Volume Leads Price - VSA and Wyckoff

What a great trading ideal. But can someone put the Volume Spread for VSA by hariprasath_ indicator here? Please!!!

Its only available on TradingView. Its not an MT4 indicator.

The indicator is nothing special really. Just makes it easier on the eyes.

@naviafra

Have you ever heard about someone called Sam Seiden? He is a guru about Supply&Demand

No can't say that I have. Appreciate you sharing this with me. Any link or info?

There are many many free videos on YouTube. The commercial stuff are on his academy website.
To start see the followings



Cheers

Thanks bro. Really appreciate anything related to this. Ten thumbs up!!!

His style is based on multi TF analysis and he doesn't use usually indicators
Let say you are intraday trader.
Your curve (bigger TF) will be the daily chart,
Your trend chart will be H4
Your entry will be H1 or M15 (occasionally M5 if you are glued on chart)

I suggest for coming viewers to start from the following links (are from a different trader) as is goes more on educational level and is more understandable to newbie (start from the back to basic videos on YouTube).
https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=590109
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBf...x3hHl3g/videos

I don't say that you are wrong...You started an educational(you said that yourself) thread here and post no charts, no explanation etc...so how anybody here can say are you wrong or right?
After only my 2 replies here you are ready to dump your "educational" thread? I wonder if you dump any idea after two fails...
Anyway, I can see my presence here is bothering you, so good luck and good bye.

same here. when i read first post, i thought to myself, sooner or later to the commercial section. your profile pic is also funny. nobody puts real or fake human photo unless they have some commercial *intentions*

can you do few live calls? or share real account?
we want to see some action before we do any educational excercises.

Ok let's get this straight.

I am not advertising. I am not selling anything. I am not even linking anything. If I did, sure, you would be right. But you cannot come and assume that sooner or later I will advertise, that's wrong.

You say that I have not posted charts. Actually I have. Several of them, and more are to come.

@WSoar I am not bothered by criticism, but there is a difference in how you do criticise. You can say your wrong, or you can say your wrong and give a detailed explanation with arguments why I am wrong. I am not saying I am right either, I am just sharing the knowledge I have of the markets, whether its right or wrong. Your arguments has no explanation or backbone, you need to argue for your sake. If I was bothered by your presence I would just block you from the thread.

You were in this forum a few months ago asking what it means when GBP is on the left side and USD on the right side of GBP/USD. But do I bash down on your knowledge? No! Because this is a forum with probably majority losing traders actively trying to learn something new. If you, without facts, go inside threads and start bashing down on theories and market views that MIGHT be profitable and actually good, you are damaging the core foundation of this forum.

You say that there is no "big evil" hunting my 0.01 lot stoploss. You don't even argue for your opinion presenting facts and/or reasoning. You just say it. So let me present you with some facts, and then your welcome to argue against but hopefully you will do it with more detail than just "Your wrong"

 

1. Nobody is hunting for 0.01 lot size in stop loss. Where you put your 0.01 lot stop loss, 1000's or more traders are putting the same stop loss. So it is not just ONE traders stop loss.
2. It is a fact that about 75-90% of traders and investors lose money. So if the institutions are earning money, where is this profit coming from if not from losers?
3. I would bet that most of the traders in FF are trading CFDs. Do you even know what that means? CFDs are a contract for difference. They represent the underlying value of an instrument, for example EURUSD. So if the EURUSD is valued at 1.111 on the OTC market, the CFD is valued the same. However, the core difference here is that a CFD order MUST be filled, no matter how much supply is present. So if you place a 100000 lot order on a CFD provider, the broker MUST give you that instrument for that price even if the OTC market could just fill 1 lot due to lack of supply. So this leads to the conclusion that you are losing against, or winning from, your CFD broker. So how does the CFD broker make money? Well, he takes the opposite side of your trade on a OTC market. Suddenly, you and your fellow traders at that particular broker, is not affecting the market with 0.01 lots correct?

So with CFD brokers (or any other broker on the OTC market) placing the opposing trade to yours, it will make it profitable for them correct?

And if you look at the brokers website they all have something like this

"CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 84% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money."

Now, suddenly, placing the opposite order is mathematically profitable. Correct?

So please, if you do have reason to believe that anything I say here is bullshit, please elaborate and argue for your sake. Just saying "Your wrong" or bash out on anything that I say is really not arguing.

Criticism is welcome, I might even learn something from it. But just say your wrong wont teach me anything!

