Chat GPT generated code not working in the backtester

Hi traders
I have tryed the Chat GPT to write a code for me, but I cannot get it to work in the backtester. As I do know nothing about coding, I hope you will look at it and tell me whats wrong with it. It seems and sounds as if it have coded for me what I have told it to do, but something have went wrong. Maybe it have coded it in old version of mql4, or that the code is incomplete because any reason, but since I do not know anything about coding I might have considered it done.
Will appreciate any help of you.

// User input parameters
input int MagicNumber = 12345;
input int WaitingPips = 50;
input double LotSize = 0.1;
input int FixStopLoss = 0;
input int FixTakeProfit = 0;
input bool MoneyManagement = true;
input double BalanceValue = 1000;
input double SLPercentage = 10;
input double TPPercentage = 10;
// Global variables
int ticket;
double stopLoss;
double takeProfit;
// Entry conditions
bool CanOpenTrade()
{
// Check if the market has moved long or short by the number of waiting pips
double waitingPipsPrice = WaitingPips * Point;
if (Bid > waitingPipsPrice && Ask > waitingPipsPrice)
return true;
if (Bid < -waitingPipsPrice && Ask < -waitingPipsPrice)
return true;
return false;
}
// Calculate stop loss and take profit
void CalculateSLTP()
{
// Calculate stop loss and take profit based on percentage of waiting pips
stopLoss = WaitingPips * SLPercentage / 100 * Point;
takeProfit = WaitingPips * TPPercentage / 100 * Point;
}
// Trade management functions
void OpenTrade(string tradeType)
{
// Calculate stop loss and take profit
if (FixStopLoss > 0)
stopLoss = FixStopLoss * Point;
if (FixTakeProfit > 0)
takeProfit = FixTakeProfit * Point;
else
CalculateSLTP();
// Calculate lot size
double lots;
if (MoneyManagement)
{
double risk = (stopLoss / Point) * LotSize;
double riskPerTrade = BalanceValue * 0.01;
lots = riskPerTrade / risk;
}
else
lots = LotSize;
// Open trade
ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), tradeType, lots, Ask, 3, stopLoss, takeProfit, "My Expert Advisor", MagicNumber, 0, Green);
if (ticket < 0)
Print("Error opening trade: ", GetLastError());
}
void CloseTrade(int ticket)
{
if (OrderClose(ticket, OrderLots(), OrderClosePrice(), 3))
Print("Trade closed successfully");
else
Print("Error closing trade: ", GetLastError());
}
// Expert Advisor function
void OnTick()
{
// Check if there are open trades
int totalTrades = OrdersTotal();
if (totalTrades > 0)
{
// Loop through all trades
for (int i = 0; i < totalTrades; i++)
{
// Get trade information
OrderSelect(i, SELECT_BY_POS);
if (OrderMagicNumber() == MagicNumber)
{
// Close trade if it is in profit or loss
if (OrderProfit() > 0 || OrderProfit() < 0)
CloseTrade(OrderTicket());
}
}
}
// Check if a new trade can be opened
if (CanOpenTrade())
{
// Check

i was aslo checking the openAI but chatGPT is not yet able to write error-free mq4 codes.

But can anyone check if this is not finished yet and therefor it will not load up in the backtester, or it is filled with coding errors

Hi
At first glance, this code is incomplete. Upload it all as a file or between code and /code tags.
I recommend this thread here on the site.

[quote=jacem;14282282]

Thanks. So you can see it is not complete. Well, I try to get the bot to code it since it will be very amazing if this can be done. I tryed to write here in this community and in the thread you mentioned earlier, but could not find solutions to my ideas. And also I have many ideas to play with. So it will be very useful if I could get the Chat GPT to do the job.
So do you guys have ideas to how I have to deal with it? May be will it be helpful if I give my orders to the bot peace for peace, and soon collect all the peaces into one?

Here is another code. I tryed with the bot several modifications. It insist that this is a complete code.
This EA uses a SMA and RSI to generate trading signals and also uses stop loss and take profit levels when placing orders. It uses the close prices for the calculation of both indicators and exits trades when the RSI goes above 70 for a buy position or below 30 for a sell position.

