I use Fxdd and Interbank. (Fxdd for the Ash system) There is a 3 hour difference between the close of the daily candle so this seems to create quite different signals for the system. I beleive Ash uses FXdd?
fxray
3 hour difference between Interbank & fxdd close of candle
I think the type of platform we use should not influence the system because the data that is fed is almost the same, what may differ is the time perhaps since the opening and the closing of the candle is different.
I think the type of platform we use should not influence the system because the data that is fed is almost the same, what may differ is the time perhaps since the opening and the closing of the candle is different.
Ignored
I think it can make a large difference in the daily signals. Having a platform that includes an extra day changes mathematical calculations. Even two platforms with server times of GMT+3 can have different weekly opening and closing times.
I am surprised that everyone has not downloaded a FXDD platform so their charts will match Ash's. The best way to learn a system is to compare your own trades with the system's author. There have been many posts related to this. I think the thread would be easier to read and understand if only one broker's charts were discussed and posted.
I think it can make a large difference in the daily signals. Having a platform that includes an extra day changes mathematical calculations. Even two platforms with server times of GMT+3 can have different weekly opening and closing times.
I am surprised that everyone has not downloaded a FXDD platform so their charts will match Ash's. The best way to learn a system is to compare your own trades with the system's author. There have been many posts related to this. I think the thread would be easier to read and understand if only one broker's charts were discussed and posted.
Ignored
Hi,
The odl has an extra day but ibfx does not, the signal does appear on both, so I am not sure if the extra day does play a role. Beside the Ash sytem is based on technical setting therefore regardless of what platform it should give the same outcome. It is like even though you use diffrent calculator everyone should give the same answer. Just my two cents.
Its possible that everyone is not using the same PSAR and settings.
I have been using the Parabolic Sar Color alert post #48, which is not part of the default mt4 indicators. (default settings: step 0.04 max 0.5)
I also added the parabolic SAR that comes with MT4
insert->indicators->Parabolic Sar to display at the same time.
(default settings: step 0.02 max 0.5) I can see both versions of charts that have been displayed by different traders.
PSAR settings reset per post #1. No difference between the PSAR's now. I will use these settings.
Thank you AshFX for this fine system. I am still in the AUD/USD trade
Please reconcile the above quote with this quote below, from the AshFx PDF document..
"Final Points
Please bear in mind that when entering a trade, it doesn't matter in which order the indicators may line up, eg. the AO and the AC don't have to change colour at the same candle as the first PSAR dot appearing. Or perhaps the AO/AC/Stochs might be compliant before the first PSAR dot appears, or vice versa, and this is fine."
