Forex Factory (https://www.forexfactory.com/forum.php)
-   Trading Systems (https://www.forexfactory.com/forumdisplay.php?f=71)
-   -   Trading FRAMA Ribbon only (https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=954170)

northwind Nov 12, 2019 8:38am | Post# 141

{quote} It's interesting to see how people are trying different ways of trading. Anyway, please be careful. As I said I never tested my EA on Renko charts.
Sorry, looks like JFHullMA_EA doesn't really work on Renko charts.

A theory :
I have different EA (Margin Trader) running in separate charts for same pairs as the Renko pairs.
JFHullMA (Mode A) on Renko charts looks like it was operating from the M1 feed and ignored the Renko M3.
All the BUY trades were with the JFHullMA magic number.
Here is the interesting thing... the first JFHullMA signal seems to have triggered the Margin Trader EA.
Margin Trader EA seems to have taken over, trading in one direction, and kept using JFHullMA to open more trades as margin freed up.
Lucky coincidence I looked at the GU chart right as the price spike occurred.
But, more interesting, the same thing happened again with EJ trades. JFHullMA triggered Margin Trader and Margin Trader kept opening trades using JFHullMA.
It too would have been very profitable - only I wasn't awake when the 172 pips jump happened.
It could have been another large profit with 172 pips on approximately 220 trades of 0.1 lots.
Currently, EJ is in drawdown. Waiting to see if goes into profit.

Don't know if this is even possible for one EA to open trades using another EA.
Thanks Joe for a very interesting set of EAs.

JoeeF Nov 12, 2019 8:45am | Post# 142

Sorry, looks like JFHullMA_EA doesn't really work on Renko charts.
No problem. That EA haven't been developed for Renko charts or tested on them.

JoeeF Nov 12, 2019 8:53am | Post# 143

{quote} No problem. That EA haven't been developed for Renko charts or tested on them.
By the way. Every my EA is strictly checking magic number. Never will touch of the position or order that doesn't belong to it.

northwind Nov 12, 2019 9:16am | Post# 144

1 Attachment(s)
{quote} By the way. Every my EA is strictly checking magic number. Never will touch of the position or order that doesn't belong to it.
Here is a section of the log file for JFHullMA_GU_M3 at the time it started trading 0.10 lots.
Magic number on trades 444014 but EA log shows errors.
If the JFHullMA EA didn't open the trades a different EA had taken over and opened BUY trades using bogus magic number.
Click to Enlarge

Name: Image1.png
Size: 88 KB

northwind Nov 12, 2019 9:19am | Post# 145

2 Attachment(s)
Same thing with different pair EJ.
JFHullMA EA has over 220 BUY trades made with its magic number.
Click to Enlarge

Name: Image1.png
Size: 89 KB
Click to Enlarge

Name: Image2.png
Size: 83 KB

JoeeF Nov 12, 2019 10:27am | Post# 146

{quote} Here is a section of the log file for JFHullMA_GU_M3 at the time it started trading 0.10 lots. Magic number on trades 444014 but EA log shows errors. If the JFHullMA EA didn't open the trades a different EA had taken over and opened BUY trades using bogus magic number. {image}
Same thing with different pair EJ. JFHullMA EA has over 220 BUY trades made with its magic number. {image} {image}
Dear John,
I think it would be better not using my EA on Renko charts. At least for now. My framework haven't been developed or tested for Renko charts. At least for now.

And for now I haven't energy and time to support Renko charts.

northwind Nov 12, 2019 11:35am | Post# 147

{quote} {quote} Dear John, I think it would be better not using my EA on Renko charts. At least for now. My framework haven't been developed or tested for Renko charts. At least for now. And for now I haven't energy and time to support Renko charts.
Fully agree.
Already removed EA and closed all Renko charts.
Now focused on JF4XTRADER testing.


© Forex Factory