Gold investor trading | Page 19 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Related Instruments

Gold/USD

Similar Threads

Publishing Trading History using Investor Login ONLY 0 replies

The Absent Minded Investor - Adventurous Forex Trading Tales 32 replies

Investor login 1 reply

Analysis for the Longer Term Trader/Investor 1 reply

Attachments: Gold investor trading
Exit Attachments

Gold investor trading

  • #361
  • Nov 16, 2025 1:37pm Nov 16, 2025 1:37pm
Quoting Stedfastgamb
{quote} Thats not the point, it really doesn’t matter when you joined, what’s fake is fake. STOP DECEIVING PEOPLE
Why people so fast to misjudge (Specially new comer) , even looking at his abokwaik profile, one can see he has contributed generously and helped many here without anything in return.
Be Greedy
Dices Return This Week: na
  • #362
  • Nov 16, 2025 2:26pm Nov 16, 2025 2:26pm
Quoting Stedfastgamb
{quote} Man stop using different accounts to reply me, it’s not possible for a 0.01 Lotsize to put you in a $-21.46 loss and at the same time hit TakeProfit .. There’s is no way a TakeProfit line will ever be at a -21$ loss on a 0.01 Lotsize .. 21$ on a 0.01 Lotsize is nowhere close to break even, not to talk of loss .. Stop deceiving people
He is using Roboforex, on demo at least, which I believe offers 500 to 1 leverage, so that could be a problem.

Anyway, I think you are on to something; I thought it strange to report only Long winners, even on the biggest down day.

The only way to do that is hold the trades open; never paid much attention to the TE, but take a look -
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: 2025-11-17_6-18-54.jpg Size: 145 KB

Bring it on, 15:30 New York, Sunday.
It takes a lot for me to IGNORE you, but you can try.
  • #363
  • Nov 16, 2025 2:28pm Nov 16, 2025 2:28pm
Quoting AKCodingEye
{quote} Why people so fast to misjudge (Specially new comer) , even looking at his abokwaik profile, one can see he has contributed generously and helped many here without anything in return.
It’s wild of you to think because someone just joined this forum means they are new to trading, it’s even more wild of you to think because someone has contributed before means when they are wrong they cannot or shouldn’t be corrected, he wasn’t even the one that posted the thing I caught, but him coming to support it without any valid point will attract him being corrected. He might have been here for a while, doesn’t mean he cannot be corrected, you have no idea how long I have been trading. New here doesn’t mean new trader. All I asked is someone should tell me why this screenshot has a TakeProfit green color bar but has a $-21.46 loss recorded. He came here and said “It’s a normal thing” .. NO ITS NOT A NORMAL THING, INFACT IT CAN NEVER HAPPEN. that’s too wide. I also showed screenshots of what it looks like on the real chart. Especially with GOLD that has one of the tightest spreads in every broker. It’s obviously edited. It doesn’t matter how long someone has been here. If they support what’s wrong they should be corrected. I have proven all points, wisdom requires following but not blindly. PEACE!
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: IMG_2923.jpeg Size: 88 KB
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #364
  • Edited 3:55pm Nov 16, 2025 3:30pm | Edited 3:55pm
There are some arrogant people......

https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...6#post15472626
  • #365
  • Edited 5:38pm Nov 16, 2025 5:15pm | Edited 5:38pm
Quoting Gatuzzo
{quote} Cheers dude, I saw in another post you offering to show your approach on the forex market and I would be greatly interested in seeing that. Would be nice to be invited to one of the zoom’s. Although I have been studying for some years, I consider myself a newbie and sometimes I even struggle with drawing S/R lines or areas. Thanks for any support, wisdom or experience shared.
sent you link. dont share it

