Currency Strength with contrarian approach - Q&A | Page 3 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

ECN && STP && Scalping && Hedging - Broker Review - Oct 2009 24 replies

Why contrarian trading works 3 replies

MACD Contrarian System 6 replies

A Contrarian View on the U.S. dollar 11 replies

FXCM Dailyfx commentary as contrarian Indicator?? 30 replies

Attachments: Currency Strength with contrarian approach - Q&A
Exit Attachments

Currency Strength with contrarian approach - Q&A

  • #41
  • May 14, 2018 9:23am May 14, 2018 9:23am
Quoting Erebus
{quote} If he keeps moving the goalposts, they will keep playing and be none the wiser; wonder what his endgame will be?? Bedtime for me, see ya
likely on other threads where he kept posting big about himself and his method, but never one seen an actual ( or couple) live trade or some sort of real proof that he trades live what he preaches.

the end, likely will be that ppl start to open their eyes to the fact that BS is running high, and there is no method, really, but smoke and mirrors.
probably around the same time will the guru get enough of his clues to make a dash to the door, either blaming his action on some "ungrateful" disciples, or the lack of time, as his multi-day swing trades dont leave him enough free time to open or post on a thread...

popcorn is ready, waiting for it to play out. i dont think it will take all that long.
there is always, always another trade!!
  • #42
  • May 14, 2018 9:38am May 14, 2018 9:38am
Quoting profitfarmer
{quote} likely on other threads where he kept posting big about himself and his method, but never one seen an actual ( or couple) live trade or some sort of real proof that he trades live what he preaches. the end, likely will be that ppl start to open their eyes to the fact that BS is running high, and there is no method, really, but smoke and mirrors. probably around the same time will the guru get enough of his clues to make a dash to the door, either blaming his action on some "ungrateful" disciples, or the lack of time, as his multi-day swing...
well you can see them reading this thread - hopefully they apologise and see the light.
  • #43
  • May 14, 2018 10:38am May 14, 2018 10:38am
If you read the other thread and not the new one, I posted a trade I opened on the Sunday (UK time) at market open - Stop wasting you're lives away.

3 or 4 trades and every one a winner. Posted at market open on the Sunday night.

Never seen anyone waste so much time. Life is short. Enjoy it and stop being so petty.
The most violent element in society is IGNORANCE
  • #44
  • May 14, 2018 10:57am May 14, 2018 10:57am
Quoting neilgroom
If you read the other thread and not the new one, I posted a trade I opened on the Sunday (UK time) at market open - Stop wasting you're lives away. 3 or 4 trades and every one a winner. Posted at market open on the Sunday night. Never seen anyone waste so much time. Life is short. Enjoy it and stop being so petty.

You can come out with all the nonsense you like Neil - we all know you are a fraud - read above.

There is an element of FF that want to protect newcomers from people like you.

"Stop wasting you're lives away." - you are the one with the magic wonder system posting nonsense to a public forum on a Saturday night, pretending that their untested theory on demo is magic.

"Life is short. Enjoy it" - you must work in marketing.
  • #45
  • May 14, 2018 1:06pm May 14, 2018 1:06pm
I did delete my posts. the currency strength is available in Dennis forum(babypips and the video of how to calculate at 5.00pm est also there). it seems these guys picked up few stuff here and there, and came up with a trading idea...not a bad idea though...over all, at least to me, their attitude and way of expression sucks... anyway, I have to mind my own trading, my friend came up with good stuff...I like that one instead of this. good luck and careful in trading...

Trade Small...Trade Often
Or
Trade Big...Trade Less.
newzTrader
  • #46
  • May 14, 2018 1:16pm May 14, 2018 1:16pm
I promised myself I wouldn't post in here but here I am..

First of all, I apologize for being rude stimpy.. but...

It's a shame that we are attacked because we are following a certain strategy and are trying to improve our trading. We are attacked because some people want to be super hero vigilantes and 'protect' people from a threat that doesn't even exist. If anything, they (you, erebus & others) are literally hindering people's chances at making money from a legitimate strategy.