//--- input parameters
extern int SMA_Period=50;
extern int RSI_Period=14;
extern double RSI_Level=30.0;
//--- global variables
double sma;
double rsi;
int stopLoss=30; //pips
int takeProfit=70; //pips
//--- initialize the indicator values
int OnInit()
{
sma=iMA(NULL,0,SMA_Period,0,MODE_SMA,PRICE_CLOSE);
rsi=iRSI(NULL,0,RSI_Period,PRICE_CLOSE);
return(INIT_SUCCEEDED);
}
//--- check for a new tick
void OnTick()
{
sma=iMA(NULL,0,SMA_Period,0,MODE_SMA,PRICE_CLOSE);
rsi=iRSI(NULL,0,RSI_Period,PRICE_CLOSE);
if(sma > sma[1] && rsi < RSI_Level)
{
//Place a buy order
int ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_BUY,Lot,Ask,3,Ask-stopLoss*Point,Ask+takeProfit*Point,NULL,0,0,clrGreen);
if(ticket>0)
{
Print("Buy Order placed, Ticket# ",ticket);
}
}
else if(sma < sma[1] && rsi > 70)
{
//Place a sell order
int ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_SELL,Lot,Bid,3,Bid+stopLoss*Point,Bid-takeProfit*Point,NULL,0,0,clrRed);
if(ticket>0)
{
Print("Sell Order placed, Ticket# ",ticket);
}
}
//Exit strategy
for(int i=0; i<OrdersTotal(); i++)
{
if(OrderSelect(i,SELECT_BY_POS,MODE_TRADES))
{
if(OrderType()==OP_BUY && rsi > 70)
OrderClose(OrderTicket(), OrderLots(), MarketInfo(OrderSymbol(),MODE_BID), 3, clrGreen);
if(OrderType()==OP_SELL && rsi < 30)
OrderClose(OrderTicket(), OrderLots(), MarketInfo(OrderSymbol(),MODE_ASK), 3, clrRed);
}
}
}


So is it really complete? Can this be compiled? Or it is me that do not understand what compiling is? I am just copying and pasting it in mt4 editor and then save it and compiling it by clicking on compile from the file menu and closing the editor. I go to the expert folder to find only a mq4 file and not an x4.
Any ideas?

Can you share the exact prompt which you fed into chatgpt? I will see if I can get it to work. I have noticed that chatgpt generates code with a lot of coding errors, but it is quite easy to rectify.

I think your second code is not incomplete, it's just syntactically wrong.
I don't know much about MQL5, but I see that the AI seems to mix MQL4 and MQL5 commands.

[quote=barnarn;14282845]{quote}

Sure. It was more of a conversation between me and the bot. I will try copy and paste all of my inputs here and skip some of the first answers from the bot and copy only the important of them that have affected the strategy building:
"
Ali Alaarajy:
Lets talk about forex and how I can build a strategy for my own

Ali Alaarajy:
Yes, tell me about indicators

Ali Alaarajy:
ok how can I build a strategy using three indicators for buy and sell signals. And others for stop loss or and take profit

Ali Alaarajy:
Ok, how can a moving averige indicator identify the overall trend

Ali Alaarajy:
How can I use the sma indicator

Ali Alaarajy:
Ok, can we use this with the rsi also

Ali Alaarajy:
So out of what you told me let us create a strategy

Chat GPT:
Sure, let's create a strategy using the Simple Moving Average (SMA) and the Relative Strength Index (RSI) indicators:
1.
Identify the trend: Use a 50-period SMA to identify the overall trend of the currency pair. When the SMA is trending upward, it indicates an uptrend, and when it's trending downward, it indicates a downtrend.
2.
Identify overbought and oversold conditions: Use the RSI to identify overbought and oversold conditions. Typically, readings above 70 indicate overbought conditions, while readings below 30 indicate oversold conditions.
3.
Generate buy and sell signals: When the 50-period SMA is trending upward and the RSI is below 30, generate a buy signal. Conversely, when the 50-period SMA is trending downward and the RSI is above 70, generate a sell signal.
4.
Exit strategy: If you enter a long position when the 50-period SMA is trending upward and the RSI is below 30, you might consider exiting the position if the RSI rises above 70 as it may indicate an overbought condition. For short positions, one could consider exiting when the RSI falls below 30, indicating an oversold condition.
5.
Risk Management: It's also important to have a sound risk management plan in place. This could include setting stop-losses to limit potential losses and carefully allocating your trading capital.
6.
Backtesting: As with any strategy, it's important to test it on historical data before using it in live trading. This can help to evaluate its performance in the past and give you a better idea of how it might perform in the future.
Please note that this is a basic example of a strategy using SMA and RSI, and there are many variations and additional indicators that can be used to confirm signals and fine-tune the strategy. Always keep in mind that no strategy can predict the market with 100% accuracy and that discipline and risk management are crucial to success in trading.
Let me know if you have any question or any other aspect of the strategy you would like me to cover.

