Home
Search Forums
Keywords:
Search Titles Only
User Name:
Exact Match
Show Results As:
Advanced Options
View Poll Results: Profitable Strategy?
Yes 182 79.13%
No 48 20.87%
Voters: 230. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
  #1393  
Old Oct 27, 2009 7:53am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fxpilot View Post
This trading strategy continues to work well for both London and US breakout sessions. The Quantum research paper attached somewhere in this thread has certainly provided great statistics as to why this strategy should continue to do well. Great job everyone.

fxpilot
Hi guys - I am knew to this site (this is my first post).

I have read through this whole thread and there's now so many different variations. I have been trading this system using the 5am to 7.15 candle, so this means i don't take a trade till after 7.30 (hope that makes sense). I use the 15 min charts for this and take the range between these candles for my stop, however i never exceed 40 pips, so if the range happens to be say 64 or whatever, i still only set it at 40. I have a profit limit of 30 and that's it. For Oct i have had 14 wins and 5 losses, so total pips for the month so far is 220pips for a hours work a day.

I have also back tested this manually and get the following results:

Sept 08 ? 17 wins / 5 losses
Oct 08 ? 16 wins / 6 losses
Nov 08 ? 16 wins / 4 losses
Dec 08 ? 16 wins / 5 losses
Jan 09 ? 15 wins / 5 losses
Feb 09 = 15 wins / 5 losses
Mar 09 ? 16 wins / 6 losses
Apr 09 ? 16 wins / 6 losses
May 09 ? 17 wins / 4 losses
June 09 ? 14 wins / 8 losses
July 09 ? 18 wins / 4 losses
Aug 09 ? 17 wins / 4 losses
Sep 09 ? 18 wins / 4 losses

Not bad for an hours work.

Please correct me if you think any of this is wrong or you think that another way is better, i'm always open to suggestions on improvements etc.

FXpilot - You mention something about Quantum research that suggests that this system should continute to do well. What is that mate, if you don't mind me asking?

Well that's my first contribution, hope to get some feedback, thanks.
Reply With Quote
  #1395  
Old Oct 27, 2009 9:33am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Smile

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Hi Scull

If you say 5 am.

Is that Gmt or Lomdon time ?

If it is London time, do you change with daylight saving ?

Maybe you can post a chart to explain.

Thanks and welcome to the thread.

Hi there - i trade London time because i'm simply trying to catch the London Breakout, so on a very basic level all i am trying to do is catch the movement at the beginning of the working day in the UK (so basically when the big players are starting to trade in the morning).

I do not get involved in the daylight changes, just use 5am till 7.15am, 15min chart, using IG index quick charts, very simple. No indicators, nothing, just draw your lines at 5am and 7.15am, which actually closes at 7.30 (check clock on laptop) and that's it.

Good results, very simple, small amount of time at PC.
Reply With Quote
  #1397  
Old Oct 27, 2009 10:00am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Thanks FXpilot - I'll take a look at the research now, cheers once again.
Reply With Quote
  #1400  
Old Oct 27, 2009 11:24am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by maq View Post
did u use a buffer zone?
Sorry forgot to mention i use 7 + spread for a BUY and just 7 for a SELL.
Reply With Quote
  #1403  
Old Oct 27, 2009 3:08pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by gregart View Post
Hi, thanks for your feedback, i am not sure to understand crearly your strategy, can you post an chart with you entries ? thanks

Greg
Hi Greg - The strategy is exactly the same principle as the thread starter (1st post), please refer to that thread. However i simply use the 5am to 7.15 candle, which actually closeS at 7.30 REAL TIME. Draw your box, same as thread starter mentions in post 1, but only difference is add 7 + spread for a BUY and just -7 for a SELL.

This strategy has been taken to bits, so don't really want to get into another debate over candles, times, etc, etc. It is simply exactly the same as thread starter, but slightly different times, set SL & PT and the inclusion of a buffer. You can obviously go for more pips if you want, depends on your trading style, but beleive it or not trading can be as simple as you want it to be and that's what i like.

Thanks.
Reply With Quote
  #1407  
Old Oct 28, 2009 3:26am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by gregart View Post
Hi, thanks for your reply, i use same set of this thread 5 to 7:15 and 7 pips buffer like you, the thing than i don't understand is the "closes at 7:30" do you mean you close the open orders at 7:30 ? you stop the EA at 7:30 if the orders were not triggered ? or something else ? sorry for that .

thanks

Greg
Hi Greg - I was trying to explain to people that i take the 7.15 candle on the 15min chart, which closes at 7.30 REAL TIME. For example right now i have set my box lines at 5am and 7.15, it is now as i write this, 7.25, but still haven't set my pending orders because the 7.15 candle on IG actually closes at 7.30, so hasn't closed yet. That's the best way i can describe it mate, sorry.
Reply With Quote
  #1408  
Old Oct 28, 2009 3:28am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Smile

Quote:
Originally Posted by Austinc1972 View Post
Scullmeister - great simple strategy - I am always a big fan of KISS
One question that I have for you (and please excuse my ignorance if I have missed your answer on this thread): do you just trade one currency pair?
Have you tried other pairs? And if so, does the basic strategy stay the same?

Thanks in advance for your response

Happy pipping

Austin
Hi Austin - I just trade GU and that's it. With compounding and good MM you should see decent profits.

