Trade Copier Technology

I am looking for a reliable Trade Copier, other than the FX Blue Personal Trade Copier. Would anyone have any personal experience?

The criteria:
1. Reliable, seamless, quick, all the good stuff
2. Must be able to copy MT4 -> MT5 and MT5 -> MT4
3. If possible, it must NOT add magic number when copying because we are manual traders and we do not want MQL5 signals showing it as "algo" trading.

Thanks in advance

Not matter the magic number ... A trade opened by an EA is seen by brokers as auto-trading.

Okay thanks, for the input on #3.

Anyone else can recommend alternative trade copier software to address #1 and #2?

I don't think FX Blue Personal Trade Copier can copy MT4 -> MT5, or MT5 -> MT4, is that correct? I have not found the documentation for it.

You could have a look at mt4copier from Rimantas Petrauskas.