MACD and Constant Range Bars?

Hi folks,

I've seen evidence here and there that MACD looks considerably better when coupled with Constant Range Bars.

Does anyone know how to get MACD to actually appear on a CRB chart in MT?

I'm not talking about the default MACD indi that comes bundled with MT, I'm talking about the one where you can plot the histogram plus TWO moving averages ("two-line MACD").

I found some two-line MACDs, but they won't load when I drag them onto the "offline" CRB chart; they just flat-line.

If anyone has any experience, please advise.

-JR

hey jr.... it should work..... or at least it does on my end.....

there are several range bar indicators/methods, perhaps you are using an old version.... not sure...... might give the guys on the renko thread a holler......h

Hayseed, Constant Range and Renko bars are two different things.

But can you please upload your MACD indi - just in case it works for me!

Thanks
-JR

hey jr..... quite possibly i could be incorrect, but mathmatically speaking, they are the same..... of course, visually they are not.....

macd is most often based on the close..... the close should be identical for range bars and renko bars if applied at the same time and same size setting......

or at least that's how mine are written....... and again i could be mistaken in both my interpertation and math......h

Hayseed, you're a champ! Your MACD worked

Thanks for your help. Much appreciated.

-JR