I am confused why traders have to try and trade as many pairs as poss along with as many systems/strategies, become a master of one first, familiarise yourself with it and then take onboard another imo.
Reply With Quote
  #1410  
Old Oct 28, 2009 4:21am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
So for today.

Buy at 1.6393
Sell at 1.6336

TP 30pips
SL 40 pips

Is this correct ?

Yes more or less, i have the following:

Buy at 1.6394
Sell at 1.6337.6

TP 30pips
SL 40 pips

I use IG quick charts, so may be a slight difference, but don't worry about a pip or two, as it's not an exact science. Had a loss on Mon and a win yesterday, so lets see what today brings.

I have backtested best i can and written down in my journal why the breakout has losers some days and it's mostly down to either rangy market conditions or news announcements that didn't quite go our way.

But at the end of the day you have to accept losers as well in trading, so as long as we keep them down to a minimum, then i just accept them and move onto the next day.

I have a 75% to 80% hit rate using it this way, so plenty of profitable days to be had.
Reply With Quote
  #1415  
Old Oct 28, 2009 5:57am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
hi guys,

have just thrown Scull's method on a backtest of this year. 2 lots of results attached, 1 with an 85 ema filter added and 1 without.

the higher result is with the ema filter

cheers

Grant

ps had to zip the files as they would attach
What is an EMA filter, these results seem pretty nice to me.
Reply With Quote
  #1420  
Old Oct 28, 2009 6:19am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
i only trade in the direction of the 85ema, so if price is below the ema go short and if price is above the ema go long. if ema value is about the same as price i pass that day...

also in that backtest i used 7 buffer long and 5 short...

your exact buffers are in this test, long i made 10 to include spread and short 7 with orders canceled at 10 am gmt, no ema filter and 1 trade per day.

again risk was 1% per trade

cheers

Grant
So in your opinion what is the best method as per backtest results?
Reply With Quote
  #1421  
Old Oct 28, 2009 6:26am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
i only trade in the direction of the 85ema, so if price is below the ema go short and if price is above the ema go long. if ema value is about the same as price i pass that day...

also in that backtest i used 7 buffer long and 5 short...

your exact buffers are in this test, long i made 10 to include spread and short 7 with orders canceled at 10 am gmt, no ema filter and 1 trade per day.

again risk was 1% per trade

cheers

Grant
By the way i do not cancel orders at all, just let it run.
Reply With Quote
  #1423  
Old Oct 28, 2009 6:37am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
Scull,

that is a work in progress, there are so many different combinations of time, Tp, SL, move stop to BE, ema on or off...

also depends on your risk appetite..

my method backtest attached, this is a work in progress still though...

if anyone (within reason) has settings they want tested pm me.

cheers

Grant
What are your settings mate?
PT?
SL?
What time do you draw your lines?
Buffers if any?
Timeframes, i.e. 15min, 30min, 60min charts, etc, etc.
Do you cancel order once the other has activated?
Reply With Quote
  #1427  
Old Oct 28, 2009 8:34am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fumiryu View Post
Hi Scullmeister,

How long do you leave the pending order open? Or do you close the pending orders perhaps after a few hours if not triggered on any side?

Also, do you use OCO order? I.E If buy gets triggered, cancel sell order?

Today's market seemed quite slow, trade was not triggered at this point of time when I posted this message.

Thanks.
Never close it, just ride it out, until your PT or SL is hit. As soon as one is activated, close the other out, that's it.
Reply With Quote
  #1431  
Old Oct 28, 2009 11:27am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
hi guys,

have just thrown Scull's method on a backtest of this year. 2 lots of results attached, 1 with an 85 ema filter added and 1 without.

the higher result is with the ema filter

cheers

Grant

ps had to zip the files as they would attach
Grant thanks for doing this, but it is imperative that this is correct. I am always weary of EA's, for example on Mon of this week using my exact settings i made a loss using IG. However if i would have used say an MT4 chart or a few others i would have actually made a profit, so i ask what are these EA's taken from???

Do they account for spread?
What data is it taken from?
Are the settings EXACTLY same as my first post?

My manual backtest show reasonably consistent profits, some months better than others, but overall from Sept 08 it has been consistent. I have manually backtested this (it took me ages) using Tess charts.

In your first post you said you had carried out an EA same as my method, but then after a few questions the method was not the same it was with a 7 buffer for buy and 5 for sell. Are the times the same as mine or are they yours, i.e. 4-6am gmt (winter) 3-5 am gmt (summer). Bear in mind i do not use GMT, i.e. change with daylight savings etc, etc, it is London time always, i never change it. Plus i never close a trade, keep it open always and let it run, some you win, some you lose, that's the way it goes.

Thanks for doing an EA, but i want to ensure that the info is 100% correct, trust you understand. Cheers.
Reply With Quote
  #1442  
Old Oct 29, 2009 3:53am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Scull

I am also of the old school. Been doing this for over 7 years and all backrest by hand. I agree it takes ages, but if I can see it I trust it.

That is why I am impressed with your work.

If you do the hard work the pips will follow you.

Hi Matlobien - I agree 100%. The EA's are good, but unless i physically do the backtest myself, so i know 100% that the parameters are correct then i will stick with my method for now and simply forward test it. If i start noticing things are changing i will simply tweak accordingly.

Bottom line is that done correctly and simply breakout strategies in general are profitable and more importantly consistent.

