Forex Factory (https://www.forexfactory.com/forum.php)
-   Trading Systems (https://www.forexfactory.com/forumdisplay.php?f=71)
-   -   Symphonie Trader System (https://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=315572)

Evaluator Sep 16, 2011 10:38am | Post# 1

7 Attachment(s)
(This is a constantly updated document that will contain additions and modifications to strategy)
LATEST VERSION is 4.4h

Hello and welcome,

I have been testing many indicators and programs for years to determine which combinations will work the best and most importantly which combinations are the most accurate. From all my studies and research I put forth the following program. I call this program the

Symphonie Trader System

Named for the combination of indicators used to determine tops and bottoms for placing entry orders and exit strategy to maximize profit. These four forces at work in the marketplace are; Trend, Emotion, Sentiment, and Extreme and each one reinforces the other. The Symphonie Trader System works together like the components of a Symphonie. Alone each instrument has a weak sound, but; when put together the complete symphonie makes beautiful music rich in sound and texture

The four Indicators are:

Symphonie Extreme Indicator *
Symphonie Emotion Indicator
Symphonie Sentiment Indicator *
Symphonie Trendline Indicator

(* - these are prone to repaint in older version version 3.0 extreme is NOT prone to repaint)

Basically, you are following the color changes i n the four indicators and ONLY placing orders (SELL or BUY) when all these indicators all line up pointing in one direction.

Placing an order without confirmation of the 4 signals together will not work as well as waiting for all 4 indicators to tell you when to take action.

Remember confliction in the marketplace is common and will cause you to buy when you should be selling and the reverse. This system seeks to calm the market movement by making showing signals as to the true direction of the market. I attach a screen shot with 3 situations to help you better understand.

As you can see we have the 4 indicators loaded into 4 divided windows.

Symphonie Trendline Indicator - A
Symphonie Extreme Indicator - B
Symphonie Emotion Indicator - C
Symphonie Sentiment Indicator - D

Also I have attached a basic Symphonie System Trade Cycle diagram that show how the theory for Symphonie was developed. Again, Symphonie was not designed to get the tops or bottoms; Symphonie looks to catch the main body of the price action movement.

Money Management Strategy Rules and Guidelines

Proper Money Management skills are essential to becoming good and successful currency trader. Money management is by far the most important skill to master if you want to become successful at trading FOREX. Money management is simply a system you incorporate that will effectively preserve capital while you increase your profits. In other words a good system will help keep you from losing all of your money and help you make money.

Account Ratio System (ARS) and Order Sizing

It is important to maintain a proper account ratio system (ARS) based on the size of your total account balance. This is to ensure that your account does not get overextended and one suffers significant account losses or even a margin call on account causing one to lose all tradable capital in account. To properly do this one need to establish a ratio system based on the 1000 basis ratio rule.

ARS basically states that for every 1000 in an account will be equal to one trade lot allowance of 0.10 lot. Therefore the maximum total trades for a 1000 account would be 0.10 lot(s). Based on this system you would maintain the following ratios.

ARS Ratio System
1000 equals 0.10 lot(s)
2000 equals 0.20 lot(s)
3000 equals 0.30 lot(s)
4000 equals 0.40 lot(s)
5000 equals 0.50 lot(s)
6000 equals 0.60 lot(s)
7000 equals 0.70 lot(s)
8000 equals 0.80 lot(s)
9000 equals 0.90 lot(s)
10000 equals 1.00 lot(s)
etc….

However, this does not mean that one is only allowed to trade one order at a time. This system simply stated that the MAXIUMUM open orders do not exceed the ARS system ratios allowance. So, if one had 5k in account the maximum number of mini lots cannot exceed the 0.50 ARS total. Orders could be organized in any combination desired.

