C4 Scalping

Hi folks

What I've seen in this thread till now is not what Edge is trying to transmit till now.

What I've seen is that many folks are questioning his method, introducing new indicators and rules.

Edge knows what he's talking about (at least I think so) and maybe it doesn't come through clearly sometimes but he don't ask to "improve" his way to trade.

Let me tell you that I don't trade C4 but I'm watching it on a chart, this is another way to see PA and that is good so, but it doesn't mean that it fits everybodie's character.

Anyhow who want's to follow a thread starter should also follow his art or just skip to somewhere else.

I've seen Edge many times quiete pi$$ed off and he had all the reasons to feel like that 'cause stuff went out of what it should be.

Edge always said that there is no holy grail and who thinks that he can archive 95% is just one more stupid fool.

This thread wasted a lot of time with useless indi talks (hey DX, you are not included to that, you've done a good job ) and with that thread readers patience, I hope for Edge that the new thread will be free of those negative interventions.

When you post, try to analize negative trades, that's the only way to improve your skills with Edge, posts like "I'm done for today" or "I've got my 2%" don't help nobody.

Have a great and relaxing weekend everybody.

Good luck for the new thread Edge

Add: try to catch up what Edge means with the 75%

Cobra

hmmm. Aren't these your quotes in Frank's thread.


"Looks like the "Monster" got under Edgetrader's skin. When will the silliness cease?"
"What did FrankenPip steal? He doesn't use indicators. His signals happen before Edgetrader's."
"The "train" trades beat the regular "C4" trades."
"We get a long signal from the indicator, a green arrow, AFTER we collected our money. Maybe we should keep this a secret from the other thread."
"What this shows me is, we get on the train first and if we see their indicator telling them to get on the train, we can stay on the train for another 5 or more pips. Their "get on" indicator becomes our "stay on" indicator."
"Indicators are telling me to wait but the trains are running and making money."



You keep making fun of Edge and C4 scalper on Frank's thread and then come here and say let bygone be bygone. How Hypocratic.

You're the one who is doing the fanning around here. Don't make presumptions about who you think I might be referring to. I am making a serious point here. When I refer to indicator junkies I am also inlcuding myself. Now be a good bloke.

hi guys also from sunny coast mudjimba area was a shocking 30degrees today dam winter blues
sorry off topic but good to see locals having a go with trading

go

Hi all I have downloaded the indicators and all .will try it on a deo for some time to becoe proficient.In the meantime any suggestions for a broker for this type of trading.I have been stopped by IBFX once for scalping

Good post, nmaqba ......

Game Over, then, I think, gbppip. Better for all if you don't post on this (nor on Edgetraders forthcoming Nitro thread) again ..... I guess you'll agree, if you're an honorable and dignified person.

Everyone in this forum and in life can think what he wants of other people...can judge or not judge, can believe or not believe...but there are some "actions" that is better not to do...especially when a thread creator has more than one time asked not to do...

Why posting here charts relative to another strategy and another thread? This is wrong...i have never said nothing but i didn't feel good with that... it's a matter of respect...

I've never seen in this thread nobody denigrating or discussing about another thread's strategy...however this happens in another thread regading this thread.

...it's a matter of respect...

Who cares??
I've learned in my life not to bother, i look forward...i know who i have to follow and who should i trust...

I quite agree!

This is my boy

I agree with Cobra.
There is no miracle strategy or anything like to.All you need to do is to learn discipline, respect RRR and MM and you will have earnings money in the continuity, that is important thing in the Forex.

Remember this >

Why 95 % traders lost balance ?

1. They dont have discipline
2. They dont work on demo 6 months before live
3. They to much trust comments on forex factory and other forums
4. They often change strategy
5. They dont know the basics strategy,indis and Forex trading overall

Remember:

Renco candles are pure price in movment

They are the same pips that are moving on Any Time Frame

The Bricks progress on pips rather than time like candles do.

You really do not need time, necessarily, to see PA or be successul trading

You just think you do

Bricks are different and daunting in that way

Don't give up on either approach

Don't go from idea to idea, or escape to what you think is safe, or just someone elses idea.

Keep looking at what you want, C4 or Renco, and eventuallly your mind wll
give you the clarity you seek.

For me, that took days, for you 1min, for someone else 3 weeks.

Give it the time it takes, and do not give up.