Lets see what today brings. Thanks.
Reply With Quote
  #1443  
Old Oct 29, 2009 3:58am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by gregart View Post
Hi Grant, thanks for sharing your backtest, regarding the results I think i will stay with my monday trades only, you can find attached my results, same account, period, lots than yours. I use the wtlam EA
Good results mate, but i can see that people are now going to start to get confused with which method this is. Can you please let us know the following:

PT=
SL=
What time do you draw your lines=
What days do you trade=
Do you close your trade at any point=
Do you have set SL and PT, or do you move SL to b/e after a certain time=

Only answer this if you want to share of course mate. Thanks.
Reply With Quote
  #1448  
Old Oct 29, 2009 4:45am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobcat2 View Post
Hi Scullmeister,

Thanks for sharing your version of this trading strategy. My trade on Oanda was a loss tonight. If I'm not mistaken, that's 3 losses out of the last 4 trades. What's the worst string of losses you have encountered?

Losses are to be expected, but this is not an auspicious start for me.
Hi there, this is exactly my point about EA's and backtesting.

I have a loss on Mon, win on Tue, win on Wed and my order hasn't activated today mate.
Reply With Quote
  #1451  
Old Oct 29, 2009 5:35am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
scull

4-6am gmt (winter) 3-5 am gmt (summer)
SL 25
TP 75
move SL to BE @25
buffer long 7
buffer short 5

remember the EA cant distinguish between the gmt switch that just happened so the box time through summer for those results was 3-5 am gmt

cheers
Just sent you a PM mate, thanks.
Reply With Quote
  #1455  
Old Oct 29, 2009 7:49am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
Scull,

just replied

cheers

Grant
Cheers Grant, just PM'd you again mate.
Reply With Quote
  #1456  
Old Oct 29, 2009 7:55am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
Scull,

just replied

cheers

Grant
Emailed you i mean.
Reply With Quote
  #1465  
Old Oct 30, 2009 5:37am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Scull

What is your experience on NFP Fridays with this system ?

I usually do not trade them - too many bad experiences.

Thanks

I just trade every day mate to be honest. Today wasn't too good, but these days occur.

So for this month i finish +170 for the month.
Reply With Quote
  #1467  
Old Oct 30, 2009 7:51am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

I have read through all of this thread and just have a small issue. Fed seems to have this method nailed more or less, his times are 2am and 5am GMT. Does this mean he takes into account the change in Winter and Summer months, if so what are the current timeframes London time?

Is this method still working, i.e. TP1 at 30, TP2, try bag an extra 40 if poss, but move stop to b/e. I am a little confused as to how you can move stop to b/e on the second trade immediately because if it hits 30 and moves your direction say 5 pips, are you then supposed to move your stop up/down, what if it retraces say 10/15 pips, but then moves back in your direction you would have been stopped out or am i missing something???
Reply With Quote
  #1470  
Old Oct 30, 2009 9:55am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobcat2 View Post
Scull,

Both trades are entered at the same point. When TP1 is hit and makes +30 pips profit, TP2 is also ahead by +30 pips. Break-even is then set at that point (would be the same effect as a 30 pip SL). You don't move it from BE, and you have 30 pips of breathing room. You don't move the SL after that. Let the trade hit either SL or TP just like you are doing with your version of the breakout.

Hope this helps...

Excellant, thx for your explanation, i understand now, so if it hits your SL, then you just make the first TP of 30 pips.

What are the best times to trade currently. What time is that London time as i am from England?

Cheers again, much appreciated.
Reply With Quote
  #1471  
Old Oct 30, 2009 10:56am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
What a crazy spiky day on the GU.

I have tried different Tp and SL levels, but feel that Scull have a very good one here.

What you want in forex is consistency, not massive pips.

Usually good systems last +/- 6 months. So don't be fooled by only 170 pips this month. So far it did not loose in 1 year.

Greed kills you in this business.

I agree with that mate.

You can also use the system with times set at 5am and 7am, 15min chart, instead of 7.15am and set SL at the range between the high and low, but never exceed 60 pips. It seems to work alright as well. For example the one that some people lost yesterday would have been a winner doing it this way.

I think it's a case of being flexible, keeping a journal and changing as and when required with the market conditions.

Anyway have a good weekend all, and heres to next week.
Reply With Quote
  #1475  
Old Oct 31, 2009 5:42am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobcat2 View Post
Hi Scull,

Yes...if price hits the SL after you have pocketed 30 pips, then you end up with a net TP of 30 pips. Personally, I have never done well with that scenario and is the reason I don't like using it. Why?

When you split your lots into 2 trades and take the profit at TP1 for 30 pips, you have effectively doubled your risk. How so? Let's say your risk to reward ratio is 1:1. Your SL = 30 pips and your TP = 30 pips. Overall, you have risked 60 pips (30 per trade), and now that you have taken your TP1 for trade #1, you set trade #2 for Breakeven....
Hi Bobcat,

Thanks for your interest.

I 100% agree with you, i just take 30 pips per trade and that's me done for the day. Nice early finish, then got rest of the day to do your own thing, or work or whatever.

You can either stick with 40SL and 7.15 candle or use 60SL and 7.00 candle, or even a combination of the two. But remember it's not always 60SL, it's the range between the high and the low. So if the range was 44 for example, then your SL would be 44, if it was 27, it would be 27SL, however if the range is over 60, so say 76 or whatever, then it's not a 76SL, it would be 60. I would never but an SL over 60 pips because then you are risking too much for the initial 30 pips you are trying to take from the market.

