I'm not going to promote or disprove Alfonso or anybody else, my friend. I can show it to you in private if you promise not to publish it anywhere.

Hi, As for me I learned supply and demand by Alfonso Moreno here and also I was a member of his private community. What can I say? His system really works. I use it in my everyday trading. Yes, it's difficult. Yes, it needs many tests to understand ...

Hi, I absolutely agree with topic starter that commercial members should provide some kind of proof that their trading systems work and give some profit. It is very easy to do - just show myfxbook monitoring page of their account. I can not ...

I just want to say thank you to Alfonso, he is a great man and helped me a lot in understanding supply and demand. But if you are a newbie be ready to work hard because nobody is going to do your work for you

Thank you very much!

And another question about validating zones. Now I would like to ask about the rule of "removing opposing zone". It's a core rule. But how many zones do we need to validate? Difficult to explain... Well, we have to understand is current zone valid ...

It was just an example I'm talking about this rule: When is a supply or demand imbalance confirmed as a level? A zone or imbalance is validated under these 2 specific circumstances: A Trendline has been broken at a bigger timeframe or a flip zone ...

I need some help in validating SD zones correctly. This question is about flip zones. As rules say a level is validated if it has removed opposing level, trendline or a flip zone. 1. Do I understand right that flip zone is a zone with a series of ...

Thank you very much for your post and your warm words! Frankly speaking I have a mess now in my head about confirmation and s&f trades. I decided to move step by step and start from the very beginning. Now I'm going to practice in identifying trends ...

And another question about EURJPY Monthly. Is it up or down? image On the one hand we can draw ascending trendline which is still valid. On the other hand 2 DZ have been removed. I would say that trend is down because demand is violated and supply ...

Hi Alfonso! I'm learning and learning, trying to make top-down analysis and find trades. Was it a trade on Daily (pointed as blue circle) due to realignment/sequence rules? Monthly was down bouncing from not fresh demand. image Weekly was down (no ...

No trend=no CP's It's easy to display any custom TF chart in MT4 by using "period converter" script included in MT. Apply this script to current TF and set Period Multiplier Factor to what you need. Then load created offline chart. BUT the thing is ...

1. I must agree with you that weekly is down. It was my mistake. Two demand zones have been removed, I pointed them, but they are different to yours . image 2. Is daily USDJPY in consolidation now and the nearest valid levels are correct? ...

Dear Alfonso, was it set and forget trade (AUDJPY Daily)? Monthly up image Weekly up image Daily down. Daily demand was fresh and original, nested in Weekly fresh demand (but not original). image

Good question and I hope Alfonso will answer it. As for me I remove orders if price hits first target.

Hi Alfonso, my mistake What about this new chart? Are drops & bases identified correctly? image

Thank you very much! Unfortunately it's a little bit difficult to point correct zones... I'm more or less sure about latest Monthly Supply Zone you talked about (am I right with identifying drops/bases and RBD there?). But to find correct Demand ...

Dear Alfonso, am I right with top-down analyses? EURGBP Monthly is down, Demand in control, no shorts image WK is down, Demand in control, no shorts image Daily is down, but wk & monthly are too low on the Curve. The nearest daily supply zone is ...

I would say it's a single RBD but not 2 of RBDs Otherwise peaks and valleys can be seen everywhere.

On my opinion, we can't say that we're on a downtrend now. We don't have 2 peaks to connect, we don't have 3 CP to draw an aggressive TL, we don't have 2 DZ taken out. It looks like a bullish consolidation. If we had a higher TF than monthly with ...