Disliked{quote} Astrology only works when astrology is known. If you don't know that is your problem. .Ignored
1
Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD)
- #10,582
- Sep 10, 2019 11:09am Sep 10, 2019 11:09am
- Joined May 2008 | Status: Gannalist | 1,184 Posts
{quote} Gann did not use astrology. Gann did not know astrology. He used astronomical cycles. That's why he also used heliocentric astronomy. That is an astrological aberration because we do not live in the Sun. Astrology is not the same as astronomy. When people don't know astrology, they confuse astrology with astronomy. Astrology is a symbolic language. The second question remains unanswered, where is the fortune of W.D. Gann? Does it hide in South American banks? Why do you have such a need to worship myths? .
Other people can be successful with other methods, even without using any astrology at all. (well at least they will have that illusion)
About worshipping myths, don't get me started, 2000 years of regulated religion tells me that people have an innate need for such
I don't care how much money mr. Gann made, he didn't take anything with him when he died. I only care about the knowledge.
So that said, what type of medieval astrology are you using?
And why that specific branch of astrology. Can you give an example?
- #10,583
- Sep 10, 2019 11:34am Sep 10, 2019 11:34am
{quote} I did it to remember my old days. When I worked in an EU financial institution. In Belgium I found a lot of guys who talked a lot without saying anything. As your. "Bavard comme une pie". .
The only thing you can do lately is talking about that i am from Belgium, that you don't like Belgium people but you like our chocolate and how Belgium people talk alot and say nothing all, blablabla..
How old are you? Because it's a fact that you are older then me, but damn you are being so chilidsh.
+ you are being a racist, trying to offend me because you know i got it right and you are verry wrong. Such a shame.
You worked for a EU financial institution?
I hope for them you didn't use your "ASTROLOGY" or they would be bankrupt by now.
I make an astrological prediction here every week for months. Sometimes it works well and is profitable. Other times it doesn't work.
I make the astrological predictions because I want. I like to make them. If you don't like them, don't look at them. Go to another thread.
Astrology only works when astrology is known. If you don't know that is your problem.
I have not seen Mr. Gann ### predict anything. Do you have vision problems?
Are you being serious?
You have been here since 2010 and you are still not able to predict the future to a certain % higher then 50%. Then what's the point of what you are doing??
Sometimes it works, sometimes not. lol. W.D. Gann analysis works everyday. If it doesn't work it's my own fault because i made a mistake in analysis.
It's not the fault of the law of vibration, it's the fault of human mistakes. With your system i we can not say that, it's a fact that astrology in financial markets only works from time to time, WHICH IS NOT AN EDGE! It's only confusing yourself and other people.
Then you should consider flipping a coin, maybe you get more luck in trading that way.
I saw your twitter and your blog, it's been very quiet since 2011..
What happened? Did your system fail you?
Anyway i am sure i will get another funny, childish answer from you.
This was my last post to you since i have no time to waste on you anymore.
- #10,584
- Edited 6:30pm Sep 10, 2019 4:25pm | Edited 6:30pm
{quote} The only thing you can do lately is talking about that i am from Belgium, that you don't like Belgium people but you like our chocolate and how Belgium people talk alot and say nothing all, blablabla..
Signal seller.
!!!
Do not troll anymore please.
- #10,585
- Sep 10, 2019 5:45pm Sep 10, 2019 5:45pm
{quote} It is your picture. Right? Signal seller. !!! Do not troll anymore please. {image}
Yes that is indeed my picture.
But if you would really read my posts you would know that i never sold anything on this forum and never will.
From all the signals i send to my clients i post some of them for FREE in this forum.
And as you can read on the picture you uploaded yourself it says: FREE SIGNAL GROUP
In what kind of way are you contributing, because calling people a scammer with no reason is not contributing my friend.
Do you have proof that i am a scammer? Because i have lots of proof that people love my analysis and make lots of profits with it.
Selling signals outside this forum is not illegal and it does not make me a scammer.
If you want a picture of my face too you can just ask me or go to my profile.
You think a scammer would use his real name and real picture of his face?
Most of you don't even show your face or real name, so now i can call you a scammer right?
I am totally transparant in my trading, analysis and personal info.
The ONLY thing i will not share in here is my knowledge. Which is my right to do so.
You trolls are taking this thread way off topic, you should stop wasting your time trying to call me a scammer and you should contribute to this thread or say nothing at all because all this is not forex or astrology related and myself & other traders don't care about it.