EDIT: sorry, tried to send link but you dont have messaging yet
gave you a shout. read it and get in touch. will add you to room. watch this weeks analysis first
  • #366
  • Nov 16, 2025 6:04pm Nov 16, 2025 6:04pm
Quoting Price
{quote} It is possible for a trade to be under water and to set a take profit that is also still under water. A stop can be in profit and a TP can be in a loss... is this all you got?? Strong words
Yes it is possible for a StopLoss to be in front of Entry price but it is not possible for a TakeProfit to be behind Entry price .. The markets are opened now, you can get it to see where $-21.46 StopLoss is on a 0.01 Lotsize and see how far it will take or what type of magic it requires for it to hit TakeProfit and Record a loss at the same time. You can also try putting your TakeProfit behind Entry price and let us know what happens. I’d be waiting
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #367
  • Nov 16, 2025 6:19pm Nov 16, 2025 6:19pm
Quoting Price
{quote} But what really pisses me off is the way you went into a respected members personal journal and started a delusional trash talk that you're totally wrong about.
Apart from that drama, FX 4 Money has presented himself as consistently profitable, but have you taken a look at the TE as I posted earlier?

Please do and explain that with math, thanks.

It takes a lot for me to IGNORE you, but you can try.
  • #368
  • Nov 16, 2025 6:52pm Nov 16, 2025 6:52pm
Quoting Price
{quote} Bruh, Stop with this, You are delusional. Lets try to help you through this. !. Enter a trade. 2. Trade goes a hundred bucks against you. 3. Set a Take Profit level for when it gets back to only minus 21 bucks. Opposite for Stops. Trade goes a hundred bucks your way and then set a STOP LOSS at plus 50 bucks. And your "0.01 Lot size".... 4144 to 4123 is 21 bucks. You failed at math But what really pisses me off is the way you went into a respected members personal journal and started a delusional trash talk that you're totally wrong about....
Man there is no need for us doing this back and forth, just as you have explained it now, go to your METATRADER and try it. Try putting your TakeProfit level somewhere between your Loss and your Entry point and see if it will stay. Then come back. Don’t explain, just go and do it and come back with proof.
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #369
  • Nov 16, 2025 7:20pm Nov 16, 2025 7:20pm
Quoting Price
{quote} Delusional. If you mean to set a take profit that is below the current price??? Yeah you can't do that. And no one did. Could you just explain what you are talking about. If a trade goes against you, you can absolutely set a take profit that will close in a loss. "Try putting your TakeProfit level somewhere between your Loss and your Entry point and see if it will stay" Yeah it stays. what are you talking about
You really have no idea .. Stay Blessed
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #370
  • Nov 16, 2025 7:41pm Nov 16, 2025 7:41pm
Quoting Price
{quote}If you're not going to explain what you're rant was even about then you should definitely just STFU.
You can see how carefully I have been choosing my words? Just points and facts. But when people don’t have points they always resort to insult that’s why all you have done so far was insult with no points, I said the markets are opened now, go and make what you explained to happen. Don’t come here explaining anything, just come with proof. But you came here explaining again. So you really DID NOT KNOW what this argument was all about in the first place then you just jumped in to support him?? As your Lord and Personal saviour that he is he cannot be corrected? once he’s wrong you fight for him still?. Well, if your Lord and personal saviour is wrong on our side we stand to correct him. He’s your own Lord and personal saviour not ours. Since you didn’t know what this argument was all about in the first place I think it’s you who should have just STFU instead. PEACE Though!
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #371
  • Nov 16, 2025 8:25pm Nov 16, 2025 8:25pm
Quoting Price
{quote} ok I looked at it.... what is there to see?? Only long trades is because the EA is set to only allow long trades. I've used this EA, it adds to trades and averages the TP. I'm not sure what you were pointing to in that TE shot. It all looks right to me
Sure, if it looks fine to you and you are used to holding drawdown like that, go for it.

I said before, strange that only phone screenshots are used to prove profits, when he must use an EA on a computer, just like this demo shows, and why not show the money, it's just a demo FFS, what's to hide?

