Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) Discussion 2 replies
Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) and background 5 replies
What is the best VSA (Volume Spread Analysis) system/indicator? 1 reply
Volume Spread Analysis (VSA) and the EURUSD 3 replies
VSA Volume Spread Analysis: No demand and accumlation 2 replies
DislikedNot sure if I have gotten any better over the weekend totally understanding how to read VSA but, I think I am heading in the right direction....using my TA indicators and the help with VSA I was able to take 90 pips out of the AUD/USD tonight. I have never been able to predict the absolute bottom but, with the help of VSA I NAILED IT!!!Ignored
DislikedToday on USDGBP there's a interesting downtrend, noted that all big volumes week last max, max contract and last day, are closed, below this are the VSA confirms the downtrend.
See that now price is under today max vol, wait to see if can go down again or stop downtrend, probably it could move down again cause there aren't big obstacle under this level.
LuboIgnored
DislikedPlease don't let the previous post from that member scare you, VSA works and it works good..I'm placing trades using this strategy proof that it's working.Ignored
DislikedStill don't get it why the MT4 Volume indicator should be of any help.
If you compare different Brokers you will get totaly different signals.
Please spare me with the "Activity Indicator Crap". Especially on
low timeframes the size and shape of the volume bars will vary even
greater if you compare them.
Same Pair Same Zoom Level, different Broker.Ignored
DislikedIf so it should be an easy task to explain why.
And given the fact that broker volumes on MT4 are totally random what makes you so sure that your broker is the one with the tick volume that works best?Ignored
DislikedIf so it should be an easy task to explain why.
And given the fact that broker volumes on MT4 are totally random what makes you so sure that your broker is the one with the tick volume that works best?Ignored
DislikedOkay so whats your point? I think when we setup this forum it was established already. If you've read Tom Williams book you would know that he clearly explains where no volume is available use tick volume. I haven't seen you post one trade using this VSA strategy yet your coming in here claiming something that really is of no substance..Before you people come dogging a system lets see you post some charts,were are your trades! I've posted several charts showing how I clearly trade VSA using the tick volume. Thiers no ta indicators or nothing, so...Ignored
Disliked................................
Futures Volume might be better because everyone is working with the same data there since it comes from
a real exchange. Like price quotes.
Everyone has the same information. That's my main point. No one is working with the same volume data if you
are looking at MT4.Ignored
DislikedI think the same. But sometimes, especially on asian session and out of CME open time, when on future there is really little volume, the spot volume may work better.
What do u think about?
Lubo.Ignored
Disliked..................
Drawing conclusions becomes impossible. You need information that is completely universal in order to use it as a trading tool. Like your normal price chart. Everybroker will have the same type of candle at the same time displayed to all traders.
On a central stock exchange every has access to exactly the same volume data making it valuable for trading.Ignored