Anyways, no amount of debate or argument will help this situation. The best bet is to take time away from FF and focus on your craft, studying the charts and refining the strategy, that's the only way you'll get better, you won't get better by going back and forth with some guy on the internet because you disagree and think he's a fraud (even though he isn't selling a thing )

First live day for week of 5-13-18 so far. Good luck to everyone and happy trading.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Capture.PNG Size: 32 KB


Count down to me getting called a fraud for blocking out sensitive information...1...2..3

EDIT: Just came up with the holy grail guys!! While everyone is arguing and making NO progress on FF, the idea is to not participate and instead refine your strategy! Ok im gone now
  • #47
  • May 14, 2018 1:23pm May 14, 2018 1:23pm
Quoting osjoe2
I promised myself I wouldn't post in here but here I am.. First of all, I apologize for being rude stimpy.. but... It's a shame that we are attacked because we are following a certain strategy and are trying to improve our trading. We are attacked because some people want to be super hero vigilantes and 'protect' people from a threat that doesn't even exist. If anything, they (you, erebus & others) are literally hindering people's chances at making money from a legitimate strategy. Anyways, no amount of debate or argument will help this situation....
good trades. keep going...
newzTrader
  • #48
  • May 14, 2018 1:37pm May 14, 2018 1:37pm
Quoting osjoe2
I promised myself I wouldn't post in here but here I am.. First of all, I apologize for being rude stimpy.. but... It's a shame that we are attacked because we are following a certain strategy and are trying to improve our trading. We are attacked because some people want to be super hero vigilantes and 'protect' people from a threat that doesn't even exist. If anything, they (you, erebus & others) are literally hindering people's chances at making money from a legitimate strategy. Anyways, no amount of debate or argument will help this situation....
You don't have a strategy. You are not trading. You are gambling on information you have no idea what it is or how it is compiled.

thank goodness I have your advice - I really need it.

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: real.png Size: 33 KB
  • #49
  • May 14, 2018 1:45pm May 14, 2018 1:45pm
Quoting osjoe2
I promised myself I wouldn't post in here but here I am.. First of all, I apologize for being rude stimpy.. but... It's a shame that we are attacked because we are following a certain strategy and are trying to improve our trading. We are attacked because some people want to be super hero vigilantes and 'protect' people from a threat that doesn't even exist. If anything, they (you, erebus & others) are literally hindering people's chances at making money from a legitimate strategy. Anyways, no amount of debate or argument will help this situation....
it is little confusing that you multiple times mention strategy, whereas on that thread the most there is an idea, that not even really new.
the only clear part that is out really:
go contrarian to retail....and figure out for yourself the missing pieces to make it a strategy.
yeah, great, sure.

it equals about the way to present for you the revolutionary idea:
buy low, sell high, or vice versa.
without some sufficient pointers where is low, what considered to be high, and some basic money management at least...guessed right, it isnt a strategy.

RE Holy Grail: some days the best way to make progress is not to trade if there isnt a high probability one. to my liking there is nothing today, thus plenty time to read and post.
there is always, always another trade!!
  • #50
  • May 14, 2018 1:45pm May 14, 2018 1:45pm
I need to go to Las Vegas than because im damn good at gambling
  • #51
  • May 14, 2018 1:59pm May 14, 2018 1:59pm
No strategy. See what the NZDUSD has done today. As I can't get to my computer as I'm away.. A far as I know the only method selection is The NZDUSD so far today. I havn't even looked at the rest because I have a life. When I sit down for 5 minutes I check here on my tablet.

By using Scorpionfx... I also this morning choice the NZDCAD as it was the ratings best selection for this week. Proof can be posted but I don't waste my time on little people. The world is full of angry people. It's not the Jews fault. The Arabs, The Germans, the Asians, The Europeans, The Americans that this world has problems. It's little people who blame the world for their problems.

No trading this week though as I don't trade from a phone or tablet. So I can't post proof of a real trade this week. Now I'm getting ready to go enjoy my life with my family.