EXAMPLE
5K equals ARS of 0.50 in total open orders
(any combination)
(5) 0.10 lots....
(3) 0.10 lots and (1) 0.20 lot….
(2)0.20 lots and (1) 0.10 lot….
(1)0.20 lot and (1) 0.30 lot….
(1)0.50 lot

ARS keeps a traders maxium risk to 3% or less of ones total markt exposure based on 30 pip stoploss.

Entry Points Strategy

The entry and exit strategy is simple. For placing an order one would wait until you have an extreme spike (opposing colour change) and the other 3 indicators show the same colour in the direction of the extreme value. So, one will execute order at close of all 4 indikators point in same direktion. As an alternate method to better protect ones stress level do not execute a ''markt order'' and utilizy the ''pending order'' function instead.

Why a pending order? Easy; one can avoid the whipsaw pullbacks that normally happens at the start of a Symphonie Signal as price aktion breaks the edges of a range. Some time the edge holds and price aktion reverses that can result in one have a loss order. Pending orders keep one to the edge breaks and with the trend versus chasing price aktion with a markt order. Let the markt come to you and hand you pips. The downside to a pending order is that one is enter the markt at a high price (buying) or lower price (selling) than using markt order. (Usually 7 pips)

Order Account Balance Protection

For this system, I recommend practicing a very conservative order protection loss system. Once an order is executed, immediately assign the order a 50pip stoploss. If the market turns against you, you will only loose a small amount versus if there is no stoploss and it the market move is heavily against you if can be very costly with no stoploss. As an alternate one may use the previous swing high/low for the Stoploss most of the time you will find that this is always less than 50 pips but remember that the smaller/tighter the stoploss the greater the chance of the stoploss being hit by whipsaws.

(Dynamic Stoploss)
The key is to protect your orders as much as possible in effort to minimize losses and maximize gains. Once a order is made place a stoploss immediately. Once the pip count exceeds 30pips positive (market moves 30pips in your favor), move the stoploss to 3pips in front of the order to protect from having any loss on the trade. This will ensure you have atleast a 3 pip profit if there is a sudden change in market conditions.

Alternate Dynamic Stoploss (more labor intense for all timeframes)

Again, the key is to protect your orders as much as possible in effort to minimize losses and maximize gains. Once a order is made place a stoploss immediately. On open orders 30 pip stoploss is assigned. As the pip count exceeds 10pips positive (market moves 10pips in your favor), move the stoploss to breakeven +1 pips in front of the order to protect from having any loss on the trade. As the pip count exceeds 30pips positive (market moves 30pips in your favor), move the stoploss to breakeven +3 pips in front of the order to protect from having any loss on the trade.This will ensure you have atleast a 3 pip profit if there is a sudden change in market conditions.

Yes, in whipsaw action one may get stopped out more often but in those cases it usually means the market is not ready to move in the direction of your order and you can wait on new pricing action that normally means a second entry order that is at a better price than the first because the market was simply not ready.

** - In higher timeframes 15 min it is recommended a 75 pip Stoploss, in 1 hour and above a minimum 100 pip stoploss is recommended. This is only a guideline. Please use Stoploss at levels that you feel most comfortable. However on 100 pips stoploss you will use 1/2 the ARS number as to maximum lotsize.

Exit Strategy

The system exit strategy is simple but here are three possible degrees of exit based on ones level of conservativeness or aggressiveness.

Exit Strategy One. (most conservative)

When theTrend indicator shows an trend value change (i.e. colour change) exit the trade at the close of that candlestick. This strategy makes sure that you get all the profit from a trade in a movement. The downside to this strategy is you are exiting an order when the ends level may not be fully complete and you may miss out on additional profit. If the price action movement is stronger that the cycle extreme shows one would be exiting potentially at the first beginnings of a strong movement and will miss out of the entire movement.

