside of it...
  • #89
  • Jan 20, 2006 11:03pm Jan 20, 2006 11:03pm
Quoting cici
I'm sorry johns, you didn't deserve that. I was drunk when I wrote that, and when I'm in that state, I tend to be an asshole. Really.

Also, I had just finished reading the lies and false accusations on MoneyTec about the PF and it's instructors. I was in a pissed off mood from that and I happened to come on your post during that and so, perceiving your post as yet another attack, I posted the way I did. Still, none of that is an excuse.

In another vein, I see that James16 has updated the poll data and there is a single disatisfied customer. 1 out of 55. I know from the garbage thread on MT that some of the MT members are lurking here and then going back to MT to twist, distort and spew there trash. So I would imagine that those lurkers are now having a party, celebrating the single PF customer as *PROOF* that the PF is a scam and the instructors are all cheats. It is just like MT folks to totally ignore the 55 satisfied customers.

To be clear, I'm glad the MT'ers exists. We need someone to take money from....don't we?

BTW, I am not a member of the PF, nor do I have any interest in joining. But I do admire the instructors for what they are doing.
Apology accepted. Thanks
  • #90
  • Jan 21, 2006 12:19am Jan 21, 2006 12:19am
Now, this is more like it..

Now give each other a hug..
  • #91
  • Feb 7, 2006 11:11pm Feb 7, 2006 11:11pm
I joined James16 PF today..

Let me brief my background first..I have ard 18 months of forex exp..have read many books, surfed tons of web pages, been a member of so many forums, have participated in many many chat rooms..

Being a newbie, I had done hours and hours of demos on so many systems (without sticking to one !). Being so exited with the intro of forex, I tried everything possible here...scalping, daytrading, swing trading, position trading..everything,everything I could...but could not stop blowing up my mini-live accounts several times..was very much frustrated and stopped thinking about forex for couple of months..

I came across these sentences one day..

Peter : Hey Tom, I had met many failures in my life so far...I'm really confused to choose now what is right for me in my life..Could you help?

Tom : Peter, I don't know what is right for you..But if you find it, nothing in this world would stop you doing that !!

My affection for Forex kicked me again to re-start the journey..I came across Vegas threads and started getting confidence. Then I came across James16 Public thread on Price action and was impressed by his stuff and more than that his attitude to help people so closely. When I heard about his PF, I was sceptical at first for a couple of days with my past experience on buying many e-books.

In my opinion, not all e-books are total crap...I had bought a couple of them which really had very good stuff..But what was lacking in all of them is their ability to guide you to implement that stuff to taste the success..If you are a really self motivated person who can control your emotions and need no external guidance, then all stuff required for succeeding in Forex is available for free in many places in the web. For newbies and for those who were not able to taste the success in forex, my belief is you need some one to guide you thru the process so that you can implement what all successful systems preach you.

Today being the first day in PF, I went thru the PA thread. Jim not only has put the essense of his hard experience, but has a very big attitude to help people to implement that..I like that aspect most.

Shan
  • #92
  • Feb 12, 2006 10:52pm Feb 12, 2006 10:52pm
my vot took this to 50%
Quoting PipGoddess
And my vote took it to 40!
  • #93
  • Feb 12, 2006 10:57pm Feb 12, 2006 10:57pm
what type of demo is best
Quoting vishalshan
I joined James16 PF today..

Let me brief my background first..I have ard 18 months of forex exp..have read many books, surfed tons of web pages, been a member of so many forums, have participated in many many chat rooms..

Being a newbie, I had done hours and hours of demos on so many systems (without sticking to one !). Being so exited with the intro of forex, I tried everything possible here...scalping, daytrading, swing trading, position trading..everything,everything I could...but could not stop blowing up my mini-live accounts several times..was very much frustrated and stopped thinking about forex for couple of months..

I came across these sentences one day..

Peter : Hey Tom, I had met many failures in my life so far...I'm really confused to choose now what is right for me in my life..Could you help?