CHOW
The most violent element in society is IGNORANCE
  • #52
  • May 14, 2018 2:01pm May 14, 2018 2:01pm
Quoting profitfarmer
{quote}the only clear part that is out really: go contrarian to retail....and figure out for yourself the missing pieces to make it a strategy. yeah, great, sure
What if I told you.... it really is that simple? Seriously, it is. You KNOW THE PAIRS TO TRADE. IT'S UP TO YOU TO FIGURE OUT YOUR ENTRIES AND EXITS AND RISK MANAGEMENT. I feel like this has been said 10,000 times but it just doesn't click with people. I don't get it, is it laziness, lack of intelligence, not trying to be rude, I just don't see why you don't want to put in the work, you're obviously still interested in the idea because you keep coming back, so what's the deal?

Don't follow what I am saying. Check out what Dennis is doing on BabyPips, like newzTrader has stated on this thread. His STRATEGY is almost just as simple, maybe if not simpler. Determining individual currency strength off the 200SMA strength, FOLLOWING THE TREND, entering on PULLBACKS hetells everyone in his thread it's their job to figure out entries, exits, its their job to know market structure.. Has been doing it profitably for 3 years, yet it's such a simple concept.

Seriously, what else do you want? Maybe someone to come over to your house and hold your hand through the process? Anyways... I'm getting sucked into the bullshit here. Peace.
  • #53
  • Edited 4:08pm May 14, 2018 3:51pm | Edited 4:08pm
Quoting neilgroom
No strategy. See what the NZDUSD has done today. As I can't get to my computer as I'm away.. A far as I know the only method selection is The NZDUSD so far today. I havn't even looked at the rest because I have a life. When I sit down for 5 minutes I check here on my tablet. By using Scorpionfx... I also this morning choice the NZDCAD as it was the ratings best selection for this week. Proof can be posted but I don't waste my time on little people. The world is full of angry people. It's not the Jews fault. The Arabs, The Germans, the Asians, The...
"Proof can be posted but I don't waste my time on little people." We are not worthy oh mighty Neil Groom from South London.

Imagine our surprise when you give an excuse that you cannot show any proof of real trading results. This is a recurring theme isn't it Neil.

And it's ciao you rambling despot.
  • #54
  • May 14, 2018 3:59pm May 14, 2018 3:59pm
Quoting osjoe2
{quote} What if I told you.... it really is that simple? Seriously, it is. You KNOW THE PAIRS TO TRADE. IT'S UP TO YOU TO FIGURE OUT YOUR ENTRIES AND EXITS AND RISK MANAGEMENT. I feel like this has been said 10,000 times but it just doesn't click with people. I don't get it, is it laziness, lack of intelligence, not trying to be rude, I just don't see why you don't want to put in the work, you're obviously still interested in the idea because you keep coming back, so what's the deal? Don't follow what I am saying. Check out what Dennis is doing...

What is this? You have now posted a completely different method to the one in your thread. Some maniacal ego trip for you and Neil?

Surely you two are a wind up?


Again, Hanover was absolutely right about this forum - what a tremendously odd bunch of people. Neil going on as if he is Davit or Captain Jack - he hasn't even presented any concrete system, method, results, analysis or truth - yet a bunch of people servile dancing to his tune.

Fucking weird.
  • #55
  • May 14, 2018 4:21pm May 14, 2018 4:21pm
South London. I wouldn't even set foot in that place. Think again. Yes Hangover was right..

Your one and ONLY thread on this forum is as follows. Just shows everyone how uneducated you are;

right you get a load of people believing youve hit upon something no one has.

create a "calculator" that returns no better results than a simple breakout system.

release a piece of software in error.

try to cover the error by releasing a piece of software only good for that month without a 50% monthly value.

keep people on tenterhooks until the monthly close.

chat nonsense about figures that dont even match up.

until someone steps back and realises its just guff.

