so 14.2% of the loss is due to commissions
that means that for a commission/spread of about 2pip the loss is on average 14pips
so you have a bunch of perma looser that loose on average 14 pips
why not gather them in a website and trade the opposite.
anyway i strongly believe that the majority of loss is by slowly bleeding your account
so the option 2) of random market is certainly wrong
so the market is not random and the price manipulate the people to make them loose (buy high/sell low)
any guy that stare at the screen sufficiently can attest of this nasty behavior
that means that for a commission/spread of about 2pip the loss is on average 14pips
so you have a bunch of perma looser that loose on average 14 pips
why not gather them in a website and trade the opposite.
anyway i strongly believe that the majority of loss is by slowly bleeding your account
so the option 2) of random market is certainly wrong
so the market is not random and the price manipulate the people to make them loose (buy high/sell low)
any guy that stare at the screen sufficiently can attest of this nasty behavior