Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Leftovers at the dinner table, re-testing opening levels 33 replies

Phillip Futures 4 replies

Phillip Nel Cliffnotes (shortcut) 4 hour system 9 replies

whats good for late night trading?? 7 replies

Late Night Channel Flipping ... and then some. 1 reply

Phillip's late night dinner table

Quoting saka
It is not until this morning that I knew the matter about Phillip. Just two weeks ago, my uncle left me forever because of the cancer. When I heard about the news about Phillip, the same feeling just appeared in my mind just like I knew that my uncle had dead already!

Phillip to me, is the lighthouse in my life. When I first came to FF and meet 4h treard, I just guratuated from college, and still on the way of finding the way of life. If there were not Phillip, I would have never dared to trade FX in reality. It is the great thread and strategy...
saka:

I'm very sorry to hear about your uncle and I wish there could have been a lot more that I could have done when you first contacted me.

I'm sure Phillip appreciates your words...
Phillip is indeed a class act. He will be sorely missed here. I too got a kick out of "riiight" at the beginning of each mp3.

I suspect tdion is jealous of Phillips success and praise.

Saka, my condolonces.
Quoting ForexTrader

I suspect tdion is jealous of Phillips success and praise.
I wouldnt go that far mate.

I am quite jelous though, 1000 x $50 = $$$$$

Id suggest Phillip has someone look over his website to correct the Grammar, mine is no where near perfect, but Im not trying to make some sales.
Living the adventure in my head.
give it up Leon....

...also hes not selling english lessons!!...and furthermore i hope he sells 10,000, he deserves it and those individuals who learn his stuff will benefit more than they give up,, much more (not sure if that was proper english but i'm sure Leon can correct that )

also it should be noted that no one has brought up the fact that Phils commercial ventures purpose was to raise money for his daughters volunteer work in South Afrcia...working with needy children....and u can imagine the urgent need for that there,i don't want to get into that, but people who keep posting negative comments need to be put in place....its not about picking a fight or ego (not ego bemac ) , i wouldn't bother posting but some things need to be put straight, and the truth be told ...
Quoting Leonlorenzo
I wouldnt go that far mate.

I am quite jelous though, 1000 x $50 = $$$$$

Id suggest Phillip has someone look over his website to correct the Grammar, mine is no where near perfect, but Im not trying to make some sales.

Don't completely discount the possibility... I think that may be the case.

I give him slack on the language thing because it's not his first language. I work with several South African's (Phillip is SA), and they all, like many other nationalities, make the same type of errors. I suppose if you live in SA and speak English, the grammar is perfectly correct! :-)

When I lived in England (I'm American) I was so frustrated with how long spell checking took because of "ize" vs. "ise", and other locale specifics. By time time I got used to it, I moved back. As long as I can understand the meaning, I don't mind grammar or spelling..... as long as it's not too bad.
Why would I be jealous of some stranger on the Internet? I've got plenty of things in my life keeping me busy than to be sitting around fantasizing about being Phillip Nell.

I simply made an observation, and think he acted childish that somebody wasn't impressed by his system.

He got buckets and buckets of praise from dozens of people.... he just doesn't get mine (except for his diligence.)

Quoting ForexTrader
I suspect tdion is jealous of Phillips success and praise.
hi everybody. I am a silent follower of the 4h macd thread for the last year.
now I became confident about the system and feel the rhytm and philip left. i am really sorry about that.

But i have a question to him if he can answer(maybe palmer or any other experienced ones, too). Because of my daily work I can not be in front of the screen during the day.

therefore I am planning to trade at us session (actually live at london time). but how about using 15min or 30 min timeframes?

another option is daily frame.

I am sure there is answer in the thread but searching in the thread , cant find any answer. what do you suggest?
  • Post #88
  • Quote
  • Edited Jan 16, 2009 12:23am Jan 15, 2009 11:44pm | Edited Jan 16, 2009 12:23am
Quoting draven
hi everybody. I am a silent follower of the 4h macd thread for the last year.
now I became confident about the system and feel the rhytm and philip left. i am really sorry about that.

But i have a question to him if he can answer(maybe palmer or any other experienced ones, too). Because of my daily work I can not be in front of the screen during the day.

therefore I am planning to trade at us session (actually live at london time). but how about using 15min or 30 min timeframes?

another option is daily frame.

I am sure there is answer...

If you want to trade 15 minute and 30 minute time frames with Phillip, you should check out his new website. I believe there is a forum too. I don't think he will post here anymore so you should email him via the website and ask him about his products yourself.
Quoting draven
how about using 15min or 30 min timeframes?

another option is daily frame.

I am sure there is answer in the thread but searching in the thread , cant find any answer. what do you suggest?
Draven...

Different trader trades in different time frame. I respect your intention about looking for a good entry in 15 & 30m, but my friend....any entry below h1 time frame is such a high risk trade. You should know why I say this.

