I am more than interested to join possible private forum (paid one ... of course ... right price) Your system works and helped me a lot!
If I Change, the whole World changes!
- #3,722
- Jun 30, 2010 8:12pm Jun 30, 2010 8:12pm
Hey guys, do you have some ideas how to improve this forum, what would you like to see here, or maybe private forum ( paid content, maybe videos or I have archive with very enought trades - images and comments ) or what do you think ?
I don't trade this particular strategy, but have followed all of ryanmcds posts and really appreciate that you have further elaborated and built up this thread. Good luck on the trading!
- #3,729
- Jul 1, 2010 3:40am Jul 1, 2010 3:40am
- Joined Feb 2009 | Status: Borderline yahoo & oh-no! | 6,607 Posts
.... ideas how to improve this forum, what would you like to see here, or maybe private forum ( paid content, maybe videos or I have archive with very enough trades - images and comments) or what do you think ?
but i see not enough reason for him to do a private forum.
-i mean no disrespect, but, he does not have a 'satisfactory command of the English language'. when one wants to do business, one needs to communicate well.
-the issue of time. i rarely see him post here. assuming the reason for his absence in his own thread, is that he trades...well, how can i be assured that he will give enough dedicated time for his potential business & that the fee will be worth it?
-i feel it's a disrespect for the originator of this method, Ryanmcd*, if jankone pushes through with his intent -- whether or not Ryanmcd allows it or not.
it's just like the james16 private forum which had former students break away & set up their own business teaching the same thing.
-the method presented here is TOO simple* to render a need to have a private forum. EVERYONE can use this method without a paid forum (everyone just needs chart time & practice).. if u noticed, the questions & answers posted here are very redundant.
if u are going to have an archive of charts/trades in a paid forum, what does that achieve? we already have many charts in this thread* & in FF as a whole.
a trader of this method does not need multiple charts showing the 'same thing'*; what he/she needs is to trade the 'same thing' multiple times.
in short, consistency.
if anyone does not understand this method using this free thread, it simply means he/she has not given ENOUGH time to read/understand/learn/practice what has been presented here. if so, then a paid forum is for u.
for those who understood the free content here, u dont need a private forum. believe me (& more importantly believe in yourself & inwhat u already know).
knowledge can be bought & sold ,but wisdom cannot.
the good thing is knowledge & wisdom can be planted & harvested
--- supremeChaos 
just my personal view.
*see part of your post#1 below
....
One man, changed my life, his name is Ryanmcd and this thread is dedicated to him, with humility, I'd like to continue, what he did start and I want to follow his way,....
what i said to Ryanmcd.
Sep 23, 2008 8:10pm... I want to train this as hard as i can.
you dont need to post anymore, because it's still the same point, over and over again! I realise this.
this trade was pretty close to the setup I use.
The only difference is : I don't trade if the pinbar is too small compared to the previous candles, just my way to trade but I definitively most be more flexible on this rule
I enter on pinbar range 50%fibs retracement. (Why do I enter this close to SL for reaching a big R:R ? Because I want to take profit of the In trend & pinbar pattern & confluence power).
Set stop loss above (for a short trade) pinbar (1 pip + spread).
My TP is the last top fractal.
I would have made 6R:R on this one +variable from trailing Stop.
The only difference is : I don't trade if the pinbar is too small compared to the previous candles, just my way to trade but I definitively most be more flexible on this rule
I enter on pinbar range 50%fibs retracement. (Why do I enter this close to SL for reaching a big R:R ? Because I want to take profit of the In trend & pinbar pattern & confluence power).
Set stop loss above (for a short trade) pinbar (1 pip + spread).
My TP is the last top fractal.
I would have made 6R:R on this one +variable from trailing Stop.
this trade was pretty close to the setup I use.
The only difference is : I don't trade if the pinbar is too small compared to the previous candles, just my way to trade but I definitively most be more flexible on this rule
I enter on pinbar range 50%fibs retracement. (Why do I enter this close to SL for reaching a big R:R ? Because I want to take profit of the In trend & pinbar pattern & confluence power).
Set stop loss above (for a short trade) pinbar (1 pip + spread).
My TP is the last top fractal.
I would have made 6R:R on this one +variable...
Those were good points supremeChaos, but still ... you have to look at it from newbies point of view. I have been studying FX for about 8 months and never was able to be really profitable. I paid for 2 "forex schools", tried signal providers etc. I learned a lot about MAs, pivots, trendlines, fibo, ellit waves, S/Rs etc ... but was never able to put it together. When I found Jankone I finally started making more good trades than bad ones! But still ... I have A LOT to learn because of my poor money management, slow decision making etc. And this is why I want to pay for additional education, access to archieve and maybe possible one to one chat. About language ... Jankone is from Czech republic and I am from Slovakia so we have almost the same native language And about Ryanmcd and James16 ... James is trading 4H timeframes and Ryan somehow dissapeared and it is impossible to contact him 
So best solution for me personally is Jankone. Why not pay him for his extra time?
And about Ryanmcd and James16 ... James is trading 4H timeframes and Ryan somehow dissapeared and it is impossible to contact him So best solution for me personally is Jankone. Why not pay him for his extra time?
- #3,735
- Jul 1, 2010 6:32am Jul 1, 2010 6:32am
- Joined Feb 2009 | Status: Borderline yahoo & oh-no! | 6,607 Posts
Those were good points... you have to look at it from newbies point of view. I have been studying FX for about 8 months and never was able to be really profitable....
Ryan somehow disappeared and it is impossible to contact him... So best solution for me personally is Jankone. Why not pay him for his extra time?
(if u read my post carefully, u will realize this)like i said, this method is simple. u just need to practice & experience it.
let me ask u,
-what questions can u ask in that possible private forum that u cannot ask here in this free thread?
-were all YOUR questions in this free thread UNanswered? point me to at least 1 question which got unanswered, i'll happily answer.
personally, i make time to reply to posts & to PMs (private messages). it takes time away from my trading, but it's in my nature to help.
i've made 4000+ posts & many PM replies (i only joined last year), that's a LOT of MY time spent... did i ask for or receive money for doing so?
i've replied to YOUR posts... did u have to pay me money for that?
-trading is a business. do u expect to learn & be consistently profitable within 8months? if yes, well IMHO u have an unrealistic expectation.
trading is a process. it takes time to learn; further, it takes some more time to be consistently profitable.
Ryan did not disappear. he still posts from time to time.
im not trying to compare myself with anybody. i just want to make a point that there is no distinct difference between free thread/proposed private forum & there's no valid & adequate reason to open a private forum.
i have already made my point, so this will be my last post on this subject.
if he pushes thru with a private forum, it's his prerogative.
if u want to pay money for something like that, it's your decision too.
SupremeChaos, I really appreciate that you answered all my questions and spent your time to help me without any financial reward. You belong to group of traders I respect. Without doubt ... I will be willing to pay you for private lessons too. All I need is to spend some time live with experienced traders to see how you think and what are your views on current market situation. It is different to "read" and to "see in action" .. at least for me
- #3,740
- Jul 1, 2010 7:18am Jul 1, 2010 7:18am
- Joined Feb 2009 | Status: Borderline yahoo & oh-no! | 6,607 Posts