Exit Strategy Two. (Moderate Aggressive)
When the Extreme indicator shows an extreme value change (spike or v3.0 colour change) ) exit one half of the trade at the close of that candlestick. (One caveat.....once you get an extreme spike wait for 3 to 4 bars to see it the Extereme holds or exit on first from version 3.0). If no repaint then exit at close of 4th bar/beginning of 5th. (see post#5177)) This strategy makes sure that you get half of the profit from a trade as the extreme points are reached in a movement. The second half of the order would continue to run until the trendline changes colour. Once the trendline changed colour one would exit at the close of that candlestick. With this strategy half of your order has the potential to gain further if the price action movement is stronger than the extreme point indicated and you could reap the extra movement pips. The downside is that if the extreme is on target and rebounds could hit your 3 pip positive stoploss and loose half your profit.

One caveat.....once you get an extreme value one can wait 3 to 4 bars to see it the Extereme holds. If no repaint then exit at close of 4th bar/beginning of 5th. (see post#5177) or exit at change in extreme value.


Exit Strategy Three. (most aggressive) ‘’the Gambler’’
When all four indicator shows an colour change (spike or v3.0 colour change) one would not exit the order and look to a second indicator order to execute on the new signal. With this strategy you have the potential for further gains if the price action movement is stronger than the extreme point indicated and you could reap all extra movement pips with a full order. The downside is that if the extreme is on target and rebounds the price action could hit your 3 pip positive stoploss and one would lose your potential profit. This exit strategy is also called ''Signal to Signal'' exit. See post #2885

SPECIAL EXCEPTION to Exit Strategy (original version only) This exception applies to all Exit Strategies and supersedes them. When a trade produces an Extreme Spikes before reaching 30 pips....,EXIT THE TRADE IMMEDIATELY.

Symphonie 5% growth Strategy

Take the Symphonie method into a solid growth plan in effort to build ones account and minimize account losses. By using the ARS method you only risk 3% per trade. Combine with a modest 5% for a weekly profit goal. That is right! make a 1% (i.e. 10 pips of profit) per day. If you exceed the 10 pips that is great because it will balance out the bad days when you lose...(trust me it will happen, happens to every one) the overall strategy is to make a total of 50 pips per week of net profit of your account. Very do-able. Now, with the Symphonie method, we draw out a 2 year growth plan. I have attach a spreadsheet that will demonstrate the power of this strategy based on a 1000$ investment over 104 weeks.(i.e. 2 years) It is attached to this post or to post#14318. I think this is a perfekt strategy for those unable to trade full-time.

See 12 months of trading growth plan and what you can achieve Post 15,823.

--------Markt Pattern Recongnition---------

The ability to recognize markt patterns is an important part to ones development as a consistant trader. Using markt pattern recognition and letting Symphonie indikators tell one the entry point and improve win trade ratios.

BabyPips Basic Chart Patterns
http://www.babypips.com/school/chart...hmatterns.html

--------Symphonie Trader Systems Current Indikator Settings---------


Nov 2012 Settings for Symphonie System v3.0.

Extreme indikator
50
50
20

Emotion indikator
7
50.6
3000

Trendline indikator
40, 5

Sentiment indikator
12

Symphonie Matrix v4 Optimizes Settings Matrix

Please see Post 15,842 for settings matrix.