You can master the h1 entry method taught by Phillip himself. Hope this advise helps....

"better be roughly right rather than be precisely wrong"
  • Post #90
  • Quote
  • Edited 3:32am Jan 16, 2009 2:59am | Edited 3:32am
Quoting tdion
Why would I be jealous of some stranger on the Internet? I've got plenty of things in my life keeping me busy than to be sitting around fantasizing about being Phillip Nell.

I simply made an observation, and think he acted childish that somebody wasn't impressed by his system.

He got buckets and buckets of praise from dozens of people.... he just doesn't get mine (except for his diligence.)
If you are not impressed with Phillip's method...why did you posting in this thread at first place? Such a waste of time....

If you had plenty of things in your life keeping you busy...why did you still posting in this thread anyway? Again...such a waste of time....

Your ego and arrogant went too far already. I have no idea why Phillip's method bothered you so much. Hey....if you don't like his method...just simply ignore it. I don't have to teach you that. Nobody will teach you that too.Don't be such a retart...JUST MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS....

I believe members in this thread as well as in FF site are trying to find and make friends each other... me and other members are not making ENEMY like what you did here....gossh...I bet you must have problem in you social life...

I tell you what...the more you post your comment here...the more meaningless it become for us...so either you should stop posting here or there will be many more members in this thread will give you a HEAD SHOT.

Anyway, I am not going to entertain you no matter what. Others will do the same too...

I'm done with you!!!!

Jeez...........!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Post #91
  • Quote
  • Edited 11:17pm Jan 17, 2009 2:29am | Edited 11:17pm
Member since.... December 2008 Not even here a month, and you're bossing me around like you own the joint.

Quoting orangeRANGE
If you are not impressed with Phillip's method...why did you posting in this thread at first place? Such a waste of time....
Why did I post here? Because I could

Why did I post here when I have things I could do in real life? I wanted to
Let me preface by saying that I have no experience with the system and as such have no opinion of it.

I understand that there are rules here to be followed or pay the consequences. What I don't understand is why he was banned but several other highly regarded members who offer paid services are not.
Quoting deuce
...
What I don't understand is why he was banned but several other highly regarded members who offer paid services are not.
http://www.forexfactory.com/faq.php?faq=rules#faq_rule3

FF allows acceptions to this rule as stated at the bottom of rule #3.

Also, FF is a business and operates as such. If Philip wanted to become a partner or advertiser I'm sure he could contact FF and operate through the established channels.

I have no affiliation with FF, but I took the time to explore the FAQ section at the bottom of the main page when I became a member. That's why I'm so smart!
Quoting draven
hi everybody. I am a silent follower of the 4h macd thread for the last year.
now I became confident about the system and feel the rhytm and philip left. i am really sorry about that.

But i have a question to him if he can answer(maybe palmer or any other experienced ones, too). Because of my daily work I can not be in front of the screen during the day.

therefore I am planning to trade at us session (actually live at london time). but how about using 15min or 30 min timeframes?

another option is daily frame.

I am sure there is answer...
Hi D

I already gave you an answer on possibly using the daily chart - please go back to the 4h MACD thread, it was a few page ago.

Enjoy the trading
Willem Forex recipe for success = Patience, discipline & hard work.
tdion is just a shit stirrer, he did the same thing in the Jacko thread
Grabbing the bull by the horns!
whitegoodman is really saying he doesn't believe that people should be allowed to have a different point of view than the majority.
Quoting tdion
whitegoodman is really saying he doesn't believe that people should be allowed to have a different point of view than the majority.
no i believe there should always be constructive criticism... just word it correctly so it doesnt seem rude
Grabbing the bull by the horns!
Quoting deuce
Let me preface by saying that I have no experience with the system and as such have no opinion of it.

I understand that there are rules here to be followed or pay the consequences. What I don't understand is why he was banned but several other highly regarded members who offer paid services are not.
I totally agree! If I understand it right Phillip was not even selling any products to do with the 4h system, who's thread has always had an air of honesty, totally deviod of marketing, but many others here are free to set up systems that are commersial spring boards from the onset, definately double standards.
Quoting whitegoodman
no i believe there should always be constructive criticism... just word it correctly so it doesnt seem rude
Bring it on bro....!!!!I support you....yeah....
I have read the 4 hour and 5 minute threads by Phillip. Not one time was he trying to sell anything to anyone. It was threads like the 4 hour system that made Forex Factory successful. The people who run this site should remember that.

It is good to have rules set in place to protect the integrity of the site. It is another thing to block someone from posting on a thread that has contributed a lot to the success of the site when he was not selling anything.

I don't want to start a fight but I am curious as to why the James 16 thread the person who clearly runs a paid place and recruits people all the time is allowed to keep posting? Don't get me wrong I love that thread as well but I am curious about it. Is it that James is part owner of this web site?

Good Luck Phillip your thread helped me a lot to develop a foundation to currency trading.
0 traders viewing now