DislikedHello, sir. If you dont mind, can you show the 1H GBPUSD chart from the beginning of February with this tool? I just want to compare it with other views. Thank u for your kindness.Ignored
Supply and Demand Thread using any Indicator 64 replies
Automated trendline trading EA + indicator 35 replies
Automated Trading & ONLY Auto Trading 3 replies
Automated or semi automated trading? 3 replies
Best ECN Brokers for automated trading using C language or MT4??? 5 replies
DislikedHello, sir. If you dont mind, can you show the 1H GBPUSD chart from the beginning of February with this tool? I just want to compare it with other views. Thank u for your kindness.Ignored
DislikedSo here is my opinion. I looked at your supply and demand indicator on mql5. I like how simple it is compared to other supply and demand indicators that are bloated with unnecessary features. My complaint is your price tag. It seems unreasonable. There are free supply and demand indicators similar to yours. How do you justify charging so much for your indicator? What makes it so special compared to other indicators of this kind?Ignored
DislikedWow. Awesome. Thanks, man. All i need is to see this area. And ur tools identify it nicely. Appreciate. I think i really need this tools. Anyway, have u ever try the AutoUFOs indicator in tradingview? It detects the unfilled order area, just like yours. What do you think about that indicator? {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} Do the same on GPBUSD 1hr using the free indicator and please tell me if you see the same zones....Ignored
Disliked{quote} Admittedly, most of these types of indicators are going to produce different results.Ignored
Dislikedok. As far as I know, in supply and demand theory, the more often the area is touched, the weaker the area is. Does this indicator tell us which areas are still fresh or not?Ignored
DislikedHi! Just got your indicator and so far backtesting has been great! Win rare for 2 years is between 58-62%. Would definitely be higher if I didn’t take some dumb trades. I do have one question though. I noticed that the dotted and yellow timeframe lines are not showing up? Is there a setting I should have changed?Ignored
DislikedI am a firm believer that if you are selling a product, then you need to be competitive with your pricing. I can think of another popular supply and demand indicator on MQL5 (out of respect for you, I am not going to share a link to it) being sold for the same price as yours but it has far more features. In fact, I have the indicator. It works quite well. What irritates me about it, however, is it has TOO MANY features, and the developer of it doesn't clearly explain what all of the features are for and how to use them. I like to keep things simple....Ignored
Disliked{quote} First of all i like simplicity too....My intetion was to create an indicator from scratch that will create Supply AND Demand zone with the best possible way... And not just add useless features for marketing reasons!!! The other indicator you mention it is just the free version that has been added some features... But the core is the same... I told you before please send some screenshots using your indicator and i will send the same screenshots from same charts....and compare them in detail!! Nevertheless more features will be added....and...Ignored
Disliked{quote} Actually, the other indicator I am talking about was developed by professional traders. It's not some knock-off of a free version with added features. It's a high quality indicator. As for your argument that your supply and demand areas are better, that is subjective at best. It's what a trader decides to do at such areas that matters most. I am certain your areas of supply and demand don't always work out. If they did, then you would have the Holy Grail of indicators and be uber wealthy. Frankly, it is irresponsible to give people the impression...Ignored
Disliked{quote} Sorry to butt in but you can’t just tell someone “it is irresponsible to give people the impression that your indicator is perfect and all others suck.” When you are clearly asking him to explain why he has a higher price tag on his own indicator. He developed the indicator and priced it as he sees fit he himself doesn’t event have to answer you since you have never purchased it or tried it. If you don’t like the price due to your VAST knowledge of being in the forex space for so long then don’t buy it. Simply move on. Stop pestering him...Ignored
Disliked{quote} It's my right to share my opinion. You have no right to order me around. If you don't like what I have to say, then ignore me. I am offering constructive criticism based on experience trading and knowledge of other indicators. My words should not be frowned on but welcomed. How do you think products get improvements over time and business thrives? It's because customers and potential customers alike share their opinions. Responsible business owners who want to succeed take such opinions seriously.Ignored
Disliked{quote} It’s clear your end goal is to get a cheaper price on the indicator. Any developer has put in hours/days/months into their work and for you to demand a cheaper price for their own work just because other indicators are cheaper is just in bad taste. That’s just sad.Ignored