hey thanks for the commentary guys!! please keep it up as i dont have access to the room. have to sleep now and would like to know what happened when i get up tomorrow (aus) i love a good ff soap opera
strickly candlesticks now no line chart for 1 hour
Ignored
Lies ! That must be straight out lies because it's "black line only" according to shakes ! He's probably explaining to people how useless candles are ? That's what he must be doing I imagine.
by my count he is even when counting spread, when u take commissions into account b/c it is an ECN, he finished down for the day. I am not too impressed considering that he averaged 452 pips a day when he was not being watched...that is the point, who wants to watch everyday...Also, 90% of the time he was using Candlesticks, which he recommened not to use..The times he scalped he got burned, he was saved by the last trade by holding for more than an hour. Marsh what do u show?
That is so so right jigsaw.....not my opinion...but a follower of Shakes...on his thread...
Ignored
Ah, gotcha. Well with awesome conditions like these (Having a good day myself - albeit not to "Scalpin' the pip outta it" epic proportions) there should be no problem.
Jigsaw....you are proving a good point here....it just takes reading and thinking about the trading and you can find all those misleading statements BY Shakes.......The problem with his followers is..they can read....but jst not sure on the thinking part....
by my count he is even when counting spread, when u take commissions into account b/c it is an ECN, he finished down for the day. I am not too impressed considering that he averaged 452 pips a day when he was not being watched...that is the point, who wants to watch everyday...Also, 90% of the time he was using Candlesticks, which he recommened not to use..The times he scalped he got burned, he was saved by the last trade by holding for more than an hour. Marsh what do u show?
Ignored
First of all, I have no bias towards him, I am just collecting facts. Aside from the losing positions earlier, he is holding this profitable trade and is collecting good money from it, there is not denying that. As far as "scalping the pip outta it", as far as I am concerned he is not doing that. He took a few positions early on and cut his losses short, but is banking on this large trade to carry him into profit. Looks like any old short term trending system to me.
All I ask for is a chance to prove that money cannot make me happy.
First of all, I have no bias towards him, I am just collecting facts. Aside from the losing positions earlier, he is holding this profitable trade and is collecting good money from it, there is not denying that. As far as "scalping the pip outta it", as far as I am concerned he is not doing that. He took a few positions early on and cut his losses short, but is banking on this large trade to carry him into profit. Looks like any old short term trending system to me.
Marsh....your welcome here.....being unbiased is a good thing...you keep an open mind when your looking at other trading methods...you dont just follow in the hope maybe there is something....you like some facts to support and it might be hard for some to believe BUT that is all we on this thread have been asking for all this time...
Take my word for it - A Trading Journal