So if you share the same view of the market as I do, or any other supply & demand trader, your welcome add your knowledge to this thread.
If you do not agree, I would love to hear logical arguments, arguments that might even teach me a thing or two.
If your here to bash out and just be negative and skeptical without any reasoning or facts presented, well your better off in the threads where the view of the market is similar to yours.

I am sorry, was I wrong to put my real photo? Would a picture of the letter A make me look like I know what I am talking about? Im really confused here. Saying "nobody puts their photo unless they have commercial intentions" is far fetched. What if I said "nobody puts a letter as their profile photo unless they were this and that" Jesus, come on. When I start advertising, sure ill give you credit for your prediction of the future. But until then, you are wrong my friend

I can do live calls, anytime. I actually host live trading sessions aswell (non paid non commercial so don't say it's advertising lol). But sure, setup live trading calls and Ill join anytime. This is what makes us traders evolve, sharing knowledge and learning from eachother.

I don't need to share my live account, it is my personal business. I could however make a fake account with fake results like a lot of people do here, but I am not promoting anything, nor am I sharing any strategy. I am just sharing my (and many others) view of the markets.

Not correct.
84% might lose only because of the spread/commission.

Also 84% might only lose a little bit and the 16% might make more than this in total. I don't think they do but it's not a mathematical certainty.

– 1Barber, Lee, Odean (2010): Do Day Traders Rationally Learn About Their Ability?
– 2Odean (1998): Volume, volatility, price, and profit when all traders are above average
– 3Barber, & Odean (2000): Trading is hazardous to your wealth: The common stock investment performance of individual investors
– 4 Kumar: Who Gambles In The Stock Market?
– 5 Barber, Odean (2001): Boys will be boys: Gender, overconfidence, and common stock investment
– 6Calvet, L. E., Campbell, J., & Sodini P. (2009). Fight or flight? Portfolio rebalancing by individual investors.
–7Barber, B. M., Lee, Y., Liu, Y., & Odean, T. (2009). Just how much do individual investors lose by trading?
– 8Gao, X., & Lin, T. (2011). Do individual investors trade stocks as gambling? Evidence from repeated natural experiments
– 9Strahilevitz, M., Odean, T., & Barber, B. (2011). Once burned, twice shy: How naïve learning, counterfactuals, and regret affect the repurchase of stocks previously sol.
– 10Da, Z., Engelberg, J., & Gao, P. (2011). In search of attention
– 11De, S., Gondhi, N. R. & Pochiraju, B. (2010). Does sign matter more than size? An investigation into the source of investor overconfidence

Tons of research backing my statement.

It becomes a mathematical certainty, that is how odds work. There might be variance, but in the long run, the odds work themselves out.
And the opposing trades are usually matched against the exact amount of the original trade. So even if the 16% end up winning more money, the 84% who lost and were matched with the same order size, can pay the winners. If the winners were bigger than the losers, CFD brokers would lose money and eventually go out of business.

However, we are going off track now. We should probably stick with discussing supply and demand

Yes please
Let's go back to the tipoc of supply & demand
Cheers

So, I have talked about areas of balance, and areas of imbalance.

So this leads to the conclusion

1. Whenever there is an area of balance, orders can easily be filled
2. Whenever there is imbalance, order will go unfilled.

With this, you can spot if a sudden widespread, high volume move, is actually bearish or bullish.

For example

1. Price goes up, and suddenly comes down.
2. When it comes down it consolidates for some time. There is time here to fill orders, long or short doesnt matter.
3. Price spikes up on a wide spread very quickly and then falls back down quickly again.

This action suddenly become bearish.

Why? Ask your self, if there was a lot of buying in the lows (right after supply was present pushing prices lower), would that really create imbalance and shoot price up and then fall quickly down again?

The reverse goes for buying

Hi
I have taught about VSA on a public site more than 3 months, of course not in English and during that time so many viewers copied all lessons and indicators which some of them were from a thread of this site. Even i traded on line for each subject per week.
1st of all, I should say, Unfortunately whenever a trader wanna share an idea or teaches sth here, few viewers say constantly that " You wanna advertise and sell sth" though Do not care about them if you really wanna get sth of this issue.
Be flexible for learning and teaching and be patient because this method of trading is very difficult and need a lot of effort
If i have time i'll translate some of the useful subjects of those days and share with you and other may be helpful to go ahead. ( As you said above not advertising or selling just for sharing )
Wish you green days

Appreciate this. Thank you brother

naviafra you are a good teacher, you know what you are talking about and you certainly must be a good trader, please continue that many of us here appreciate your work and knowledge.

Thank you =)
Appreciate this