The following are the first posts from a certain member asking for verification of claims made by other members (who in contrast were actually not soliciting or promoting a business here on Forex Factory).
I am asking for verification of claims (and to produce hard evidence) in the same way with the difference that I am asking for evidence of a real money business.
Quote:
Originally Posted by J.L.
I cannot reveal my method but if you read the forum next week I will have posted some very interesting stuff.
Hmmm, I decided to have a look at this...
Quote:
Posted by JL Dated 12 May
I believe the current upward movement is completed .I was Long Euro since 1.2081.Exited at 1.2880.
I went short 50% of my account at 1.2950 with 1/100 leverage.
Current stop loss is at 1.2950.
Target is at 1.2550.Let's see how it turns out...
1. Can you verify that you were long since 1.2081 ?? ...is this what they call "posting after the event" ??
2. There was a quick sell off after the market hit 1.2950...some time after that happened, you posted that you had gone "short" at 1.2950 ...is this what they call "posting after the event" ??
3. Why would you exit at 1.2880 if you "knew" it was going to 1.2950 ?
Would you please consider starting a "live time" journal in order for others to verify your statements, or alternatively, post your predictions before (rather than after) the events?
Jacko
...and another one:
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigballer
DOH !!!!
Boy I hate to be on your bad side......
hehe
Hi Bigballer,
There was no malice intended in the post....I just think that if you post something, then if necessary, you should be prepared to verify those statements.
Jacko
regards
daytrading
P.S. here are the links:
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...8216#post58216
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...8225#post58225
I am asking for verification of claims (and to produce hard evidence) in the same way with the difference that I am asking for evidence of a real money business.
Quote:
Originally Posted by J.L.
I cannot reveal my method but if you read the forum next week I will have posted some very interesting stuff.
Hmmm, I decided to have a look at this...
Quote:
Posted by JL Dated 12 May
I believe the current upward movement is completed .I was Long Euro since 1.2081.Exited at 1.2880.
I went short 50% of my account at 1.2950 with 1/100 leverage.
Current stop loss is at 1.2950.
Target is at 1.2550.Let's see how it turns out...
1. Can you verify that you were long since 1.2081 ?? ...is this what they call "posting after the event" ??
2. There was a quick sell off after the market hit 1.2950...some time after that happened, you posted that you had gone "short" at 1.2950 ...is this what they call "posting after the event" ??
3. Why would you exit at 1.2880 if you "knew" it was going to 1.2950 ?
Would you please consider starting a "live time" journal in order for others to verify your statements, or alternatively, post your predictions before (rather than after) the events?
Jacko
...and another one:
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigballer
DOH !!!!
Boy I hate to be on your bad side......
hehe
Hi Bigballer,
There was no malice intended in the post....I just think that if you post something, then if necessary, you should be prepared to verify those statements.
Jacko
regards
daytrading
P.S. here are the links:
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...8216#post58216
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...8225#post58225
Enter Signature