Do these Indicators Repaint or Not?

Hi,

I have a version of the Forex Freedom Bars, and another version that is supposed to be Non Repainting.

The problem is both indicators do not display data exactly in the distant past. And I still can't figure if both are repainting or both are non repainting.

Can anyone look into these indicators to see if they repaint more than 1 bar back? Thanks a lot.

"int limit=Bars-counted_bars;
for (int ii=start... ii>=limit; ii--)
{ ... re-calc here ... etc"

Any time you see this code, YES it repaints.
You need to understand what that code does.

Indicators (most of them) do not need to update tick-by-tick, but that is how the developers show you how to code, and everybody does it that way. It will kill any EA.
I have posted several items that show code that does proper backfill and then updates on bar close. I think the most recent is the BBSAR.

Thank you!

just tried it.. it repaints

really ? i just test it on m1 and watch it for more than 3 hours.. there are so many signal which ask to buy and sell and there are not repaint.

the way to check it repaint or not is wait till the candle close first. when there is a signal to buy or sell after the candle close, directly move to another time frame then back to previous time frame which give a signal. if the signal still there even the price move on opposite direction it mean not repaint.

for example :
on time frame M1 there is a buy signal appear on 01.00am, when the candle close and create new candle on 01.01am and the buy signal is still there (on candle 01.00am), hurry up move to another time frame, example M5, then back to M1. if the signal still there (on 01.00am candle) even now the price go down it prove the indicator is not repaint. But if the buy signal disappear that's what we call repaint.

look at this picture :



in the circle there are buy signal and sell signal, if we move to M5 or another time frame, it still there even the price move to opposite direction. It's not repaint..