--------Symphonie Trader Tips and Links Section---------
#166 - discusses double down process
#278 - discusses ordering process and stoploss modifications
#300 - discusses false signals and money management
#709 - discusses Double Down Momements or Market Re-Entry.
# 1081 - discusses pattern development.
#1454 - discusses bearflag pattern.
#1552 - discusses using higher in timeframe for confirmation in lower timframe trading sindows to avoid false signals
#1936 - discusses repaint and how to make repaint plays
#2330 - discusses Symphonie Extreme Indikator interpretation
#2449 - discusses alternate signal entry system to avoid whipsaws
#2543 - discusses using the Heiken Ashi Indikator as accent to Symphonie Signals for confirmation. Plus an update to this post #4507.
#2686 - discusses basic design of the Symphonie System.
#2884 - discusses ''Signal to Signal'' strategy with reference statistics
#4061 - discusses the new enhancement to Symphonie Trader System. Symphonie Matrix v1.6
#4527 - discusses the enhancements and new format of trading Symphonie Trader System.
#4913 and #4983 - discusses how to trade using Symphonie Matrix v1.8 and Symphonie Signaler v1.8
#5177 - discusses modifications to Extreme Spike modification which effects Exit Strategy #1.
#6820 - discusses a trading tip for 1 hour timeframe using daily Extreme Spike to trade with trend.
#7330 - discusses the 'Three Keytones'' to successful trading. (a must read for new traders!)
#8129 - discusses the topic of ranging verus trending with interesting statistics for easy identification.
#8647 and #14377 - discusses the Symphonie 60-5 method.
#8702 - discusses the RealJumper method of trading Symphonie for 1 min and 5 min timeframes.
#8888 - discusses ''Triple Top'' forex pattern formation.
#8906 - discusses ''Ascending Wedge'' forex pattern formation.
#9774 - summary on Symphonie and Symphonie 60-5 price action flowchart.
#10216 -summary on the Symphonie Matrix v3.0 and upgrades and new trading templates.
(Latest version is 3.0.1)
#12273 - discusses useage of the 60 Simple Moving Average as addon indikator with Symphonie.
#14019 - using trendlines for better Symphonie Signal entry points and followup post #14039.
#14474 - discusses Support and Resistance - How to determine Breakouts
#15,822 - Announce major upgrade and latest version of Symphonie Trader System Matrix v4.4h
#15,832 - discusses multiple orders and using ARS.
#15,842 also #17,260 - Symphonie v4.4h Optimaization Matrix
#16,901 - Graphical explaination of Symphonie Trader System using Matrix v4.4h

--------UPDATE Account Stats Section---------
The proof of this system is in the actual trading and these numbers do not lie. Just compare results.
The SYMPHONIE SYSTEM............... WORKS!

2011 Trial #1 Account information. Beginning balance on Friday, 19 September 2011 --$3000.00
Trial #1 Account Statistics Report Week 0.5 on Post #60 (3 days)
Trial #1 Account Statistics Report Week 1 on Post #145
Trial #1 Account Statistics Report Week 2 on Post #625
Trial #1 Account Statistics Report Week 3 on Post #1156
Trial #1 Account Statistics Report Week 4 on Post #1496 (Special Update post #1569)
Trial #1 Account Statistics Report Week 5 on Post #1750 (I stop account because I almost triple in one week Trial#1 ends)

2011 Trial #2 Account information. Beginning balance on Friday, 28 Oktober 2011 --$3000.00
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 0 on Post #1989
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 1 on Post #2256
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 2 on Post #2550
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 3 on Post #2868
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 4 on Post #3104
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 5 on Post #3400
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 6 on Post #3498
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 7 on Post #3641
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 8 on Post #3724
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 9 on Post #3981
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 10 on Post #4211
Trial #2 Account Statistics Report Week 11 on Post #4562 (Trial#2 ends)

NEW 2012 Thread Trading Acccount -Beginning balance on Tuesday, 7 Feb. 2012 -$3000.00
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 0 on Post #4912
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 1 on Post #5143
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 2 on Post #5769
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 3 on Post #6705
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 4 on Post #7295
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 5 on Post #8285
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 6 on Post #9100
Trial #3 -Account Statistics Report Week 6 on Post #9557 (Trial#3 ends)

Post #9556 TimeFrame Trading Statistics

--------Symphonie Addon Section---------
-This is a good addon to the Symphonie System you may find helpful. The Heiken Ashi Indikator.
(see post #2543)
- Here one can find the second version of Symphonie Extreme Indikator v2 that marks the repaints of the extreme spikes with a dot after to repaint.
(see post #2545)
- Here one can find the new Symphonie Matrix Indikator that streamlines the four elemental
indikators into one easy to read format. There is no change to the system just in format.
(see post #4297)
- Here one can find the new Symphonie Signaler indikator v1.8 made by lhDT. Good Job!
(see post #4476 and version v1.7 is here post #4314 and version v.1.9beta is here post #7102)
- Symphonie Chart Autorefresher to keep your charts up to date with current information.
(see post #3598) Many thanks to chjungen.
-Additionally, I attach the combination Sentiment and Emotion indikator made by rmyers. Thanks rmyers. It is called Symphonie SenitmentEmotion Combi Indikator v1.0.

