I agree, I love the concept and thank NSK for sharing.
Tick Bars and/or Range bars 5 replies
Small help with the code to count up-bars and down-bars 12 replies
I need Renko bars that also show inside bars 3 replies
It's interesting how different range bars are from regular bars 0 replies
Inside bars vs pin bars 3 replies
DislikedThanks for the explanation. How do you filter the bars? --because otherwise it seems like a control bar is just the same as a wide range bar.Ignored
DislikedAttached is the 1H chart of GBPUSD. The control bar has again been marked as A. It is very simple and easy to locate. You can see that the price has kept bouncing off the highs of the control bar. The high of the bar serves as a good support after it has been broken. It has bounced 3-4 times now and each time , you could have easily made 30-40 pips. I had taken a short on EURGBP and long on GBPUSD as per the control bars and have already closed each of them for 40 pips. Had taken them with a SL of 20 pips. Easy !!Ignored
Dislikedyou marked same as my post # 46.. you changed your opinion or your specialized algo lol told you to do so ?Ignored
Dislikedsigh....its cos of idiots like these that i stopped posting/sharing my thoughts here....this from a man who proudly advertises a stupid thing called 'SMART' and shows a record of wins & losses which is clearly stupid...anyway, i knew i would get such idiotic posts...if more people continue with this idiocy, i would rather stop wasting my time here in this thread...Ignored
Dislikedsigh....its cos of idiots like these that i stopped posting/sharing my thoughts here....this from a man who proudly advertises a stupid thing called 'SMART' and shows a record of wins & losses which is clearly stupid...anyway, i knew i would get such idiotic posts...if more people continue with this idiocy, i would rather stop wasting my time here in this thread...Ignored
DislikedNo need to be distracted. Everyone can make comment and everyone else can ignore them.
So the Control Bar is a breakout at 1200(whatever tomeframe) followed by several hours of range action and trades (if you can be bothered trading a range). What happens next?Ignored
DislikedYou've totally missed the point.
NSK is trying to show us how a control bar can contain price movement (range) and how it can provide support/resistance levels (after price breaks out) for intraday trading.Ignored
DislikedWhat point have I missed? If you know something about "the point" then please share. So far we have been told CBs are major bars that move the price to a higher/lower range (my words). Which I think is similar to what you have just said. I am happy to wait for further information but just as happy to venture an opinion.Ignored
Disliked@ns_karthik
I'm definately bowing out of this thread, although I would like to add it did lead me to investigate VSA, a lot of threads and opinons, interesting stuff....
On that note I really see no difference other then verbiage then trading inside or outside bars and adding support and resistance via the bar it takes all of 1 second and doesn't take a special Alog....good luck to all. Not a hater
Ignored