Tom : Peter, I don't know what is right for you..But if you find it, nothing in this world would stop you doing that !!

My affection for Forex kicked me again to re-start the journey..I came across Vegas threads and started getting confidence. Then I came across James16 Public thread on Price action and was impressed by his stuff and more than that his attitude to help people so closely. When I heard about his PF, I was sceptical at first for a couple of days with my past experience on buying many e-books.

In my opinion, not all e-books are total crap...I had bought a couple of them which really had very good stuff..But what was lacking in all of them is their ability to guide you to implement that stuff to taste the success..If you are a really self motivated person who can control your emotions and need no external guidance, then all stuff required for succeeding in Forex is available for free in many places in the web. For newbies and for those who were not able to taste the success in forex, my belief is you need some one to guide you thru the process so that you can implement what all successful systems preach you.

Today being the first day in PF, I went thru the PA thread. Jim not only has put the essense of his hard experience, but has a very big attitude to help people to implement that..I like that aspect most.

Shan
  • #94
  • Edited Feb 13, 2006 3:29am Feb 12, 2006 11:07pm | Edited Feb 13, 2006 3:29am
Quoting mshz
what type of demo is best
Just my opinion though..
Demo with the broker you're planning to use when you go live.
This way, you're hitting two birds with one stone.. well I think that's
what I'll be doing..

The first bird is that you're able to demo your system.
And the second is that you're familiarizing with the platform..
So that when you do decide to start trading live, the transition will be easy.

So if the platform you plan to use is Metatrader 4, then go with the brokers using such platform (like InterbankFx, FXDD, etc.) there's a list here:
http://www.forexfactory.com/forexfor...6&postcount=10

Or you can do it the other way around, choose your broker first, then use their platform. For example, if you're planning to use Oanda as your broker, then go with their platform..

Please take note, this is just my opinion..

Hope this helps,
East
  • #95
  • Feb 13, 2006 3:22pm Feb 13, 2006 3:22pm
Quoting eastmaels
Just my opinion though..
Demo with the broker you're planning to use when you go live.
This way, you're hitting two birds with one stone.. well I think that's
what I'll be doing..

The first bird is that you're able to demo your system.
And the second is that you're familiarizing with the platform..
So that when you do decide to start trading live, the transition will be easy.

So if the platform you plan to use is Metatrader 4, then go with the brokers using such platform (like InterbankFx, FXDD, etc.) there's a list here:
http://www.forexfactory.com/forexfor...6&postcount=10

Or you can do it the other way around, choose your broker first, then use their platform. For example, if you're planning to use Oanda as your broker, then go with their platform..

Please take note, this is just my opinion..

Hope this helps,
East
which platform most member used to do trading, specialy james16th group.
any sujesstion please
  • #96
  • Feb 13, 2006 3:26pm Feb 13, 2006 3:26pm
I use FXCM Trading Station II and Intellicharts. Also use MetaTrader4 (IBFX) for some functionalities...
  • #97
  • Feb 13, 2006 6:06pm Feb 13, 2006 6:06pm
Quoting mshz
which platform most member used to do trading, specialy james16th group.
any sujesstion please
Okay, I'm not sure about this, but I think it's Metatrader 4 since it's free.
  • #98
  • Feb 13, 2006 9:01pm Feb 13, 2006 9:01pm
Quoting mshz
which platform most member used to do trading, specialy james16th group.
any sujesstion please
i use interbanks met4 and tradestation.
  • #99
  • Feb 14, 2006 12:30am Feb 14, 2006 12:30am
The best thing about interbank is micromini's.
Makes a $500 dollar account trade like a $50,000 dollar account.
You can apply the same strategies.!!
  • #100
  • Feb 19, 2006 4:26pm Feb 19, 2006 4:26pm
Quoting mshz
what type of demo is best
I use oanda for demo and live mini trading since it offers a very flexible position sizing. But I feel the charting facility is not that good in oanda. So I use Metatrader for charting.

Shan
0 traders viewing now