--------Special Note---------
PLEASE Do not ask me to provide you signals. Also, regardless how attractive you make it....I will NOT manage anyones account!!!! I have my own accounts to manage and that is plenty for me. before you send me a nice note....DON'T.
symphonie trader basic v2 template.tpl
Symphonie System Indikator PACK.zip
Click to Enlarge

Name: Symphonie Screenshot 227.jpg
Size: 135 KB
Symphonie_Matrix_Indikator_v3.0.1 (old Sentiment).mq4
Click to Enlarge

Name: Symphonie Trading Cycle Diagram.jpg
Size: 120 KB
Symphonie v3.0 Paket.zip
Symphonie System Weekly Growth Plan -5%.xls

sasavisnic67 Sep 16, 2011 2:42pm | Post# 2

Dear friends,
Why do I have a strong feeling SEFC084 Indicator is repainting?

Any experiance?

BR

Evaluator Sep 16, 2011 3:11pm | Post# 3

Dear friends,
Why do I have a strong feeling SEFC084 Indicator is repainting?

Any experiance?

BR
Yes, you are correct!!! If you re-read my intro you would have noticed I said there were repainting in the indicators. But this system is based on 4 indicators not 1 or 2 or even 3 it must be all 4.

Two of the indicators are lagging indicators which means they are backward looking and in the lower timeframes they will repaint. That is why all 4 indicators must be in alignment in their direction before you initiate any order. In the higher timeframes; (1hr and higher) there is little or no repaints because the market price action is more complete.

The key is to watch the directional changes in the pricing action with resolution culminating in all four indicators pointing in one direction. That is the beauty of the system. It helps you identify the topping/bottoming of a price movement and you are then able to get a great entry point for the reversing action.

Pinhead Sep 16, 2011 3:55pm | Post# 4

1 Attachment(s)
Here's MQ4 Goldminer. AKA Forex Trend and Silver Trend. Apparently based on ZigZag indicator.
Goldminer.mq4

Evaluator Sep 16, 2011 4:49pm | Post# 5

Here's MQ4 Goldminer. AKA Forex Trend and Silver Trend. Apparently based on ZigZag indicator.

What is the difference between the ex4 and the mq4? Is this a newer version or more stable with less repaints??

Pinhead Sep 16, 2011 7:31pm | Post# 6

What is the difference between the ex4 and the mq4? Is this a newer version or more stable with less repaints??
MQ4 allows you to use MetaEditor to edit the code, whereas ex.4 files do not. So if you want to make semi-permanent changes to the colors or widths of the bars, e.g., you can go into MetaEditor and fiddle around to your heart's content. That way, they won't revert to their hard-coded (ex.4) styles every time you change time frames or re-load a template.

The code is the same in the MQ4 version and will repaint just like the other. It's just much easier having access to the programming in case you want to alter it. I would imagine, if it's based on ZigZag, that it repaints like crazy. But so does ZZ Semaphor, which can be useful in some strategies. It seems to me that all indicators, lagging or non-, repainting or not, don't tell us anything that our own 2 eyes can't see on their own. OTOH, I can't seem to make a decision without consulting at least 3 of 'em!

