Disliked{quote} Why not? Udine is the one who failed to give credit where credit is due.Ignored
So, let me understand...you're reason for agreeing that people should not trade Udine's method, is that he did not give credit to the coder of the signals?
Udine did state that he did not invent the system, and i would be pretty interested to hear who was the FIRST to use bias...that idea in one form or another has been around for so long, I doubt we can pinpoint the original thought.
Udine put forth HIS interpretation of an idea. The indicator still bears the logo of TRO, so it's clear he did not code it. What does it matter? Loads of people on this, and other forums share indicators...and not all of them reference the inventor every single time they post it. Not really a reason to not trade the system is it?
Also the rumpled one, in his video complaining about Udine's thread, states that he himself modified another persons indicator, and the other person got mad...so don't his complaints seem a little hypocritical?
As for the proof you, and others seem to require; i have said personally for me, i don't care to see them. I don't care if he makes 50% weekly. I care if I can make it work for me.
He is not selling anything.
He has not asked for anything.
He shared an idea, and he is also taking the time to help others apply it. If we don't like it, nor find it useful then we have the right to move on.
So what is the complaint?
I have read your thread. I find it interesting you link to Udine's post for indicators by the way...why don't you link to the creators if you find Udine's plagiarism so distasteful?
Your rules to me are more vague than the ones laid out by Udine. Take profit when the price "stops moving?" If that is not discretionary then nothing is.
That being said i hope it is profitable for you.
But i don't see any profit/loss statement showing all trades from you either? Nor do i see you post clearly defined pendings or manual entry points before they come?
And i would love to hear how you mathematically prove your version of this, when you exit the trade when "it stops moving?"
I could be wrong. But your way is not for me.
Wealth comes from what you keep, not what you earn