The Bitter Truth About Forex Trading By Shigosag | Forex Factory

Options

Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

GOLD mohamad-java❤️ 9 replies

What would you do - Sweet possibility v.s. Bitter certainty? 11 replies

I hate forex - the truth about gains in Forex 86 replies

The truth about retail Forex brokers !! 33 replies

The Bitter Truth About Forex Trading By Shigosag

  • #1
  • First Post: Apr 12, 2026 4:27am Apr 12, 2026 4:27am
The Bitter Truth About Forex Trading (From Someone Who Tried to Make It Work) By Shigosag
I’ll keep this simple and honest.
Forex is not as easy as it looks online.
There are too many successful trader screenshots, signals, and strategies being shared, but very little talk about what actually happens when you try to make it work long term.
The Reality Most People Don’t Say
Backtesting can look perfect but fail in live market
Strategies that worked before suddenly stop working
The market doesn’t respect your analysis all the time
Consistency is much harder than it looks
You can spend months optimizing a system and still struggle when real conditions change.
About EAs and Strategies
Many people believe building an EA or strategy is the solution.
But here’s the truth:
Optimization can lead to overfitting
Past data not guaranteed future performance
Market conditions keep changing
Something that looks perfect in a backtest can fail in forward testing.
Psychological Side
Even if you have a system:
Sticking to it is hard
Doubt creeps in
Losses affect decision-making
Trading is not just strategy, it’s mental.
So What’s the Truth?
Forex is:
Not a guaranteed income
Not easy
Not consistent for most people
It requires:
Time
Discipline
Adaptation
Open Discussion
I’m not saying it’s impossible.
But I’m curious:
How many people here have actually found something that works consistently in live trading (not just backtest)?
Let’s hear real experiences.
— Shigosag
  • #2
  • Edited 2:20pm Apr 13, 2026 2:07pm | Edited 2:20pm
Hi Shigosag,

I understand this is your personal (bitter) truth. Unfortunately, there are a lot of misconceptions but it's not your fault, the reality is rarely ever discussed nor is it well understood.

Quoting Shigosag
Backtesting can look perfect but fail in live market
Strategies that worked before suddenly stop working
The market conditions changed. Every struggling trader is either ignorant of or just awful at analyzing market conditions.


Quoting Shigosag
The market doesn’t respect your analysis all the time
For most struggling traders, analysis = scanning for setups.

For pro traders, analysis =

  1. assessing market conditions
  2. trend analysis
  3. momentum analysis
  4. intermarket analysis
  5. risk-to-reward potential of a setup, i.e. potential upside vs potential downside of a particular setup = qualitative assessment of the setup
  6. etc etc etc


Quoting Shigosag
Consistency is much harder than it looks
For most struggling traders, consistency = consistent wins.

For pro traders, consistency = consistent process adherence

Quoting Shigosag
You can spend months optimizing a system and still struggle when real conditions change.
Which begs the question: why didn't the trader monitor the real conditions and adapt to the changes?

Quoting Shigosag
About EAs and Strategies Many people believe building an EA or strategy is the solution. But here’s the truth: Optimization can lead to overfitting Past data not guaranteed future performance Market conditions keep changing Something that looks perfect in a backtest can fail in forward testing.
If a trader can't trade manually, they will struggle with an EA and algo trading as well.

Quoting Shigosag
Psychological Side Even if you have a system: Sticking to it is hard Doubt creeps in Losses affect decision-making Trading is not just strategy, it’s mental.
Actually I'd say trading is 90% process, 5% strategy and 5% mental (psychological)

If you have a system but don't adapt it to market conditions, you're essentially trading blind => leads to random results => doubt creeps in.

Quoting Shigosag
Open Discussion I’m not saying it’s impossible. But I’m curious: How many people here have actually found something that works consistently in live trading (not just backtest)? Let’s hear real experiences. — Shigosag
I've been trading for more than 18 years and full time for over 5 years. Yes, it is possible but profitable trading isn't as exciting as many believe nor is it as simple as just finding the "right strategy with a proven edge". However the reality isn't what most people want to hear, otherwise they'd quit. So it doesn't get talked about much:

  1. profitable trading is about process, process, process (= staying several steps ahead of the evolving market and conditions).
  2. most of the time goes to analysis (not scanning for setups), waiting to enter and waiting to exit. Most people would find it very boring and lonely.
  3. the market (not the trader's strategy) determines if a trader wins and how much. The only thing a trader can determine is how much they will lose and when to enter / exit.
  4. The market will tell a trader everything they need to know as long as they listen and react.
  5. Struggling traders have an emotional attachment to money and become too fixated on their P&L, which hijacks their attention away from what the market is telling them.
  6. Pros usually have a genuine love and passion for analyzing markets and adhering to process, they'd probably do it even if there was no money involved. The actual buying / selling / entering / exiting positions is very boring, at least to me. The money is a nice bonus but not the primary motivation for most seasoned professionals.