With your template, it would appear we'll all be millionaires by the end of the year! Which tells me it's too good to be true. But, I'll see how it acts come Monday. Who knows, maybe you've discovered the elusive

http://www.chumpysclipart.com/images...n_trumpets.jpg Holy Grail http://www.chumpysclipart.com/images...jubilation.jpg

Pinhead Sep 16, 2011 7:57pm | Post# 7

1 Attachment(s)
Here's a (supposedly) non-repainting Silvertrend (Goldminer) indi. It's not coded as a histogram but as arrows. Run it alongside Goldminer and you can see the difference. Not sure what your experience is with indicators, but if you choose to go down that rabbit hole, take a lunch. If you're already down it, do try the mushrooms, I hear they're excellent!
Silver Trend signal.mq4

Pinhead Sep 16, 2011 8:16pm | Post# 8

1 Attachment(s)
While I'm at it, here's MQ4 version of the SEFC indi. It's also know as Bulls-Bears. I read that it has some minor repainting issues.
Bulls-Bears.mq4

Evaluator Sep 18, 2011 2:40pm | Post# 9

PinHead.....

Thanks much for the indicators. I will add them to my collection.

Try them out and see how they work and if better than the ones in my program I will throw the others out and use these. The major problem I have found with indicators are they will repaint. However, some are better than others...

But, when the 4 I use in this system line up in one direction you are almost guaranteed to get 20 pips in that direction or atleast be able to put a stop loss in giving you positive pips ahead of your order point. (i.e. above you buy price or below your sell price) Therefore, you atleast don't loose money on a trade.

Again, thanks!!

Pinhead Sep 18, 2011 3:15pm | Post# 10

PinHead.....

Thanks much for the indicators. I will add them to my collection.

Try them out and see how they work and if better than the ones in my program I will throw the others out and use these. The major problem I have found with indicators are they will repaint. However, some are better than others...

But, when the 4 I use in this system line up in one direction you are almost guaranteed to get 20 pips in that direction or atleast be able to put a stop loss in giving you positive pips ahead of your order point. (i.e. above...
My pleasure.

Evaluator Sep 19, 2011 8:06am | Post# 11

3 Attachment(s)
I have been testing the bullbear and cycle identifiers and it appears to be stable. I have been trading in 5min timeframe for the past 8 hour and have had 8 winning trade and 1 loss for a total win in pips of 88 pips in the positive. These are very short and small pip levels smallest win 2 pips and larger pip win was 23 pips.

Basically I just trade the cycle extreme markers in the direction of the trade colors from bullbears I only trade after as they reach an extreme in the cycle identifier and the color change in the bullbear.

Time to take profit is when the cycle identifier shows an extreme has been reached which is indicated by the spike.

Here is a screenshot and the indicators.

Oh and I turn off the alarm as it become annoying.
Click to Enlarge

Name: bullbearcycle sceenshot.jpg
Size: 129 KB
SEFC Bulls-Bears.mq4
Cycle identifier wAlert1 major.mq4

Evaluator Sep 19, 2011 1:01pm | Post# 12

Update: (trading 5 min window)

Have made 4 more trades in past 4 hours....3 wins 1 loss.

Total winning trades(3).....47pips
Total loosing trades(1).....18pips

Opps...make that 4 trades with another win for 19pips

Evaluator Sep 19, 2011 6:09pm | Post# 13

1 Attachment(s)
Here is another screenshot that shows clear buy signal then clear signal to close buy order and open sell order.
Click to Enlarge

Name: SEFC Cycle Screen 2.jpg
Size: 158 KB

starlimit03 Sep 20, 2011 6:18am | Post# 14

Repainting Issues
 
hi,
As much as I seem to appreciate your charts, I wud want you to address the issue of repainting of the Cycle Identifier. According to your charts,(if i get you right), a long order shud be taken if the cycle identifier spikes downward with a blue line at the same time the Bull bear shud also be in Blue with the Gold miner also in blue . If so when( on what candle does the cycle identifier stops repainting)?

Evaluator Sep 20, 2011 10:12am | Post# 15

1 Attachment(s)
hi,
As much as I seem to appreciate your charts, I wud want you to address the issue of repainting of the Cycle Identifier. According to your charts,(if i get you right), a long order shud be taken if the cycle identifier spikes downward with a blue line at the same time the Bull bear shud also be in Blue with the Gold miner also in blue . If so when( on what candle does the cycle identifier stops repainting)?
In the 5 min timeframe I have found that there is some repainting. Howerver in the higher timeframes (30min and up) there is no repainting.