Ali Alaarajy:
Make this to an ea

Chat GPT:
An EA, or expert advisor, is a type of software that can be used to automate trades in the forex market. Creating an EA based on a trading strategy that uses the Simple Moving Average (SMA) and the Relative Strength Index (RSI) indicators is a relatively straightforward process that can be done using a software development platform such as MetaTrader 4 or 5, which provides the ability to create custom indicators and EAs.
Here is an example of how the strategy we discussed earlier could be implemented in an EA:
1. Identify the trend: Use the iMA() function to calculate the 50-period SMA of the currency pair and store the value in a variable. Use the value of this variable to identify the overall trend of the currency pair. When the SMA is trending upward, it indicates an uptrend, and when it's trending downward, it indicates a
downtrend.
2.
Identify overbought and oversold conditions: Use the iRSI() function to calculate the RSI of the currency pair and store the value in a variable. Use the value of this variable to identify overbought and oversold conditions. Typically, readings above 70 indicate overbought conditions, while readings below 30 indicate oversold conditions.
3.
Generate buy and sell signals: Use the trend and overbought/oversold conditions identified in steps 1 and 2 to generate buy and sell signals. For example, if the trend is upward and the RSI is below 30, then generate a buy signal. Conversely, if the trend is downward and the RSI is above 70, then generate a sell signal.
4.
Exit strategy: Add a set of conditions to exit positions using the RSI, for example if a long position is open and the RSI rises above 70 then close the position, as it may indicate an overbought condition. For short positions, you could use the RSI falling below 30 as an exit condition, indicating oversold conditions.
5.
Risk management: Implement risk management measures, such as setting stop-loss levels and limiting the amount of capital allocated to each trade.
6.
Backtesting: Backtesting the EA on historical data can be done by importing the data into the development platform, and using the built-in backtesting capabilities to test the performance of the EA.
Keep in mind that creating an EA require knowledge in programming and testing, it's also worth noting that an EA cannot guarantee profits, it is also subject to the same market volatility and uncertainty as manual trading, so it's important to continually monitor the performance of the EA and make adjustments as necessary.
Please let me know if you have any further questions or need more information on creating an EA.

Ali Al-aarajy
Ok, please make it to an expert using mql4

Chat GPT:
I'd be happy to help you create an EA using the MQL4 programming language for MetaTrader 4 platform. Here is an example of how the strategy we discussed earlier could be implemented in an EA using MQL4:

"

And then I kept tell it to finish up when the code seems to stop flowing out of the system because of the load. And then I told it several times about it will not compile and it gave me only informations and tips about how to compile it.
All in all thats all for getting this code. But it will not work.

I don't know. But it will be really amazing if we could get it to do the job. Especially for some one like me with tons of ideas that I am sure that they are not working, but I just want to test them out.

I will try to make my instructions paragraphs and fed them to the bot one by one. Or may be I will just use as little words as possible since this might confusions.
I hope if anyone have ideas to do this better.

The code is wrong, you can't expect that ChatGPT gives you code to plug into mql4 or anything else. You need to understand what you are doing first, if you aren't a programmer, stop wasting your time with this, because this tool can be an aid for a programmer, but it doesn't substitute one.

Ok, thanks man! Your comment made me tell the bot to use only mql4 and not mixing up with other coding languages. And it did it. Finally I got something I could compile.
Also I have noticed that when I copy and paste code peaces I have extra lines. I deleted them and could find another to compile and so on.
Seems that the bot can give something to be compiled but not garanteed that it will do what I requested.
Anyway I will continue the playing around with this bot.
This is a good new year gift to me that I found someone to code for me per my request. Let see if I succeed in making something useful out of it.
Of course any advice and comments from you will be helpful.