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: 2025-11-17_12-17-37.jpg Size: 64 KB

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: 2025-11-17_12-21-17.jpg Size: 132 KB


He will be here to defend shortly, I'm sure!
It takes a lot for me to IGNORE you, but you can try.
  • #372
  • Nov 16, 2025 8:28pm Nov 16, 2025 8:28pm
Quoting Price
{quote} If you've got a point to make, please just make it. Everyone else can see that it is possible to put a TP below the open price and have it close negative. In 2 weeks and 20 posts you have presented yourself as a troll. Go away
Sometimes I wonder why y’all lie so much, someone has gone again to create a fake screenshot just to make us believe again .. But attached is a clean video I did just now, since all you have is screenshot edits, now let me see you bring a clean video proof that shows just like mine .. I’d be waiting

SEE ATTACHED TO SHOW YOU IN REAL TIME VIDEO OF HOW IMPOSSIBLE IT IS. DON’T MESSAGE ME AGAIN IF YOU DON’T HAVE A CLEAN PROOF LIKE THIS WHICH I HAVE PROVIDED. NOW LET EVERYONE SEE THAT ITS NOT POSSIBLE BASED ON THE VIDEO I PROVIDED. THERE IS NOTHING BEING A TROLL IN CORRECTING WHO IS WRONG NO MATTER WHO THEY ARE. Don’t forget to see video. PEACE!
Attached File(s)
File Type: mp4 1eb9ed71-d197-4e17-9a87-b4ba532df194.mp4   3.1 MB | 95 downloads
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #373
  • Nov 16, 2025 8:48pm Nov 16, 2025 8:48pm
Quoting Price
{quote}ok Stedfastgamb. I can see now that you have proven that it is not possible to place a stoploss above the current price. Thank you. But it is possible to have a trade go against you and after the trade has gone 50 points against you, it is then possible to set a take profit that is above the current price, but is still below the open. This would close a "green bar" TP in a loss to the account. That would show up as a GREEN BAR in front of a loss trade just like in his screenshots. You called that impossible, but this is where you are wrong....
There is no way $-21.46 will hit TakeProfit and at the same time record $-21.46 Loss on a 0.01 Lotsize. That distance is just too wide for GOLD, you can see in the video it’s only just $7 away from Entry price and you can see how far away it already is. Gold has one of the tightest spreads in the markets on any broker. There is no spread on gold that can ever be 21dollar much on gold at 0.01 Lotsize, not on any broker … Not even a $5 spread will be acceptable. Not even 2$ on gold at 0.01 Lotsize, the markets are there, you can always go and check and verify for yourself. -21.46 dollar is wild edit.
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #374
  • Nov 16, 2025 9:15pm Nov 16, 2025 9:15pm
Quoting Stedfastgamb
{quote} There is no way $-21.46 will hit TakeProfit and at the same time record $-21.46 Loss on a 0.01 Lotsize.
Sir.... if I may.... with respect, a 0.01 Lot size is one dollar per dollar in Gold. On this trade Buy Gold at 4144 and it falls to 4123, that is a $21 loss. So that math is correct at -$21.

Setting "TakeProfit" levels that, in reality, book "21 Dollar Losses" does sound kinda funny, I agree.... but lets look at the screenshot.

Trade opened at 4144 went badly.... so add double (0.02) at 4126... triple at 4116, again at 4113, and then add 0.05 at 4119.

OK, so we are now sitting at 4119 (+/-) and take profits are set to 4123.26 by the EA. All trades TP set to 4123 while the current market price was lower.

This is, as the OP already said, Totally Normal.

When the price of Gold moved higher again.... the TakeProfit levels of all trades triggered. Some in profit, some in loss.