Also, I if you follow the system even thought one indicator repaint it will recover in the direction of the change in trend. I also use a 50pip stoploss that has never been hit. The only loss I have had is when there is a another extreme indication and a change in trend. I just close the order and open a new order of the trend indicated. So, even though one indicator may repaint it will recover and you should be on the correct side of the trade. In other words, stay true to the system and you should make positive pips.

You are correct in that you make an order when there is a spike with color and the bullbear indicator (the bars) change direction in the direction the cycle indicator shows. You would make and order at the close of the first bullbear bar in the direction the cycle indicator shows.

However, just because the spike shows a direction change does not mean that is when you take the order. You only take the order when both indicators have a bar close in the same direction. See graph example below and please let me know if you have questions:
Click to Enlarge

Name: SEFC Cycle Screen 3.jpg
Size: 143 KB

stricky1967 Sep 20, 2011 10:26am | Post# 16

In the 5 min timeframe I have found that there is some repainting. Howerver in the higher timeframes (30min and up) there is no repainting.

Also, I if you follow the system even thought one indicator repaint it will recover in the direction of the change in trend. I also use a 50pip stoploss that has never been hit. The only loss I have had is when there is a another extreme indication and a change in trend. I just close the order and open a new order of the trend indicated. So, even though one indicator may repaint it will recover...

But your sa_mtie is red , not blue in the last example of a long trade?

All 4 indis to line up?

Evaluator Sep 20, 2011 10:36am | Post# 17

Trading Update: (trading 5 min window)

Have made 3 more trades in since post#12....3 wins 0 loss.

Total of winning trades(3).....72pips
Total of loosing trades(0)..... 0pips

Overall Tally:

Winning Trades: 12
Pip Total: 207
Loosing Trades: 3
Pip Total: 41

Overall Total: 166 pips positive

Evaluator Sep 20, 2011 10:47am | Post# 18

But your sa_mtie is red , not blue in the last example of a long trade?

All 4 indis to line up?
stricky1967.

You are correct!!! I was testing just 2 of the indicators given to me in this thread by pinhead in the 5 min window.

The system still holds for the 4 indicators.

However, to clearify, if I had waited for the line to turn blue I would have gotten a better price because there was another downturn later down the track followed by a uptrend in the EURUSD when the line turned blue if you go back and look at today chart in the 5 min window you will see it.

So using this chart was probably a bad example and caused confusion. My apoligies. We humans do make mistakes from time to time.

However, you are correct waiting for the other indicator would have been best because the entry point was a better price.

stricky1967 Sep 20, 2011 10:53am | Post# 19

stricky1967.

You are correct!!! I was testing just 2 of the indicators given to me in this thread by pinhead in the 5 min window.

The system still holds for the 4 indicators.

However, to clearify, if I had waited for the line to turn blue I would have gotten a better price because there was another downturn later down the track followed by a uptrend in the EURUSD when the line turned blue if you go back and look at today chart in the 5 min window you will see it.

So using this chart was probably a bad example and caused...

If you have time it would be great if you could post some charts of todays trades. Would help a lot, thankyou

Evaluator Sep 20, 2011 11:04am | Post# 20

1 Attachment(s)
stricky1967,

You must be reading my mind. I was already working on it.

Here is a better chart to use from TODAY. I apoligize for the size but in the 5 min. timeframe it is kinda small.

I think this is a better example. As you can see from the intial buy entry point; there was still some whipsaw motion culminating in another buy entry point. However, by the time the opposite extreme was reached you would have made positive pips. (in other words if you are a gamble that could be a double down position)
Click to Enlarge

Name: SEFC Cycle Screen 4.jpg
Size: 182 KB


© Forex Factory