DislikedPrecisely - I couldn't have said it better myself BUT this must also apply to those - like you - offering opinions substantiated solely (according to yourself) by reading 1 page of a thread and having no direct contact with the person about whom you are offering said opinion.Ignored
This is actually a valid point in trading too, objective analysis with a negative bias rather than optimism, why shouldn't my trade go wrong rather than why should it go right. That's why analysis before entering a trade is more valid than analysis once you're in it.