I share all my info on my profile, so is my instagram linked to my profile, so my compliments to you for finding that picture
- #10,587
- Edited 8:11pm Sep 10, 2019 7:58pm | Edited 8:11pm
- Joined Nov 2010 | Status: Trader | 623 Posts
{quote} Yes, he also used astrological cycles. I agree with you that Gann did not use all there is to know, and that is not the point. Other people can be successful with other methods, even without using any astrology at all. (well at least they will have that illusion) About worshipping myths, don't get me started, 2000 years of regulated religion tells me that people have an innate need for such
Three important points:
1. Nothing that is not statistically tested has any predictive value.
2. You need at least 500 events for your statistics to have predictive value.
3. Commercial software lacks practical utility if they are not useful for creating statistics.
4. I have already uploaded links to buy books on classical astrology in English in my previous messages and have said what my sources are. There are no secret teachings. Secrets are a fool's thing. It is in the secrets on which the hoax religions are based.
The fundamental problem in F.F. is that people do not want to study. They just want a wonderful indicator to make money as a home trader. I say nothing more.
.
.
- #10,589
- Sep 10, 2019 9:22pm Sep 10, 2019 9:22pm
[quote = dorood; 12494781] {quote} Es tu foto. ¿Correcto? Vendedor de señales. !!! No troll más por favor. {imagen} [/ cita] If the memory of W.D. Gann endures, it is because there is a horde of scammers who claim to possess the secrets of W.D. Gann They sell books, software, signals and even videos. They use the name of W.D. Gann as a successful brand. . .
- #10,591
- Sep 11, 2019 6:06am Sep 11, 2019 6:06am
- Joined Jan 2019 | Status: "Ideas stimulate the mind" | 4,203 Posts
{quote} Some considerations about Gann: 1. W.D. Gann could never do scientific astrology because he lacked the statistical means to do so. 2. Gann's vibration law is the third law of the Kybalion. 3. Gann sought the application in the markets of the sixth law of Kybalion in astrology. But Gann's use of astrology was extremely rudimentary. Gann was not an astrologer. I didn't know astrology. 4. The Kybalion was written in 1908. Possibly by William Walker Atkinson. 5. Gann recommended reading poor books that lack practical utility 6. If Gann had earned...
maybe he codified the books because they are so powerful.
{quote} Hi suryananda ... hello everyone ... I can't believe the rumors that gann didn't make money ... we see with our own eyes that it works.
- #10,593
- Sep 11, 2019 6:45am Sep 11, 2019 6:45am
- Joined Jan 2019 | Status: "Ideas stimulate the mind" | 4,203 Posts
{quote} Hi suryananda ... hello everyone ... I can't believe the rumors that gann didn't make money ... we see with our own eyes that it works.
The only scientific way to know if a technique works is with the confirmation of its corresponding statistics. Have you seen any of those statistics with Gann's techniques? I do not.
I don't want to talk more about W.D. Gann. I want to talk about astrology.
Example:
In Greco-Latin astrology the retrogradations of the planets are harmful. But in Vedic astrology it is said that it is positive because it accentuates the character of the planets. Positive for positive planets and negative for harmful planets.
I constantly see in the threads that people say that when the planets are retrograde the price falls. That prejudice comes from Greco-Latin astrology.
I uploaded one of my threads the graphs of the retrogradations of all the planets in 20 years of the German Bund. There it looked good that retrogradations do work. But not as it is said in traditional Hindu and European astrologies.
Then if you want to do something with astrology you have to raise your own statistics. If you get a 30% advantage (hedge) you will already be lucky. That implies that you will lose 70% of your operations. Consecutive losses will make you lose your capital.
So you need three things:
1. Statistics based on astrology.
2. A support system to show you when to enter the market.
3. Severe money management.
Note: The predictions that jnevins shows every week are a money-making machine if points 2 and 3 apply.
I apologize to everyone for my bad English.
.
- #10,596
- Sep 11, 2019 7:01am Sep 11, 2019 7:01am
- Joined Jan 2019 | Status: "Ideas stimulate the mind" | 4,203 Posts
- #10,599
- Edited 7:18am Sep 11, 2019 7:07am | Edited 7:18am
- Joined Oct 2017 | Status: Trader | 12,472 Posts
[quote = Gann1993; 12490561] Si eres tan bueno como te lo dices a ti mismo, hagamos una competencia de predicción. Tú eliges el mercado y predices los próximos 30 días. Haré mi propio análisis y podremos compararlo entre sí. De todos modos, si tienes las bolas para hacer esto. [/ Quote] I make an astrological prediction here weekly. Sometimes it works well and sometimes bad. I also have other old threads where I made predictions. With them you can earn some money statistically tested. But it's only 50% of my system. The other half I have...
Suryananda I have another one for you " After an Uptrend, comes a Downtrend" !
By the way where can I and others consult YOUR statistics ?
- #10,600
- Sep 11, 2019 7:11am Sep 11, 2019 7:11am
- Joined Jan 2019 | Status: "Ideas stimulate the mind" | 4,203 Posts