Forex Factory (https://www.forexfactory.com/)
-   Interactive Trading (https://www.forexfactory.com/forum/137-interactive-trading)
-   -   Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD) (https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/108462-planetary-cycles-trading-eurusd)

Suryananda Mar 26, 2020 12:23pm | Post# 11141

{quote} It is 90% based on the period studied... as we all know, past performance does not necessarily mean future guarantees. It is easy to verify though, open a chart and count the pips.
Jupiter with Pluto only has two square aspects every 12.8 years.
At least 500 operations are necessary in order to make reliable statistics. This greatly limits the application of statistics to astrology....

jnevins Mar 26, 2020 1:26pm | Post# 11142

Agreed that the sample size is too small for it to be meaningful. I did include conjunctions and oppositions in the daily chart I posted.

Regal2k Mar 26, 2020 7:06pm | Post# 11143

Ephiramus(sp)

Anybody have a reliable source of Ephiramus data going back to early 1700s?


https://www.udemy.com/course/build-y...t=225#overview

Just downloaded this course for beginner EA programming, wish me luck gentleman.

Ilovepippin Mar 27, 2020 11:35am | Post# 11144

{quote} Jupiter with Pluto only has two square aspects every 12.8 years. At least 500 operations are necessary in order to make reliable statistics. This greatly limits the application of statistics to astrology....
Well, this is the Planetary Cycles thread, not the statistical thread.
If you want to share something meaningful about statistics related to planetary cycles, then please do it here.
Don't keep posting repeated messages about how great and necessary statistics is and cutting off posters without meaningful data to back it up.
Thank you.

Ilovepippin Mar 27, 2020 11:36am | Post# 11145

Ephemeris:

https://www.astro.com/swisseph/swepha_e.htm

parisboy Mar 27, 2020 12:33pm | Post# 11146

{quote} You have to work harder making statistics with a rational basis. Mr. Gann, Hurst, Wyckoff, Nostradamus, Christ, or Muhammad said too many things. But it is useless if it is not verifiable. We live in the scientific age. The dark ages of mythomania are behind us. .
All readers of your informative posts have to thank you a thousand times for your hard statiscal work which has allowed you to warn us beforehand of the recent drop in the market(s)

jnevins Mar 27, 2020 5:34pm | Post# 11147

1 Attachment(s)
End of week recap: 480 pips based on post 11,124, March 21.
Click to Enlarge

Name: Capture.PNG
Size: 36 KB

Suryananda Mar 27, 2020 5:58pm | Post# 11148

{quote} Well, this is the Planetary Cycles thread, not the statistical thread. If you want to share something meaningful about statistics related to planetary cycles, then please do it here. Don't keep posting repeated messages about how great and necessary statistics is and cutting off posters without meaningful data to back it up. Thank you.
Sorry, I only send statistical data by personal message.
For posts with statistical predictions on this forum ask Parisboy. That guy knows everything.
Greetings.
.

parisboy Mar 27, 2020 6:01pm | Post# 11149

{quote} Sorry, I only send statistical data by personal message. For posts with statistical predictions on this forum ask Parisboy. That guy knows everything. Greetings. .
You are just a clown and a coward

Suryananda Mar 27, 2020 6:59pm | Post# 11150

1 Attachment(s)
{quote} Well, this is the Planetary Cycles thread, not the statistical thread. If you want to share something meaningful about statistics related to planetary cycles, then please do it here. Don't keep posting repeated messages about how great and necessary statistics is and cutting off posters without meaningful data to back it up. Thank you.
On Sunday 03/22/2020 I uploaded these predictions for the following week in the DJIA.
Profits: 923.66 points; + 6.36%
... {image} .
Prediction for the DJIA 03/23/2020 to 03/27/2020.
Click to Enlarge

Name: 2020-03-27 22_47_51-Window.png
Size: 11 KB
Have to study and work much more. Gann and the Bible say too many irrational things.

The data source.
https://es.finance.yahoo.com/quote/%...story?p=%5EDJI
.

MoreYummy Mar 27, 2020 10:32pm | Post# 11151

{quote} On Sunday 03/22/2020 I uploaded these predictions for the following week in the DJIA. Profits: 923.66 points; + 6.36% {quote} Prediction for the DJIA 03/23/2020 to 03/27/2020. {image} Have to study and work much more. Gann and the Bible say too many irrational things. The data source. https://es.finance.yahoo.com/quote/%...story?p=%5EDJI .
How do you do your prediction? Using planetary method or something else?

jnevins Mar 27, 2020 11:02pm | Post# 11152

{quote} On Sunday 03/22/2020 I uploaded these predictions for the following week in the DJIA. Profits: 923.66 points; + 6.36% {quote} Prediction for the DJIA 03/23/2020 to 03/27/2020. {image} Have to study and work much more. Gann and the Bible say too many irrational things. The data source. https://es.finance.yahoo.com/quote/%...story?p=%5EDJI .
Thank you for posting a follow up account of your predictions...