Hi, you can compile this code. But be careful, you have to limit the number of allowed trades:
//-----------------------

//--- input parameters
extern int SMA_Period=50;
extern int RSI_Period=14;
extern double RSI_Level=30.0;
//--- global variables
double sma;
double sma1;
double rsi;
double Lot = 0.01;
int stopLoss=30; //pips
int takeProfit=70; //pips
//--- initialize the indicator values
int OnInit()
{
return(INIT_SUCCEEDED);
}
//--- check for a new tick
void OnTick()
{
sma=iMA(NULL,0,SMA_Period,0,MODE_SMA,PRICE_CLOSE,0);
rsi=iRSI(NULL,0,RSI_Period,PRICE_CLOSE,0);
sma1=iMA(NULL,0,SMA_Period,0,MODE_SMA,PRICE_CLOSE,1);

if(sma > sma1 && rsi < RSI_Level)
{
//Place a buy order
int ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_BUY,Lot,Ask,3,Ask-stopLoss*Point,Ask+takeProfit*Point,NULL,0,0,clrGreen);
if(ticket>0)
{
Print("Buy Order placed, Ticket# ",ticket);
}
}
else if(sma < sma1 && rsi > 70)
{
//Place a sell order
ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(),OP_SELL,Lot,Bid,3,Bid+stopLoss*Point,Bid-takeProfit*Point,NULL,0,0,clrRed);
if(ticket>0)
{
Print("Sell Order placed, Ticket# ",ticket);
}
}
//Exit strategy
for(int i=0; i<OrdersTotal(); i++)
{
if(OrderSelect(i,SELECT_BY_POS,MODE_TRADES))
{
if(OrderType()==OP_BUY && rsi > 70)
OrderClose(OrderTicket(), OrderLots(), MarketInfo(OrderSymbol(),MODE_BID), 3, clrGreen);
if(OrderType()==OP_SELL && rsi < 30)
OrderClose(OrderTicket(), OrderLots(), MarketInfo(OrderSymbol(),MODE_ASK), 3, clrRed);
}
}
}

//-----------------------

[quote=IAmRetep;14283341]

Thanks for your help. But did you find many errors in the code? I want to figure out how the bot is dealing with such type of instructions, and why it code such errors.

Here is the functioning code:

void OnTick(){
// Trend identification
double sma50 = iMA(NULL, 0, 50, 0, MODE_SMA, PRICE_CLOSE, 0);
// Overbought/oversold identification
double rsi = iRSI(NULL, 0, 14, PRICE_CLOSE, 0);
// Risk management
double riskPercent = 2; // 2% risk per trade
double accountBalance = AccountBalance();
double stopLoss = 200; // set stop loss at 20 pips
double takeProfit = 500; // set take profit at 50 pips
double tradeAmount = accountBalance / 10000; // calculate trade amount based on risk percentage
// Entry
if (sma50 > iClose(NULL, 0, 1) && rsi < 30) {
// Generate buy signal
OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_BUY, tradeAmount, Ask, 3, Bid - stopLoss * Point, takeProfit * Point, "My EA", 0, 0, Green);
} else if (sma50 < iClose(NULL, 0, 1) && rsi > 70) {
// Generate sell signal
OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_SELL, tradeAmount, Bid, 3, Ask + stopLoss * Point, takeProfit * Point, "My EA", 0, 0, Red);
}
// Exit strategy
for (int i = 0; i < OrdersTotal(); i++) {
if (OrderSelect(i, SELECT_BY_POS, MODE_TRADES)) {
if (OrderType() == OP_BUY && rsi > 70) {
// Close long position
OrderClose(OrderTicket(), OrderLots(), Ask, 3, Red);
} else if (OrderType() == OP_SELL && rsi < 30) {
// Close short position
OrderClose(OrderTicket(), OrderLots(), Bid, 3, Green);
}
}
}
}

Please note that it may require some adjustment to meet your needs - but it is functional now.

Cheers

[quote=aalaarajy;14283357] Perhaps the easiest way to test and debug the MQL4 program written by 'chat-gpt' is:
- you copy the code written by the robot into a file with mq4 extension (in the appropriate directory)
- you open it with the metaeditor program
- press F7 and the list of errors/warnings can be seen in the terminal window

The lines starting with ' // ' are only comments, they are not included in the program.
This 'chat-gpt' world is interesting. It has only appeared recently, and many people are already afraid of it. However, it is certain that you will become smarter and will perhaps be of more help to you in writing forex robots in the future.