You will loose some if you stick with 40 because the market may retrace over 40 pips then go onto make a profit (happens a lot). But then again the losers that shoot in the opposite direction, using 40 pips will potentially save you 20 pips, if that makes sense.

For example this month using 30PT and range between high and low for SL(never exceeding 60 pips), using 7.00am candle i have made: 17 wins, 5 losses = 229 pips for the month. Some months this strategy is better, sometimes it's the other. Just got to be flexible i guess mate.

Hope that helps. (sort of, LOL)

Just have a play, keep records and see what suits you.
Reply With Quote
  #1476  
Old Oct 31, 2009 5:47am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scullmeister View Post
Hi Bobcat,

Thanks for your interest.

I 100% agree with you, i just take 30 pips per trade and that's me done for the day. Nice early finish, then got rest of the day to do your own thing, or work or whatever.

You can either stick with 40SL and 7.15 candle or use 60SL and 7.00 candle, or even a combination of the two. But remember it's not always 60SL, it's the range between the high and the low. So if the range was 44 for example, then your SL would be 44, if it was 27, it would be 27SL, however if the range is over 60, so say 76 or whatever,...
Sorry made a mistake, it was 15 wins, 6 losses = 139 pips.
Reply With Quote
  #1481  
Old Nov 2, 2009 3:51am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Great start to the week.

Yep, not bad mate.

I set my SL to 60 today due to the big move earlier, but didn't need it anyway.
Reply With Quote
  #1483  
Old Nov 2, 2009 5:39am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by wltam View Post
not good on GJ...
Unfortunate mate, i don't trade GJ.
Reply With Quote
  #1491  
Old Nov 3, 2009 3:42am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Well, Tuesday turned out to be a 30 pipper.

Another 30 pips bagged, well done everyone, just stick with it.
Reply With Quote
  #1505  
Old Nov 4, 2009 9:28am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
GU winner again.

Yep good result, stay grounded though, we are due a loser.

But 3 out of 3 this month is a good start nonetheless.
Reply With Quote
  #1528  
Old Nov 7, 2009 7:12am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Haha - how i love these 20 page debates over trading times.

For my strategy i am simply catching the breakout of the London open, which is at 8am, so my lines are drawn at 5am and 7.15am LONDON TIME.

Buffer 10 for long, buffer 7 for short, now using the range as my SL, never exceeding 50 or 60 depending on the market condition with a PT of +30.

Can't get simpler than that cheekos.

Happy trading, i look forward to all the posts about where my lines are drawn again, LOL.
Reply With Quote
  #1532  
Old Nov 7, 2009 11:31am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Reply With Quote
  #1534  
Old Nov 8, 2009 6:04am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by maq View Post
scull a few questions

1. how long have you been trading this breakout time frame
2. which broker do u use
3. how much backtesting did you trading this
4. which broker did u use for backtest
Hi -
1 - About 4 months live.
2 - IG Index
3 - Right back to Sep 08
4 - Tess (TUFXP Software) - manual backtest.

Remember the strategy is only 50% of my trading. If there are high impact news announcements out then i monitor the trade and may move my SL where appropriate. I may even exit a trade if i think its going to go the other way, just so i at least take a bit of profit. I sometimes set my SL to the ranges of the high/low and i may even take a few more pips if the indicators are showing me that we are in a potential trend. I will also lower my risk sometimes depending on what announcements are out.

Imo having a system is great, but you have to use a bit of common sense as well. Combine that with a decent breakout method and you should bring in consistent profits per month.

For example Thur i moved my stop to b/e due to the high impact news announcement that came out and we were still in a trade and luckily didn't need it as it went on to make 30pips and on Fri i came out at b/e because the market was trending and it was NFP, i also lowered my risk for this day as well.

I personally think if you stick to a pretty decent breakout method, mix a little common sense in there and you should be ok.

Hope that helps and these are simply my opinions of course, doesn't mean it's right, it's whatever suits you.
Reply With Quote
  #1537  
Old Nov 8, 2009 9:12am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by maq View Post
scull about ig index are they not spread + control risk GSL + 3

tess = is this software the one advertised by canbury publishing i guy called nick L costing 2.5k because i remember buying it but returned it withing the 30 days period
Yes and yes.

Tufxp isn't for me either, but it is working for some. Cashmaster system seems to be pretty consistent with TUFXP.
Reply With Quote
  #1547  
Old Nov 9, 2009 5:06am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Hope you all bagged your 30pips.
Reply With Quote
  #1550  
Old Nov 10, 2009 1:41am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by maq View Post
scull look at tradefair only 2 pip spread on gu also they give u ?75 to sign up and something to the person that refers you if you decide to put them in
Sorry missed this post, got lost in the thread.

Thanks for the tip mate, but to be honest although the spread seems lower by a pip, i actually really like IG's platform and i have had no problems with them in the past. Plus their customer service is good or has been for me anyway.

But thx anyway, much appreciated.

P.S. Careful today, BIG drop happened already.....................
Reply With Quote
  #1561  
Old Nov 11, 2009 4:25am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Guys -I think one of the best posts on here is post 211 by Strada.

Read it, it will help you with questions on times, where to plot your lines, buffers, etc, etc. Basically use whatever suits you and don't get too bogged down with the exactness of breakouts. For this breakout there are so many different permutations, so just do your own research and use the basic principle of the very first post.