Ilovepippin Mar 28, 2020 9:44am | Post# 11153

{quote} I did check out every Jupiter/Saturn hard aspect going back to June 2006... all but one were up reactions... EUR/USD Daily
Can you do more complecated cycle analysis, such as:

- Moon-Mars conjunctions while Mars is in retrograde
- Venus conjunctions while in combustion
- Helio Mars Venus conjunctions per astrological sign
- Mercury retrograde per sign
- Venus conjunct sun after a solar eclipse

Just to name a few.

Ilovepippin Mar 28, 2020 10:00am | Post# 11154

1 Attachment(s)
Gann and the Bible say too many irrational things. The data source.
Can you prove that statistically?

Not that I think Gann is "the" answer, it is just a small piece in the bigger puzzel but he did test his methods and has proof.
Statistically significant maybe as sample size was over 500, evidence that whatever he did worked.
And herein lies the problem: In order to say that Gann is bogus you need to test his technique and in order to do that you need to know exacly what he knew.
So unless you know what he knew and have tested that statistically, you cannot say that it was all bogus.
And thats the last I will say about it. Fin, ja basta.

Click to Enlarge

Name: Trading Record Capture.JPG
Size: 72 KB

vinz3316 Mar 28, 2020 10:57am | Post# 11155

{quote} On Sunday 03/22/2020 I uploaded these predictions for the following week in the DJIA. Profits: 923.66 points; + 6.36% {quote} Prediction for the DJIA 03/23/2020 to 03/27/2020. {image} Have to study and work much more. Gann and the Bible say too many irrational things. The data source. https://es.finance.yahoo.com/quote/%...story?p=%5EDJI .

I didn't know you have losses

Hhhhmmm quite confusing, after all GANN system and its successful practitioner have results shown some consistency. So how hahaha who's who to believe?

jnevins Mar 28, 2020 11:58am | Post# 11156

2 Attachment(s)
{quote} Can you do more complecated cycle analysis, such as: - Moon-Mars conjunctions while Mars is in retrograde - Venus conjunctions while in combustion - Helio Mars Venus conjunctions per astrological sign - Mercury retrograde per sign - Venus conjunct sun after a solar eclipse Just to name a few.

Yes, Timing Solution is especially robust in this area... Screen shot 1 shows the Astro tools available through one of the editors....

#2 shows Moon-Mars conjunctions, the highlighted green line is when Mercury is in Rx.

Here is an article on planets in retrograde by Timing Solution author, Sergey Tarasov.. http://www.timingsolution.com/TS/Study/retrograde.pdf
Click to Enlarge

Name: Capture.PNG
Size: 41 KB
Click to Enlarge

Name: Capture1.PNG
Size: 52 KB

parisboy Mar 28, 2020 12:23pm | Post# 11157

2 Attachment(s)
{quote} On Sunday 03/22/2020 I uploaded these predictions for the following week in the DJIA. Profits: 923.66 points; + 6.36% {quote} Prediction for the DJIA 03/23/2020 to 03/27/2020. {image} Have to study and work much more. Gann and the Bible say too many irrational things. The data source. https://es.finance.yahoo.com/quote/%...story?p=%5EDJI .

Statisticians say that 5 data is too small a sample to be significant. Hence we will wait the next results
Click to Enlarge

Name: SURYA PREDICTIONS.jpg
Size: 23 KB
Name:  SURYA RESULTS VS PREDICTIONS.jpg
Views: 482
Size:  19 KB

jnevins Mar 28, 2020 1:50pm | Post# 11158

1 Attachment(s)
Outlook for next week... Up week in store.

The Blue line is Venus-Venus, Right Ascension, 3rd harmonic, 100% smooth orb, Inverted.

The Green line is Pluto - Saturn, Phase, 94th harmonic, 200% smooth orb also Inverted.
Click to Enlarge

Name: Capture.PNG
Size: 18 KB

sponge Mar 28, 2020 2:22pm | Post# 11159

Outlook for next week... Up week in store. The Blue line is Venus-Venus, Right Ascension, 3rd harmonic, 100% smooth orb, Inverted. The Green line is Pluto - Saturn, Phase, 94th harmonic, 200% smooth orb also Inverted. {image}
Hi jnevins, have you kept a record of your EU predictions?

What a great run you have had

I love the spooky stuff

jnevins Mar 28, 2020 2:30pm | Post# 11160

2 Attachment(s)
{quote} Hi jnevins, have you kept a record of your EU predictions? What a great run you have had I love the pooky stuff
Here is a document showing each week for 2019... 3 losses, 49 wins... 2 of those were flat.

ctrl-click on links to open

Update: I just put together 2020 results... 12 weeks, 10 wins, 2 losses
TS Predictions, 2019.docx
2020 predictions TS.docx


© Forex Factory