Are there actually any profitable traders on Forex Factory?

I've been through quite a bit of threads, and 99% of responses or threads seem like complete beginners or indian scammers.
This forum becomes quite a massive problem when it's all beginners talking to each other when no one knows how actual profitable trading is like.
This forum becomes quite useless if no one knows anything, there should be an improved community with actual good traders to share their knowledge with each other and have a nice time. Now i have made a Discord server with primarily profitable traders (Which i am not going to share here because that would fit into the commercial channel)

But anyone here, do you know of an improved version of this forum essentially, or just some actual good threads, because everything goes to ruin, if it's a bunch of retail beginner traders - let me know if you know any actual genuine good threads, or improved communities of good traders. If you want to know more about the Discord i mentioned you can PM me.

Think about this if you're using this forum, have you actually made money consistently, if you're a beginner it probably won't help you to learn from other beginners? If you're a good trader you get nothing out of this.
Cheers, William.

You can always assume a 1/10 ratio. So let us see.. there are at times up to 20k traders on the site. You get the numbers. Why?

You can't really assume a 1/10 ratio definitely not if you've read through a lot of threads on here.
You can probably assume a 1/100 ratio at best

The 1% you're talking about are usually busy trading or living their lives. You won't find them very active on forums, if they're forum members in the first place. That being said though, You'll find excellent traders and very bright minds here on FF.

Interesting threads are rare, but you'll find some gems here too. You'd need some long hours reading and filtering threads though.

Yes of course there are.

Most successful traders probably get fed up of the negativity and malcontents though, and spend less time on here as a result.

They're around though... you'll probably find an inverse correlation between ego and profitability

Watch this and learn why most loose...

And these guys, make money every day trading only cable...are you ready to put the effort?


https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=849587