No need to over complicate, it's so very simple.
Reply With Quote
  #1570  
Old Nov 11, 2009 6:58am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Reas View Post
Hi Koco,

That's good, but remember that all expierienced (i'm Dutch, dunno how to spell that :-) traders tell that losses cannot be avoided, every system has it's false breakouts.

If you test your system with a large enough data sample (10 years), it will become clear that those false breakouts are there, but in the long run they don't matter much.
That will also help you controling those nerves.
On the other hand it's allways a good idea to look for improvements.
As long as they are valid in your tests, you can decide to implement them, but...
Couldn't agree more with that Reas.
Reply With Quote
  #1576  
Old Nov 12, 2009 3:38am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by koco View Post
anyone has a GBP/USD on sell this morning?
Yep, fingers crossed eh.
Reply With Quote
  #1581  
Old Nov 12, 2009 6:43am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by koco View Post
Hey, Scullmeister, where's your entry/SL/TP?

Mine's: 1.65302/1.65879/1.65002
Hi my entry was:

Short: 1.6540.3 with a SL of 48.9.

Loss today, but still up for the month with 8 trades, 6 wins, 2 losses.

Plenty of days left to trade, so imo going well.
Reply With Quote
  #1582  
Old Nov 12, 2009 6:45am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scullmeister View Post
Hi my entry was:

Short: 1.6540.3 with a SL of 48.9.

Loss today, but still up for the month with 8 trades, 6 wins, 2 losses.

Plenty of days left to trade, so imo going well.
Sorry forgot to mention that PT was -30 from entry....
Reply With Quote
  #1584  
Old Nov 12, 2009 8:38am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

You will probably find that you will have a much higher hit rate if you put your SL to the range of the high and low line instead of 40, but never exceeding 60 and still only going for the +30 pips at a time.

You should average about 180ish pips per month and because it has a pretty good hit rate you could go for 5% of cash balance.

Just a thought.
Reply With Quote
  #1586  
Old Nov 12, 2009 8:41am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Amigo View Post
I had sell on 1.65465 with tp1=1.65165 . Still holding position, -12 points.
Good luck.
Reply With Quote
  #1587  
Old Nov 12, 2009 8:46am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scullmeister View Post
You will probably find that you will have a much higher hit rate if you put your SL to the range of the high and low line instead of 40, but never exceeding 60 and still only going for the +30 pips at a time.

You should average about 180ish pips per month and because it has a pretty good hit rate you could go for 5% of cash balance.

Just a thought.
By the way the above is using my trade times, don't want anyone to get confused as it may not work on other trade times, not sure.
Reply With Quote
  #1591  
Old Nov 13, 2009 2:38am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobcat2 View Post
Scull,

Please post your current trading rules to make certain I am following your strategy correctly.

Thanks,
Bob
Ok here are my rules Bobcat and for any other traders out there that are interested. This may not suit all of you, so just take a look. If you like them use them, if you don't, then maybe you can adjust them to suit your own style of trading.

15min timeframe using IG index quick charts
Draw vertical line @ 0500 (which closes at 0515) - London Time
Draw vertical line @ 0700 (which closes at 0715) - London Time
PT = +30
SL = The range of the high and low line, but never exceeding 60 pips.

Let the trades run all day if you have to, however if they have not activated by say 1700hrs London Time, then cancel, them but this is very rare indeed.

Don't trade on NFP days and any other high volatility days as you will end up losing more than you win.

I use 5% of my cash balance because it has an average hit rate of around 78%, but on Fri i lower my risk to just 2%.

Use a bit of common sense as well guys. If there is a high impact news announcement at say 0930 and it gets to say 0927 and your trade has been messing about at around 20-25ish pips and the feeling is that the news is going to make the trade go in the opposite direction, then just take your profits - best be safe than sorry!!!

This month we have had 8 trades, 6 wins, 2 losses, +87. Trade not activated today yet, but remember i have lowered my risk.........

That's it i think. Hope that helps and if you guys can think of any way to make it better than please reply with your comments, cheers.

Happy pipping.....................
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1592  
Old Nov 13, 2009 2:45am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scullmeister View Post
Ok here are my rules Bobcat and for any other traders out there that are interested. This may not suit all of you, so just take a look. If you like them use them, if you don't, then maybe you can adjust them to suit your own style of trading.

15min timeframe using IG index quick charts
Draw vertical line @ 0500 (which closes at 0515) - London Time
Draw vertical line @ 0700 (which closes at 0715) - London Time
PT = +30
SL = The range of the high and low line, but never exceeding 60 pips.

Let the trades run all day if you have to, however if they...
Bugger i always do this. For the Long, use buffer of 10 and the Short use 7, sorry. ARGGHHHH!!!!!
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1595  
Old Nov 13, 2009 3:25am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

+30 today, so for the month so far we have 9 trades, 7 wins, 2 losses.

Koco - Please refer to previous posts, all info is there for you. I trade GU.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1597  
Old Nov 13, 2009 4:16am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fumiryu View Post
Hi Scullmeister, according to your post at http://www.forexfactory.com/showpost...postcount=1393, you mentioned that you will not enter until GMT0730hrs (closing of GMT0715 candle) and with a stop loss of 40 pips and you also attached the results of your back test. Now you mentioned another method in this post. So which is a better system to use? Please advise. Thank you.
Hi there - There are a few other posts above from me that said that you may get better results using the strategy this way. However the other way also works, it's all a bit ying & yang, sometimes the other strategy will work best, sometimes this one. I just think that this way you will have a higher hit rate imo.