If you cannot master this simplicity, you surely cannot try to escape to more complex strategies.

If you stick with it you will be successfull

Your brain needs time to work on problems you give to give you canswer

Give the computer in your head time

Be patient with yourself

Best Regards

Mate, I was doing an evaluation of the signals generated by the dashboard, the bomb meter and the "trains". Nothing wrong with that. Sounds like you want to stir up a hornet's nest, you cheeky bugger.

Do a search of "fancy indicators", Mate. No presumptions were made. I am a good bloke and fair one, too.

The game never ends, Mate, unless you quit. Don't know why your knickers are in a twist.

You should follow yourself, Mate. That's the best thing you can do.

This message is hidden because gbppip is on your Ignore List (http://www.forexfactory.com/profile.php?do=ignorelist).

Sorry, did you say something .......??

In other words, do what you understand and don't "follow the crowd". Took me a lot longer than most to get that through my head, but it is true. Everyone is different - but the thing I would REALLY like to see is - If you don't agree with the subject of the thread, either shut up or leave. There are a lot of us that are really learning, and trying to learn more.

Have a great weekend, and bring only a positive mindset next week!

Regards

Lets holster the sidearms and take a step back.


How about we try this. Will attempt to post this on 'Franks' thread also.

There is clearly no point to FF infighting via thread to thread salvo's. I am the one that jumped on 'Frank' for a question he presented on this thread. Whether or not it was a question that was 'loaded' or not is subject to interpretation. Not to mention if I was in a bad mood (not totally out of character for me). I used his advertising of his thread in this one as my igniter and, as in the opening scenes in the movie 'Gladiator', unleashed hell. That was definitely not the most professional response I could have summoned, but am a bit worn out lately. This FF thing is not the only thing on my plate. So, in the spirit of compliance to the FF mission statement, I will tender this cease fire proposal.

Yes, I did not like some of the postings 'Frank' made in this thread. However, as his own material garnishes more attention, his focus will obviously be to his thread followers. Have seen several individuals who have been in both threads posting this that and the other either here or there. Some have abandoned C4 and some are not grasping his own trading concept. That is not unusual at all. That is why FF has hundreds of trading systems to select from. Everybody is different.

As such, I will propose the following for consideration.

I too have read all the postings in 'Franks' thread. His thread currently has had postings alluding to seeking Twee's assistance perhaps in changing the threads name to something else. I think that would only be more confusing than than beneficial.

As his thread is an actual takeoff from my own C4 material, would it not be better to simply transition those interested in C4 over to Franks thread whereby they can possibly incorporate C4 into the his train station to station trading that is presented. I can easily edit my front page to attempt to provide some direction for such a transition. My C4 aspect, once I start my intended MT4 Nitro thread, are going to slowly but surely die a slow death anyway imho. Why not give FF patrons the choice themselves instead of wasting so much time and energy on BS?

Everyone (mostly) coming to the FF is seeking some manner of trading knowledge to act upon. Maybe 'Franks' trading methodology does indeed allow for and earlier entry. And perhaps by combining a couple of indicator aspects from C4 into his methodology, those folks can indeed extend their own TP levels a few pips or however they deem appropriate.

Every thread operator in general is deemed a 'joke' to some individual sooner or later. Just another numbers game there also.Especially in a public free forum like FF. While I do not feel as though I am a 'sheepherder' or some type of flame attracting moths, I am really not overly concerned with what a bunch of virtual cyber-individuals think of me. None personally know me and I know none of you. Could at some point in time be sitting at adjoining dinner tables enjoying life and none of us would ever know who is who.

I do have a targeted trading plan that I promote. My intent for my thread may have been chaotic at times, but the transition from one plan to another has always been by design. Just happened a bit sooner than expected. That too was my own fault for previewing Nitro. Regardless, we are where we are.

So, how about we just move forward with our respective efforts in relative peace and harmony. I have restored any posting privileges to those whom I deem party to this posting as both an olive branch and a professional courtesy. If such action has also been taken against myself, I will await some manner of third party word as to intent.

Regards.

I'm with you, Mate.

The golden gun has been holstered,
Thanks Sir Edge

Well said edge, and this truce can possibly be beneficial for the benefit of traders on these treads.
IMO there is merit in both trading systems.

At this time I am still on the C4 method but looking to the possibilities of the "Nitro" trading method. I expect to move over to the "other " method next week.

GLTA members