DislikedI'm reading Master The Markets from the first post but this is all really counter intuitive...but does anyone trade live using VSA?Ignored
Yes.
Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) and background 5 replies
Trading With VSA - Volatile Volume and Spread Analysis 9 replies
What is the best VSA (Volume Spread Analysis) system/indicator? 1 reply
Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) and the EURUSD 3 replies
VSA Volume Spread Analysis: No demand and accumlation 2 replies
DislikedI'm reading Master The Markets from the first post but this is all really counter intuitive...but does anyone trade live using VSA?Ignored
DislikedI'm reading Master The Markets from the first post but this is all really counter intuitive...but does anyone trade live using VSA?Ignored
DislikedRediscover the Lost Art of Chart Reading
Using Volume Spread Analysis
by: Todd Krueger
[font=Cambria][size=3]Most traders are aware of the two widely known approaches used to analyze...Ignored
Disliked... VSA is best at reading a crowd; it's a direct language. After all, what is volume except a crowd of people, regardless of being 'smart' or with deep pockets?...Ignored
DislikedYou're missing something fundamental to VSA if this is what you think.
Have a re-read of MTM (assuming you're read it already).
While very new to VSA myself I can see you are having problems with the theory of it - perhaps this is why implementation is not working for you so for.
This is a good thread to ask if you have any questions.
MagnusIgnored
Disliked...
The MTM author does seem to build on crowd behavior, dividing volume into different trading crowds and then interpreting volume as an accumulation/distribution in which each crowd shapes differently how the volume looks. ...Ignored
DislikedFor those who followed the chatroom discussion about WallSt's breakout strategy, here is the current version of the Breakout Boxes indicator.....Ignored
DislikedGrath, you do indeed rule our mules!!!
Thank you for all the time and effort you put into this breakout indi...you work is truly appreciated
wallstIgnored
DislikedIf you're trading is going well - well done, I probably have no justification for comment.
However, your comment above is not right, that's not what Tom Williams espouses.
I have to point this out as this thread is for learning VSA and so anyone who is trying to learn VSA via this thread may be mis-informed by your comment.
With respect...
MagnusIgnored
DislikedI'm not sure where you got how my trading is going, I never mentioned this. To me, it's irrelevant at this point, since, as I told you, I'm still working on making an approach.
That you dismissed my note about crowd behavior, without, for the second time, offering a correct opinion, lends me to offer the quote that spurred me (along with the link in my first recent post) to make such a statement:
"It is called a buying climax because to create this phenomenon there has to be a huge demand for buying from the public, fund managers, banks and...Ignored
Disliked...VSA is best at reading a crowd; it's a direct language. After all, what is volume except a crowd of people, regardless of being 'smart' or with deep pockets?...Ignored
Disliked...The MTM author does seem to build on crowd behavior, dividing volume into different trading crowds and then interpreting volume as an accumulation/distribution in which each crowd shapes differently how the volume looks...Ignored
DislikedHi Shamus,
Can you tell me if you are still using this template and if so could you provide an explanation of how to read the various indicators please?
Regards
DenisIgnored
DislikedFor those who followed the chatroom discussion about WallSt's breakout strategy, here is the current version of the Breakout Boxes indicator.....Ignored
DislikedFor those who followed the chatroom discussion about WallSt's breakout strategy, here is the current version of the Breakout Boxes indicator.....Ignored
DislikedJust to let you guys know, there is no way to know volume in forex. I know this voids the whole thread but its better now than another 2000 posts.Ignored
DislikedAs i missed this chat, if anyone could point me to someplace where i could read up on this strategy, i'd be grateful...Ignored
DislikedThank you for saving me from wasting anymore time on VSA. Any other pearls of wisdom for us new guys?Ignored