Why don't you do a bit of manual backtesting so you feel comfortable with which ever one you use. Only then should you risk your hard earned cash on it.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1599  
Old Nov 13, 2009 4:23am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DubaiTrader View Post
Good trading guys, if you feel like testing an EA, you should look in the 7-9 AM Big Dog thread, you can easily adjust it for London timings.
Thanks mate, much appreciated.

I have been keeping an eye on that thread with interest.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1600  
Old Nov 13, 2009 4:33am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DubaiTrader View Post
Good trading guys, if you feel like testing an EA, you should look in the 7-9 AM Big Dog thread, you can easily adjust it for London timings.
Re: EA's.

Imo the strategy is only 50% of your trading, i also use a few indicators now and then and a bit of common sense to manage the trade, so the EA will not show that. However don't get me wrong the EA can give you an idea of past results for sure.

Thx.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1602  
Old Nov 13, 2009 4:51am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by koco View Post
Scullmeister: and do you trade only GU? Not EU for example?

Today I missed the GU! Damn! However, I couldn't decide, because it started to raise right at 8 GMT and the box was 62 pips already, which is too large (against the rules), so I stood away.
Hi those aren't my rules??? Today was valid.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1624  
Old Nov 16, 2009 8:15am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Very anoying today, just missed my TP by 2 pips, then shot up, however still in the trade as set my SL to the range of the high and low.

Get down GU, lol.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1625  
Old Nov 16, 2009 11:51am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scullmeister View Post
Very anoying today, just missed my TP by 2 pips, then shot up, however still in the trade as set my SL to the range of the high and low.

Get down GU, lol.
Loss in the end on the GU, no worries always another day.

So this month 10 trades, 7 wins, 3 losses.

Lets hope toomorrow is better.

Happy trading..........
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1627  
Old Nov 16, 2009 2:09pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by koco View Post
Agreed, F***** day this day. Missed my TP by 3 pips, then lost 43 pips!!!
I'm starting to disbelieve this method...
Koco - you need to chill mate and be patient. The system is running at 7 wins, 3 losses if followed mechanically. For an hour or two in the morning is good going & still plenty of days left yet in the month.

You can't get anoyed and upset everytime you have have a loss, because losses happen, that's trading for you mate

If you don't have faith in the system, don't trade it and find another strategy that suits your style of trading.

I have been consistently profitable since trading it this way, so if you want, take my word, if not do a bit of manual back testing and see.

For you to get anoyed like this over a loss, seems to me like you may be trading with too high stakes for your comfort level.

Just keep trading it mechanically and i bet by the end of the month it is in profit. Oh and lower your stakes if you have to........

Chin up
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1636  
Old Nov 17, 2009 1:13am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Austinc1972 View Post
Well said, Scullmeister - patience is a virtue, and a key one when trading

Question for everyone out there - has anyone looked at taking the opposite trade if the initial trade loses?
eg this morning, the GU short trade at about 8.45am nearly hit the 30 pip TP but lost, reversing and then hitting the stop loss (wherever you put the SL); it then went long by about 120 pips, from 3pm till 7pm
I have seen this happen quite a lot - the trade either hits the TP and we all go away happy, or it bounces back and hits the stop loss, before going the other...
Hi Austin - I have been thinking about this myself mate as it seems viable. However due to the fact that you could potentially lose both trades, thats double the risk i am thinking of trading my first trade (proper trade if you like) at 5% risk and keeping the opposite trade open at only 2%. This way if it does lose, your only losing 2% of cash balance on top of the 5% already lost and if it makes a profit, then it reduces the loss of the first trade by a percentage.

Hope that makes sense

mmmmmmm
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1640  
Old Nov 17, 2009 2:46pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

So a loss today, that puts us on +86ish pips for the month trading it mechanically with 9 days left to trade.

Koco - I here you mate, trading is the most frustrating thing in the world, just keep the faith and when a loser occurs, just move on.

Keep the faith and keep disciplined and the pips will come.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1665  
Old Nov 23, 2009 4:46am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Good morning

All 3 indicators are blue this morning.

So if price breaks 1.6581 you have high probability to get 30 pips.

Good luck.

+30 pips bagged already for me.

Good luck traders............
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1676  
Old Nov 24, 2009 5:42am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Thanks mate.

Everything is red this morning.

Let's see.

Looking good, +30 for me.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1683  
Old Nov 24, 2009 12:17pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DubaiTrader View Post
Good work scull. What I'm finding is if London 'breaks out' then the NY box very rarely becomes a decent trade. So, stop nicking the decent trades!!!
Can't help being a pip muncher, lol.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1684  
Old Nov 24, 2009 12:19pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by AlinCairo View Post
Hi Scull,

Have been following the brakeout strategy for a while and have adopted your settings as a test for this month, but am confused as to how you have won today?

My low is on the 0715-0730 candle at 522.3. Minus 7 gives an open at 515.3, which mean the trade is still live.

