The Secret Indicator?

This is perhaps true in this context (i.e. in a trading forum).

It's one of the classic examples of the kind of issue over which the proportions of those who'd describe themselves as "indicator-traders" and those who don't varies enormously according to the context within which it's discussed.

If you ask a group of "home-based traders posting in a forum" whether or not they use indicators as a significant component of their routine trading methods, the proportion who say "yes" will be hugely bigger than the proportion you'd find if, instead, you were to ask the same question of a group of "people trading successfully for a living".

Of course, there's also a small degree of overlap between the two groups: I don't imagine for a moment that I'm the only FF-member who doesn't normally use any indicators (in fact, I know I'm not).

MACD is the best indicator on weekly chart.

Next generation of indicator must has function to display the result straightway without guess or confuse.

See my macd indicate a down trend on usd-jpy. This can be watched from now on.

Topics like this always go one way. From the other side SILENCE. Everybody, whoever that is, is keeping quiet. Get it.

The secret is in the structure of market.

May be this is the place where the secret indicator is located !
Guido

Hi hanover
Almost you are right in every case.
and a lot of curiosities about secret indi members guessing here,including lot of funny naked symbolic comments at post number 91 and onward.
first to sorry for so late replying here,i guess mostly visitor of this thread forgot about it,just today one of visitor post picture of this secret at TSD and asked if some body point out the secret indi.
it is no secret at all,just the commercial poster take the shot from trending location of chart as every seller do and pretend his invention and claiming it unique in the coding world by hiding parameters,it was time when theft coder do it by renaming indicators or a nano bit modifying the code but now codes are safe and decompiling/reverse engineering is the past history.
let us come on the topic,traders can do with every indicator that have fast and slow period parameters,like macd,osma,rsx including some others by putting/applying 2 instances of a indicator in same sub window and just invert fast/slow period of one,with changing color in singular color ..... few examples/illustration pictures attached.
and for that specific indi,i guess it can be MLADENs "MACD Digital Kahler 1_2" from TSD or any of such kind.
but experts traders can adjust so many indicators of such kinds like that,nothing hard or secret.
regards

Fair enough. I assume that the mladen indicator calculation is derived from price, hence I stand by the comments that I made earlier in the thread.

Possibly you are right as i am zero in coding matters thanks.
regards

Hi Mr Mntiwana,
Good day.
Could you assist with the following request by adding the alert into the attached AdvanceGetOscillator?

https://www.forexfactory.com/showthr...45#post9998645

Thank you in advance.
Best regards
klkk

In my opinion: The best indicator is PA and understanding how a trend starts, moves, consolidates, reverses. To make that more simple you can add 2 simple moving averages, one is short term and the other long term, also known as moving average crossover. you can also use S/R-levels and fibonacci.

or you can make friends with all big banks and ask when they make big transactions, thats the best indicator

https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=677100

ready...here is what to do: make an indicator...keep it a secret.... then you have a secret indicator...

does anyone know what is this?

now it is even better

looks like moving average crossover. but in the image they dont seem to follow the price so well

I think that is because it shows divergence too.

Hi Juhanimi
It looks like ROC with two different time frames applied.
Could you please share the indicator - Thanks

this indicator is really superb

but where will get this

hy ramzam
succeed to find?
THX