I have been following this thread since mid December and I have attached an Excel file showing all trades for 6 currencies Harold is following. Below is the results since Dec 21st excluding spreads:
GBPUSD : +90 pips - 5 trades - 15 pips spread
GBPJPY : +17 pips - 4 trades - 16 pips spread
GBPCHF : +90 pips - 7 trades - 28 pips spread
EURJPY : +2 pips - 5 trades - 4 pips spread
EURCAD : -75 pips - 8 trades - 32 pips spread
CADJPY : +31 pips - 8 trades - 32 pips spread
Total: : +155 pips -127 pips spread
Net Result : +28 pips
I have used Oanda spreads which I believe the tightest spreads available in the market.
I know that this period was a holiday season and may not be indicative for future results.
I am also aware that Harold recommends discretion, but if you look at the spreadsheet, it is difficult to find a common point such as overbought/oversold stochastics to use discretion. For example; CADJPY long trades on 24/12 and 28/12 resulted in +30 pips while stoch was in overbought region and GBBCHF short trade on 21/12 resulted in -30 pips while stoch was not in oversold region.
I am not trying to judge this system because 10 days of forward testing is just meaningless, but these are the facts anyone who follows this thread should be aware of, IMO.
GBPUSD : +90 pips - 5 trades - 15 pips spread
GBPJPY : +17 pips - 4 trades - 16 pips spread
GBPCHF : +90 pips - 7 trades - 28 pips spread
EURJPY : +2 pips - 5 trades - 4 pips spread
EURCAD : -75 pips - 8 trades - 32 pips spread
CADJPY : +31 pips - 8 trades - 32 pips spread
Total: : +155 pips -127 pips spread
Net Result : +28 pips
I have used Oanda spreads which I believe the tightest spreads available in the market.
I know that this period was a holiday season and may not be indicative for future results.
I am also aware that Harold recommends discretion, but if you look at the spreadsheet, it is difficult to find a common point such as overbought/oversold stochastics to use discretion. For example; CADJPY long trades on 24/12 and 28/12 resulted in +30 pips while stoch was in overbought region and GBBCHF short trade on 21/12 resulted in -30 pips while stoch was not in oversold region.
I am not trying to judge this system because 10 days of forward testing is just meaningless, but these are the facts anyone who follows this thread should be aware of, IMO.
Attached File(s)
KEYMINT SYSTEM.xls
20 KB
|
697 downloads