I may have missed a post further with a change, so apologies if this is a stupid question,

Thanks,

al
No probs, i changed my box lines to 5am and 7am which closes at 7.15. Today Short was 16531.8, just made the +30 pips.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1685  
Old Nov 24, 2009 12:23pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Indyfx View Post
Hi,

My rules for the New York session for GBP USD are on the other thread "7am - 9am Big Dog USD Breakout" post # 2109. The results from my backtesting are also there. Hope this helps
Max 60 SL mate, not 40 and lines are drawn at 5 and 7 London time. From 1st Oct o now i'm on about +320 pips, but remember i don't trade mechanically all of the time, i exit trades where i feel appropriate, so your back test will not match my actual results.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1689  
Old Nov 25, 2009 1:08am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Indyfx View Post
Your results are great. I think that everyone has different requirements out of their trading system. For me I was looking for one that kept the SL smaller so that the return in relation to each position is greater. I have found that for me using a stop loss of 19 pips and entering after 07.15am works best. I am sure that there a lot of different ways that you can set up a system with broadly similar parameters and get good results
Exactly, use the basic principle and adjust accordingly to suit your trading style and that's it.

Happy trading and good luck today!
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1699  
Old Nov 25, 2009 3:42am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

+30 again, that's 5 wins on the bounce now, so pressing on nicely

No trade tomorrow due to Thanks Giving in the USA, so should be no volume in the markets.

Good luck if you do.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1709  
Old Nov 26, 2009 3:29am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DubaiTrader View Post
Another 30 pips on offer this morning on the very sharp downturn made by GU. Hope a few were on!
Of course!!!
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1716  
Old Nov 27, 2009 2:52am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Hope you all got in on that one, again another +30, that's 7 on the bounce now guys.

Koco - If your about mate, I told you, just stick with it and it will be in profit at the end of the month.

Have a good weekend guys.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1734  
Old Nov 29, 2009 2:58pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

I agree with you there Dubai. If you are trading GU breakout, then it would be common sense to try find another currency that is not correlated, GJ would be a bad choice.

I will look into this also.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1900  
Old Dec 11, 2009 8:15am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Sure

Look at post #1646.

I am using Scull's 5 to 7:30 method.

Hi Matt how are your results looking using my method, but with 85 EMA? Cheers
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1904  
Old Dec 11, 2009 9:48am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matlobien View Post
Sorry, I misread your question.

The above results is without 85 EMA.

With EMA:

Trades 4
Wins 3
% win 75
Pips 50

Cheers mate, nah still hovering around.

Thanks for results, much appreciated
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1954  
Old Dec 15, 2009 3:33pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by guitarman327 View Post
Why post if you dont need help and choose not to contribute? You come here just to brag that you have no losses and that you have a method that will not disclose? Many of us come here looking for help, even the experienced traders come here looking for new systems or ideas. I follow this thread from the first post and I had many losses until great guys like Scull and others came here and contributed with their ideas that perfected the original system. I am very thankful to many guys here. I am glad this is not a forum to show off or keep things...
Cheers mate, just read your post, many thanks, we should all work together in this.

Grant's system is also very good, i use that a lot and it is working great!

I must say again, just keep it very, very simply.

Draw lines at 5 and 7 or 7.15, doesn't matter all that much tbh. Set SL at 40 or to the range of boxes, but no more than 60 pips, take 30 pips profit. If the order hasn't activated by say 5ish London time, cancel orders. Be aware of high impact news announcements, but don't be scared. My results are based on trading it this way 100% robotically, with a bit of common sense thrown into the pot, i.e. NFP days are dodgy and some others, but even then you can trade and just lower your risks.

I think people are so into trying to eliminate losers (which is fair enough), but losing is part of the game, it's how you handle them that counts!

Accept it - Deal with it - Move on

Happy Pipping cheekos!!!
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1964  
Old Dec 16, 2009 1:34am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by maq View Post
i was going to ask grant scull and dt to update the methods in one post so all can see exactly

grant and scull beat me to it well done lads

sull whats your results like lately if you don't mind?

anybody know dt's method?

thanks again lads
I have +120 with an SL of 40 for Dec, so not bad considering it's generally not a great time to trade.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #1992  
Old Dec 16, 2009 3:08pm
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Indyfx View Post
I thought that I would add my two pennies worth. I must admit that whilst I do not condone what DT did I do have to express my thanks to him, Grant, Scull and the others (you know who you are) who are continuously sharing their thinking and spending their time working hard to help others

I have a real problem with the people that visit this thread (often for only a few posts) and they do not want to devote any of their time to research their ideas or share what they are doing all they want to do is take people ideas and go off...
Hi Indy - Thanks for your post. When you say you don't condone what DT did, what was that? Sorry if i have missed something.

Thanks for your input - good work.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2068  
Old Jan 6, 2010 7:17am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by AlinCairo View Post
Guys,

I am using sculls purely mechanical trading technique without the indicators.

Can anyone else verify wins with this over the pas two days?

Thanks,

al
Yes wins, just trade it mechanically and you will prevail.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2069  
Old Jan 6, 2010 7:25am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Sorry i don't post much anymore guys, just wanted to share my simple method which is a take on the original anyway, so not my own. I think you should be making decent profits if trading it mechanically now, i know i am.

I also trade Grants strategy the simple way and that is also bringing in the profits.

Happy pipping traders.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2073  
Old Jan 6, 2010 8:14am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by grant18265 View Post
thats what i use flyer. i try to not use more tahn 40 for the SL though...

cheers

Grant
Yeah traders discretion, the range for the SL, but never exceeding 60 or just 40, whatever sits with you well.

Hi Grant, hope your well mate, we had a loser on Mon using my strategy, so 2 wins, 1 loss.

