Will the folder be posted tomorrow?
Nanningbob 4h trading system ver. 5.0 4,432 replies
Nanningbob 60x90 EA 3,920 replies
NanningBob's 4H Sellhigh BUYLOW 158 replies
Help regarding NanningBob EA 27 replies
Help to improve profitable EA - 1H NanningBob 40MA 200 BB 10 replies
DislikedThe MACD line doesn't really work, when superimposed on the stochastics.Ignored
Dislikedare you sure cause those two pictures are at different points in time.... Its well known that the macd can change position from what it looks like now to 4 weeks from now....Ignored
DislikedThe yellow vertical is at the same point in time on both pictures.
I placed the line only once.
I moved the chart back to illustrate that the MACD is not stationary, in relation to the stochastics.
EDIT- Zoom in on the two charts.
You'll see the time stamp at the bottom of the yellow vertical line.
It's the same on both screenshots.
2009/3-10/12:00Ignored
Dislikedyeh i know but what im trying to say, and what is explained as 'the one weakness' is that the macd position today wont look the same 3 weeks from now looking back... cos we arent trading back in time it doesnt matter, we aree trading at the right edge and we take its signal from the right edge positionIgnored
DislikedThe MACD shift is not that big of a problem on a 4H chart because by the time it starts shifting you are days down the road and the trade is usually done by then. Remember from one line to the next is a week and if you see the shift in the next week your 5 days past the trade. Also notice the white line moved up and the blue line did not. With the bounce off of the 20 MA you know not to stay in the trade. It would still have been a profitable trade but a small one at that. The white line will give you a warning of the MACD shift because the blue...Ignored
Disliked
One last comment you dont have all the parameters of the trade. The red, white and blue are not bunch together below the 15 at the same time, they are spread out plus you are not at he bottom of the BB, so this is a very weak read of my system.Ignored
DislikedBob,
The MACD line is serving absolutely no purpose.
If you don't see that by now, it's my fault for not being able to adequately explain it.
The shift you are talking about is not a shift from accurate to inaccurate. It is never accurate to begin with, in its relationship to the stochastics and their levels.
Trying to superimpose unlike indicators and using the levels of one for the other, is a common mistake.
It does not work.
I'll leave it alone. I've given it my best shotIgnored
Dislikedfor everyone info , the red line is not fixed. It moves as u drag the chart, take note if u wanna do visual backtest. Which means if u see the red line on 85/15 now , it might not be on 85/15 if it continue to trend and the red line will move away from 85/15 as it trend. When it finally stop and reverse , it will then stay on 85/15Ignored
Dislikedi see what ur saying billbs...
easiest way to explain is go.. look at ur macd line and where it is at currently... now zoom in and out and see how it moves....
maby Bob can clarify but im pretty sure you should be seeing 4 weeks worth of data on 4hrIgnored
The system returned:
(104) Connection reset by peer An error condition occurred while reading data from the network. Please retry your request.
Your cache administrator is webmaster.