Need I say more.
The most violent element in society is IGNORANCE
  • #56
  • May 14, 2018 4:30pm May 14, 2018 4:30pm
Quoting stimpy
{quote} "Proof can be posted but I don't waste my time on little people." We are not worthy oh mighty Neil Groom from South London. it's ciao you rambling despot
Stimpy, just wondering what brought you out of the darkness? No posts since 2015 and bang straight into the negatives with the contrarian thread, hit the ground running, it's almost as if you were just commenting somewhere else...!!
Your approach has been quite forceful. Something doesn't add up....
So my question is, why would a member not seen since 2015 suddenly rock up and attempt to disrupt a thread that's based on an idea, that got dumped into the commercial section that hasn't anything to sell. An idea that has been around for a long time.
So what is it about looking at the Scorpion website, getting some recommended pairs to trade, then cross referencing with myfxbook to confirm which contrarian trades to take? No one is selling a product, so what's the problem. Why are you so vehemently against the ideas presented.
Stop dicking around and tell us all what the real reason is.
You have me on ignore and we haven't had a chat yet....and I'm not active on the thread....I find that rather suspicious.
  • #57
  • May 14, 2018 5:12pm May 14, 2018 5:12pm
Quoting neilgroom
South London. I wouldn't even set foot in that place. Think again. Yes Hangover was right.. Your one and ONLY thread on this forum is as follows. Just shows everyone how uneducated you are; right you get a load of people believing youve hit upon something no one has. create a "calculator" that returns no better results than a simple breakout system. release a piece of software in error. try to cover the error by releasing a piece of software only good for that month without a 50% monthly value. keep people on tenterhooks until the monthly close....
its funny how history repeats....
  • #58
  • May 14, 2018 5:27pm May 14, 2018 5:27pm
Quoting moodybot
{quote} Stimpy, just wondering what brought you out of the darkness? No posts since 2015 and bang straight into the negatives with the contrarian thread, hit the ground running, it's almost as if you were just commenting somewhere else...!! Your approach has been quite forceful. Something doesn't add up.... So my question is, why would a member not seen since 2015 suddenly rock up and attempt to disrupt a thread that's based on an idea, that got dumped into the commercial section that hasn't anything to sell. An idea that has been around for a long...
Why support someone that has serially avoided posting evidence of trading results, who is obnoxious to others, is incoherent, massages an unwarranted ego, clearly not all there and hasn't got the first clue on what he is doing in the markets?

You haven't interrogated the data presented, the calculation of the data, what the data consists of. You haven't presented any results yet people are flying in live - apparently.

If you actually read the thread properly, this is what I was asking for - data - you et al consider that an attack? You et al don't even know its a) not a strategy/method/system b) successful - you have no results.

The thread is extremely odd but again says more about the quality of the forum - certainly not any trading going on in there.

You are not learning how to trade, with Neil presenting himself as some self styled messiah when he cannot even construct a sentence - check his history - every time people ask to see real results there is an excuse - that's my problem.

When you get a few years under your belt - what I say will make sense.


Do read the posts above by me - you can see I pointed out to Neil that BankersFX looked dodgy. This was only a theory a week ago....

"Think i'm on to something better and don't need bankersfx.
Just by using myfxbook community contrarian trading. It has worked for every pair today.
Go to https://www.myfxbook.com/en/community/outlook and take every pair with a volume over 5000 (Min percentage 70%)
Add an RSI period 2 on the daily chart with the pairs you get. Jeeeeeeez
Can't send a pic here. Sometimes the fxbook last weeks in the other direction. Were talking mega pips here.
I test buy if 70 or above and sell if 30 or below. Worked every time.
What I loved to see is I had the NZD/USD sell all last week and closed it Friday afternoon New York time. Well if you look the RSI it went above 30 and today it went below 30 again and it's mega dropped.

Your right. I will leave bankersFX alone. I will test this theory more.

All the best

Neil"
  • #59
  • May 14, 2018 6:32pm May 14, 2018 6:32pm
Quoting neilgroom
No strategy. See what the NZDUSD has done today. No trading this week
Yes, I'm trading NZD to the max.

And if you guys followed the method update with the Currency Strength Meter = CSM

then AUDNZD was a better choice, or even use Price Action with TREND breakouts

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: 2018-05-15_9-25-43.png Size: 46 KB
It takes a lot for me to IGNORE you, but you can try.
  • #60
  • May 17, 2018 2:44am May 17, 2018 2:44am
people still going on as NeilGroom he is a Davit, Captain Jack.... he is the total opposite.

how did you trades work out for you this week?

noticed NeilGroom cannot prove his results yet again?

Let's see your actual results this week guys - I have had a look at the trades you took - I want to see what you closed this week - I note no one has posted a real account yet.




Blindly following a commercial 3rd party (ScorpionFX / Myfxbook) with zero analysis is NOT trading.
Thread has now dissolved into RSI 2 and MA's....
1 trader viewing now