Day Trading vs. Swing Trading vs. Position Trading 86 replies
Disliked{quote} After a quick search, I found this: https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...25#post2922825 Back then I posted some indicators, especially the Trix was discussed, copied, applied, etc. But everything stopped 10 years ago with the development. I don't think I wrote an EA, there are only two trading scripts from me. During the search, I was happy to see the name of the guy @TudorGirl and remind me in the huge fuss around her/him. Have you read my philosophical post? https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...94#post2909494...Ignored
DislikedWhy are the analyzes wrong and someone thinks they have the holy grail? Here is a test with EA-7.0 {image} - Lower rectangle: The sell trade took place at 9:30 am, at which point the CenterLine (the trend) was falling. - Upper rectangle: Here is the position of the CenterLine drawn after 34 bars, from here the indicator is no longer repainted, and the trend is rising! With the cursor, one can see at any point at which time the repainting line was drawn (present). This representation made by me is unique, one has not been seen anywhere in this form...Ignored
DislikedThis is screenshot from tester - I took it live as it happened. As you can see EA 7.0 opened actually deal in countertrend environment as it is programmed to do, Centerline TMA had just shifted from down to uptrend. I also layered over Husky v2.2 bands and signals. As a general rule, 15M timeframe is so full of noise that any signals should be taken very carefully. {image} Repainting is basically the same as signal becoming invalid due to more recent data shifting the previous MA results. Its not the end of the world, just the question of further...Ignored
Disliked{quote} Yes i think this would make a good Ea. I understand Swing man is very busy, and he has allready helped me with adding alerts which is great as i can just take the signal off my mobile, but maybe as you say we can figre out how to do it by doing some research, i much prefer Huskybands V2.2 than the indi in the EaIgnored
DislikedYou are far too optimistic - signals following the short term trend, while price bouncing opposite of the trendline are far more difficult to catch reliably. I would very much like to experiment with Husky 2.2 based EA with trend control options and some signal validity options over TP/SL levels. I hope Swingman can spare some time to plug the Trendy Husky to EA. There could be some potential. Especially if you run some trades for a longer period than a day. {quote}Ignored
Disliked{quote} After a quick search, I found this: https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...25#post2922825 Back then I posted some indicators, especially the Trix was discussed, copied, applied, etc. But everything stopped 10 years ago with the development. I don't think I wrote an EA, there are only two trading scripts from me. During the search, I was happy to see the name of the guy @TudorGirl and remind me in the huge fuss around her/him. Have you read my philosophical post? https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...94#post2909494...Ignored
DislikedHi, I hope Swingman is OK that I checked the code of Husky v2.2 and found place how tweak it, so it displays trade suggestions, which ONLY follow the main TMA trend, while taking advantage of price bouncing off the outer bands. Basically should ensure good momentum in right direction, in theory. For BUY signal: Central TMA pointing UP, price needs to be BELOW TMA by user selected Band threshold (default 1). For SELL signal: Central TMA pointing DOWN, price needs to be ABOVE TMA by user selected Band threshold (default 1). Test it out how it works...Ignored
Disliked{quote} Hi Ilvez Please fix this indicator smLazyTMA HuskyBands_v2.2_TrendOnly from your post above. When I change colors under the color inputs tab, lines 12 & 13 always revert back to the default colors when I switch time frames or when changing pairs. Thank you much in advance! GIgnored
DislikedHi, Its not my indicator to fix. It is very good as it is so feel free to fix it yourself {quote}Ignored
Disliked{quote} You're laughable, after reading your post whereas you stated that you were checking SwingMans code & that you were tweaking it I assumed that you knew how to code, so I was only asking politely if you could maybe fix it. Excuse me for assuming. If you don't know how to fix it just come out and say so. or better yet why don't you go fuk yourselfIgnored
DislikedSorry, did not mean to come out rudely but I am not coder,if you would have read few posts before. As the source code is available I am sure you can find someone to tweak it for you, just search the forum. Cheers, I {quote}Ignored
Disliked{quote} After a quick search, I found this: https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...25#post2922825 Back then I posted some indicators, especially the Trix was discussed, copied, applied, etc. But everything stopped 10 years ago with the development. I don't think I wrote an EA, there are only two trading scripts from me. During the search, I was happy to see the name of the guy @TudorGirl and remind me in the huge fuss around her/him. Have you read my philosophical post? https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...94#post2909494...Ignored
DislikedNew indicator "smLazyTMA Signals_v1" Here is a simple signal indicator, only for lazy traders: - in trend direction of TMA will be generated signals when the candles cross the TMA bands. Lazy Trading idea: - Entry at next candle. - Lots calculation with 1% risk for SL on band 4. - Exit if TMA changes the direction (color) {image} {file}Ignored
DislikedHi, Can you comment on the trade entry logic for the Husky (trending)? Why it did not take the SELL trade on EURJPY today? {image} I understood that signal is given with following logic e.g. when candle closes above/below Band threshold, signal is given at next candle? https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...3#post12322063 Is it because the second candle also breached Band2? I think it is actually prudent logic not blindly take trade at next candle as the spike may continue. Like here, the signal is given at the Band4 (threshold...Ignored
Disliked{quote} After a quick search, I found this: https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...25#post2922825 Back then I posted some indicators, especially the Trix was discussed, copied, applied, etc. But everything stopped 10 years ago with the development. I don't think I wrote an EA, there are only two trading scripts from me. During the search, I was happy to see the name of the guy @TudorGirl and remind me in the huge fuss around her/him. Have you read my philosophical post? https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...94#post2909494...Ignored
Disliked...hi Mr,SwingMan If you combine Icarus with your indicator (smLazyTMA HuskyBands_v2.2) , it will be great. Can I ask you to do this?Ignored