I hope I could help

Thanks to you all for your great help. All the previous codes I have provided was just to find out why the Chat GPT will not provide me codes that is ready to be compiled even if they are not doing exactly what I want of them. This could be because I have not told the bot my thoughts and instructions propperly. But that it give me codes that not will be compiled is the problem.

Today I have tryed to be more specific and asked of the Bot to make me a code I really want. Here I will provide you with the instructions that I fed to the bot, and what the ea supposed to do acording to what the bot have understood from my instructions, and then the code it have provided me with, and that again will not be compiled.

"
Ali Al-aarajy
Please create for me an expert adviser using mql4 language only.
The EA have to trade buy and sell as soon as it runs. It have to avoid open more than one buy and one sell at the same time.
Wehn the buy hit the TP it have to wait until the market continue up same tp value and then again place a buy. And keep doing that over and over same rule, take the tp of the buy and then wait same tp value before again placing the buy. Keep doing this as long as the market have not went down to the breakeven of the sell
When the buy hit tp and the market do not go up same tp value but begin going down, it have to place buy again if the sell become breakeven. And again apply same rule about the tp.
Wehn the sell hit the TP it have to wait until the market continue down same tp value and then again place a sell. And keep doing that over and over same rule, take the tp of the sell and then wait same tp value before again placing the sell. Keep doing this as long as the market have not went up to the breakeven of the buy
When the sell hit tp and the market do not go down same tp value but begin going up, it have to place sell again if the buy become breakeven. And again apply same rule about the tp.
Wehn either the sell or buy reach more than the user defined level begin to calculate how many the market have to go back down or up before the buy or sell get placed again. So it will be the tp * user defined level. This is the pips number for how many pips the market have to go either up or down before either sell or buy get placed back.
The eas user input have to consist of lot size, magic number, tp, sl, spred, slippage, levels, money management true or false. If true then use the lot size for every balance value. A balance value. If false then use the lot size as fixed lot.
The ea have to find out the broker digits.

Chat GPT
Sure, here is an example of an Expert Advisor (EA) in MQL4 that should meet your requirements:
It's important to keep in mind that this code is only a starting point, and it will likely require adjustments to work correctly with your specific use case. You should test it on a demo account before using it on a live account.
- The EA uses the `OnTick()` function which is called every time the price on the chart changes.
- EA take user defined input as lot size, magic number, take profit, stop loss, spread, slippage, level and money management true or false
- Once it runs, it opens a buy and sell order with OrderSend().
- It Keeps track of these two order's ticket numbers
- it checks if the order type is a buy or sell and compares the take profit level to user defined levels, If it's met it will open another order.
- If it's a buy order, it will also check if the ask price is greater than the breakeven point of the previous sell order. If it is, it will open another buy order.
- Similarly for sell order, it will check if the bid price is less than the breakeven point of the previous buy order. If it is, it will open another sell order.
- Also it uses a user defined value as level, which is a multiple of take profit, to check if the market went to opposite direction for the same amount of pips before placing the trade again
- It also uses a money management option that calculates the lot size based on the current balance. If the user set the money management as true then it will use the lot size based on the current balance and if it's false then it will use a fixed lot size.
- it finds the broker digits as well
Please let me know if there is something specific you need me to include in this EA.
"

Ok, its amazing how the bot is understanding from what you tell it to do, and amazing how it collect the information out of my bad english that are filled with grammer and spelling mistakes. But this little detail about giving me codes that will not be compiled that is really regredable thing.

This code is important for me. I hope you will tell me what errors it did and help me make it able to be compiled


Here is the code:


#property copyright "Copyright 2022, OpenAI"
#property link "https://www.openai.com"
#property version "1.00"
#property strict
input double LotSize = 0.01;
input int MagicNumber = 12345;
input double TP = 10;
input double SL = 20;
input double Spread = 0;
input double Slippage = 0;
input int Levels = 1;
input bool MoneyManagement = true;
int buy_ticket = 0, sell_ticket = 0;
double breakeven_buy, breakeven_sell;
int digits;
int OnInit()
{
digits = Digits;
return(INIT_SUCCEEDED);
}
void OnTick()
{
if (buy_ticket == 0 && sell_ticket == 0)
{
buy_ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_BUY, LotSize, Ask, Spread, SL, TP, "My EA", MagicNumber, 0, Green);
if (buy_ticket > 0)
{
breakeven_buy = Ask - (SL/digits);
Print("Buy order opened, ticket: ", buy_ticket);
}
else
{
Print("Error opening buy order: ", ErrorDescription(GetLastError()));
}
sell_ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_SELL, LotSize, Bid, Spread, SL, TP, "My EA", MagicNumber, 0, Red);
if (sell_ticket > 0)
{
breakeven_sell = Bid + (SL/digits);
Print("Sell order opened, ticket: ", sell_ticket);
}
else
{
Print("Error opening sell order: ", ErrorDescription(GetLastError()));
}
}
else
{
if (buy_ticket > 0)
{
OrderSelect(buy_ticket, SELECT_BY_TICKET, MODE_TRADES);
if (OrderType() == OP_BUY && OrderTakeProfit() == TP)
{
if (Ask >= OrderTakeProfit() * Levels)
{
double lot_size = LotSize;
if (MoneyManagement)
lot_size = AccountBalance() / (Ask * 100);
buy_ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_BUY, lot_size, Ask, Spread, SL, TP, "My EA", MagicNumber, 0, Green);
if (buy_ticket > 0)
Print("Buy order opened, ticket: ", buy_ticket);
else
Print("Error opening buy order: ", ErrorDescription(GetLastError()));
}
else if (Bid <= breakeven_sell)
{
double lot_size = LotSize;
if (MoneyManagement)
lot_size = AccountBalance() / (Ask * 100);
buy_ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_BUY, lot_size, Ask, Spread, SL, TP, "My EA", MagicNumber, 0, Green);
if (buy_ticket > 0)
Print("Buy order opened, ticket: ", buy_ticket);
else
Print("Error opening buy order: ", ErrorDescription(GetLastError()));
}
}
}
if (sell_ticket > 0)
{
OrderSelect(sell_ticket, SELECT_BY_TICKET, MODE_TRADES);
if (OrderType() == OP_SELL && OrderTakeProfit() == TP)
{
if (Bid <= OrderTakeProfit() * Levels)
{
double lot_size = LotSize;
if (MoneyManagement)
lot_size = AccountBalance() / (Bid * 100);
sell_ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_SELL, lot_size, Bid, Spread, SL, TP, "My EA", MagicNumber, 0, Red);
if (sell_ticket > 0)
Print("Sell order opened, ticket: ", sell_ticket);
else
Print("Error opening sell order: ", ErrorDescription(GetLastError()));
}
else if (Ask >= breakeven_buy)
{
double lot_size = LotSize;
if (MoneyManagement)
lot_size = AccountBalance() / (Bid * 100);
sell_ticket = OrderSend(Symbol(), OP_SELL, lot_size, Bid, Spread, SL, TP, "My EA", MagicNumber, 0, Red);
if (sell_ticket > 0)
Print("Sell order opened, ticket: ", sell_ticket);
else
Print("Error opening sell order: ", ErrorDescription(GetLastError()));
}
}
}
}
}

[quote=barnarn;14283785]

Thanks so much for your help. I have another code I have posted above this post. I hope you will also take a look at it.. This code is important for me and for my testing purposes.
But I hope also you will tell me what the bot have done of errors. If they are small of course, so I can take them to my considerations next time I talk with it.
Jasm gave me a hint about it have mixed mql5 and mql4 so I told the bot and could get one or two codes from it to be compiled.
I have also find out that sometimes when the bot stop giving me the code because of the load and I begin to combine the peaces happens that I put extra line or miss a line. This have also helped me avoid some issues.
I hope if there are other tips.
I will highly appreciate it.

Put these two lines at the beginning of the program, say in the line after '#property strict', and it won't throw an error:

Well, I am still playing around with the Chat GPT. Its very strange that in more than 90% of the codes that it produce for me cannot be compiled. Very strange. Because I will have understood it if it have produced for me codes that can be compiled but not work as expected. I mean work not in the rules I have in mind. In such case I will understand that this is a machine writing code and not a human brain that have put this code together.
But that it will not be compiled as if it is deliberetly giving me code not writing correctly.
I mean programming is something should be following specific rules, and as long as the coding rules is followed should that produce a script or an ea. Maybe it will not do what you want or give you errors while you backtest it or use it on chart, but not prevent you from compiling it. In such case it is as if you are not coding correctly.
So what is your thoughts about this?

Have you others got better results with other programming languages for other purposes ?