  • #3
  • Apr 13, 2026 3:13pm Apr 13, 2026 3:13pm
Quoting CoffeeFreak
Hi Shigosag, I understand this is your personal (bitter) truth. Unfortunately, there are a lot of misconceptions but it's not your fault, the reality is rarely ever discussed nor is it well understood. {quote} The market conditions changed. Every struggling trader is either ignorant of or just awful at analyzing market conditions. {quote} For most struggling traders, analysis = scanning for setups. For pro traders, analysis = assessing market conditions trend analysis momentum analysis intermarket analysis risk-to-reward potential of a setup, i.e....

I know this off-context but I could not find a better situation to ask my question. Who know if I will find help.

I am a day trader but not profitable yet but lose lesser than before due to proper RIsk management (which I later discovered that it more of a life jacket to keep me afloat).I trade Price Action (Breakout and retest) But in all sincerity, I feel like I still don’t know what I am doing in the market.

I have seen some trader talk about obtaining data to know the win rate of the setup but I don’t know how to go about it. I don’t even know what data to find and how to use it as a trading guide.

please I need help. Ejor
You can be wrong half of the time and still make a fortune
  • #4
  • Apr 14, 2026 3:29am Apr 14, 2026 3:29am
Hey Vikolee (Ejor),

First of all, I'm not a day trader. Second, I'm not sure what you're asking because I don't see an actual question.

With that said, I can make some observations based on what you wrote.

Quoting Vikolee
{quote} I am a day trader but not profitable yet but lose lesser than before due to proper RIsk management (which I later discovered that it more of a life jacket to keep me afloat).
Yes, this is closely related to the 80/20 Pareto Principle, meaning 80% of a typical trader's profits will come from 20% of his trades. This means (typically) that 80% of his trades will be small wins, break-evens and losses. Therefore the trader must minimize his losses so that he can stay in the game long enough for those big wins (20%) to have an impact on his trading capital. Most beginners overlook this and usually end up blowing their trading capital.

Quoting Vikolee
{quote}I trade Price Action (Breakout and retest) But in all sincerity, I feel like I still don’t know what I am doing in the market.

Unfortunately, you are the textbook case of what I wrote above:

Quote
If you have a system but don't adapt it to market conditions, you're essentially trading blind => leads to random results => doubt creeps in.

You have a system (PA B&R), but are unaware of the market conditions => trading blind => random results => doubt creeps in (feel like you don't know what you're doing)

Before you can know what to do, you have to first know what the market is doing = market conditions

Quoting Vikolee
{quote}I have seen some trader talk about obtaining data to know the win rate of the setup but I don’t know how to go about it. I don’t even know what data to find and how to use it as a trading guide. please I need help. Ejor
I don't know of any available ready-made data that tells the win rate of a particular setup and I highly doubt any exists because the win rate depends more on when the trader exits than the actual setup.

OTOH, I do know of and use analysis techniques to determine the probability of a trend change and / or change in market conditions as well as determining the potential upside vs downside of a particular setup.

My guess is that you want to know how to spot the difference between a fake / real breakout and / or probability of the breakout being real vs fake.
If this is the case then the basic principle is the same as for any other type of trading: understanding and analyzing market conditions

Q: What is a real breakout?
A: Change in market conditions:

  1. from ranging conditions to trending conditions or
  2. change from bullish to bearish conditions or
  3. change from bearish to bullish conditions

So in order to know the probability of a real breakout, you need to analyze the probability of a change in the market conditions, breakout of a range / congestion zone into a new trend or trend reversal.

  • #5
  • Last Post: Apr 14, 2026 3:08pm Apr 14, 2026 3:08pm
It took me yesrs to become profitable and many accounts were blown away.

I'm profitable and using only horizontal support and resistance lines
0 traders viewing now