Totally Normal.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Stedfastgamb.jpeg Size: 22 KB
  • #375
  • Nov 16, 2025 9:22pm Nov 16, 2025 9:22pm
Quoting Price
{quote} Sir.... if I may.... with respect, a 0.01 Lot size is one dollar per dollar in Gold. On this trade Buy Gold at 4144 and it falls to 4123, that is a $21 loss. So that math is correct at -$21. Setting "TakeProfit" levels that, in reality, book "21 Dollar Losses" does sound kinda funny, I agree.... but lets look at the screenshot. Trade opened at 4144 went badly.... so add double (0.02) at 4126... triple at 4116, again at 4113, and then add 0.05 at 4119. OK, so we are now sitting at 4119 (+/-) and take profits are set to 4123.26 by the EA....
There’s nothing normal about this screenshot, I wonder why you’ve been trying so hard to prove a wrong to be right .. Are you the one that posted it, are you controlling multiple accounts? Man no need for too much talking just show video of what you’re explaining .. That’s all.
Expert Advisor Link : https://http://bit.ly/4jHlz5L
  • #376
  • Nov 16, 2025 10:48pm Nov 16, 2025 10:48pm
Quoting Stedfastgamb
{quote} Man stop using different accounts to reply me, it’s not possible for a 0.01 Lotsize to put you in a $-21.46 loss and at the same time hit TakeProfit .. There’s is no way a TakeProfit line will ever be at a -21$ loss on a 0.01 Lotsize .. 21$ on a 0.01 Lotsize is nowhere close to break even, not to talk of loss .. Stop deceiving people
lmaooo believe whatever you want dude. you can try it on your own with a small lot size.
  • #377
  • Nov 17, 2025 2:50am Nov 17, 2025 2:50am
Quoting Stedfastgamb
{quote} There is no way $-21.46 will hit TakeProfit and at the same time record $-21.46 Loss on a 0.01 Lotsize. That distance is just too wide for GOLD, you can see in the video it’s only just $7 away from Entry price and you can see how far away it already is. Gold has one of the tightest spreads in the markets on any broker. There is no spread on gold that can ever be 21dollar much on gold at 0.01 Lotsize, not on any broker … Not even a $5 spread will be acceptable. Not even 2$ on gold at 0.01 Lotsize, the markets are there, you can always go...
EA will automatically move TP to another TP when EA opens many different orders but still maintains profit. But when running EA version V4, I see that it will open buy and sell at candles close to each other, so I don't understand the logic of this EA.
  • #378
  • Nov 17, 2025 5:13am Nov 17, 2025 5:13am
Quoting Stedfastgamb
{quote} Sometimes I wonder why y’all lie so much, someone has gone again to create a fake screenshot just to make us believe again .. But attached is a clean video I did just now, since all you have is screenshot edits, now let me see you bring a clean video proof that shows just like mine .. I’d be waiting SEE ATTACHED TO SHOW YOU IN REAL TIME VIDEO OF HOW IMPOSSIBLE IT IS. DON’T MESSAGE ME AGAIN IF YOU DON’T HAVE A CLEAN PROOF LIKE THIS WHICH I HAVE PROVIDED. NOW LET EVERYONE SEE THAT ITS NOT POSSIBLE BASED ON THE VIDEO I PROVIDED. THERE IS NOTHING...
Here's a proof vedio. ENJOY!

Attached File(s)
File Type: mp4 17.11.2025_14.07.53_REC.mp4   3.8 MB | 121 downloads


P.S. This was done for the benefit of the community not the qouted user.
No guts, no glory
  • #379
  • Nov 17, 2025 5:18am Nov 17, 2025 5:18am
Summary: The guy thought that a "Take Profit" order can not close in financial loss.

unless.... it is inside the spread. ( 2 tick gain with a 5 tick spread = loss)

Not able to understand that, after the trade is 31 bucks under water, you can set a TakeProfit that is 10 bucks higher than the current price (still $21 below the open).
This resulted in a GreenBar TakeProfit with a $21 (210 pip) Loss.

And, it doesn't matter that I've been a member over 18 years and he didn't last 18 days.... but

He has been banned from here.
The End.
  • #380
  • Nov 17, 2025 5:28am Nov 17, 2025 5:28am
Quoting Price
Summary: The guy thought that a "Take Profit" order can not close in financial loss. unless.... it is inside the spread. ( 2 tick gain with a 5 tick spread = loss) Not able to understand that, after the trade is 31 bucks under water, you can set a TakeProfit that is 10 bucks higher than the current price (still $21 below the open). This resulted in a GreenBar TakeProfit with a $21 (210 pip) Loss. And, it doesn't matter that I've been a member over 18 years and he didn't last 18 days.... but He has been banned from here. The End.

I can also confirm that I can put a TP order in a loss operation. For me it allows me. I don’t know that having a demo account influences that or why does anyone does that (putting a SL order makes more sense) but the fact is that is possible. Maybe on his account he couldn’t. I haven’t seen the videos, so I don’t know what to expect. My question is, is banning the right path here? Maybe he’s just convinced that he can’t because on his side he really can’t.

This is my only account. I just started to get more engaged in the forum because I’m taking trading forex (specially) more serious.
2 traders viewing now