Adios
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2081  
Old Jan 7, 2010 8:28am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Misiacyk View Post
Scullmeister - so your only filter is 10 and 7 pips of buffer?
You place two orders and wait for one to be activated and then you delate oposite one, or you leave two orders and it's possible for both of them to be activated?

Misiacyk
Hi - i close the opposite side, but i am looking at keeping both open, will monitor for 3 months then let you know my findings. Just 10 and 7 buffers.

Win today.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2086  
Old Jan 8, 2010 5:18am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Hope you guys enjoyed trading my strategy this week,1 loss, 4 wins, +80 for the week.

Have a cracking weekend!
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2088  
Old Jan 8, 2010 7:11am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Sorry do not understand your question?
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2092  
Old Jan 8, 2010 9:12am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by PipSqueeze View Post
What risk % do you use?
I only trade this strategy and 1 other so 2 trades per day, sometimes only 1 trade per day so i risk 5%, but that's your decision depending on your attitude to risk and how many other strategies you use.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2096  
Old Jan 8, 2010 9:54am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Austinc1972 View Post
Scull, great going with your breakout method again
Out of interest, what other strategy do you use?
Little and often seems to be a great way of trading

Happy pipping

Austin
Grants method using 85 EMA.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2099  
Old Jan 8, 2010 10:36am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Austinc1972 View Post
Aha, so still a breakout method, just with an additional indicator
Thought that you meant a completely different method eg MA crossovers, TUFXP etc
So you sometimes take 2 trades on one day at the same time on the same pair
Can I ask why?
There are a lot of no trades using Grants method, so mine compliments it quite well or bcoz the box times are earlier on Grants i may come in on Grants method and it may retrace and them mine activates the other side and makes a profit or whatever. Sometimes they both make a profit, sometimes they both lose. Sometimes Grants gets to +25 so move SL to B/E and it may retrace then mine might activate and come in. Swings and roundabouts really, but if they both make an average of +150 pips per month with 5% risk i'm a happy young man for a mornings work.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2101  
Old Jan 8, 2010 10:41am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Excellant
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2103  
Old Jan 8, 2010 10:55am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hova View Post
So i got 5 winners 1 looser (06.01.)

The looser went 3 pips in my favor and crushed in almost an hour.
We need to figure out how to avoid these trades.

OCO or half pos. size if the first one was a winner ?

thx to you Scull.
Don't think too much about it, losers happen you will never eliminate them.

5 wins and 1 loser, cracking.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2126  
Old Jan 11, 2010 6:48am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

I would personally prefer not to be greedy and take the original profit.

For example using my way (Sculls BO), my target is +30 and that's it. Go play golf, watch a movie, spend time with the kids, sunbathe or snowbathe if you live in the UK, go by a new car (ok maybe not). But you get my idea.

Imo you don't need to go for max pips, just go for a decent amount of pips and that's all you require, no need to over complicate with moving SL's and splitting position sizes etc, etc, you are just making more work for yourself.

Depending on your cash balance, just achieving +150 pips on average per month is plenty with a 3% or 5% risk, this is what Sculls method achieves on a monthly basis and has done for over a year.

Enjoy it, take the losses and accept the winners.

Just my opinion - thx.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2139  
Old Jan 11, 2010 11:16am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobcat2 View Post
Hi Scull,

What are you currently using for your SL and ending box time? You had earlier posted a couple of different optional parameters.

Thanks!
SL at moment is 40, PT is 30, box lines are 5 and 7 London local time, which closes at 7.15 real time.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2140  
Old Jan 11, 2010 11:22am
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Just to add, this month, 6 trades, 5 wins, 1 loss, so +110 for the month so far.

Good luck with the rest of your week guys.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2151  
Old Jan 12, 2010 1:21am (41 hr ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by gregart View Post
Hi Scull,

following your rules i find 2 loss, I certainly made an error but wich ?

thanks

Greg
Greg i do not know where you made the mistake, but it is def 5 wins, 1 loss.

Mon - -40
Tue - +30
Wed - +30
Thu - +30
Fri - +30
Mon - +30
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2155  
Old Jan 12, 2010 2:43am (39 hr ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hova View Post
looser on monday ? I got one @ the 6th

hmm....lookin at my chart i got a winner on 4th and 5th, but a looser on the 6th
As stated in my very first post many moons ago, i use IG charts, so my short activated and it then shot up and went long. It all depends on your broker and spread i guess. I trade this live and my results for the month are my actual live results using IG.

Not to worry, depending on your broker we may always get different results, but if you use IG they will be same as mine. You may even get better results than me using a different company, i don't know.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2170  
Old Jan 12, 2010 8:39am (33 hr ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by maq View Post
not all loses are -60 but still good
Exactly what i was going to say Mat, some of the losses will be 20, 30, 40,50 etc, etc, but using 60 shows the worst case scenario. I am using 40 standard at the moment and it seems to be working well.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2173  
Old Jan 12, 2010 9:18am (33 hr ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Austinc1972 View Post
Do you guys not use ? or $ to measure wins and losses, rather than pips?
If my risk on each trade is ?100 (for 40 pips), then a win is ?75 (30 pips at ?2.50 per pip) and a loss is ?100
Just because one day the SL is 50 pips, my loss would still be ?100 but my win would be ?60 (30 pips at ?2.00 per pip)

Just curious, as I am sure that the bank manager would rather see money than pips

Austin
I do for myself, you have to (pips mean nothing, real hard cash is everything), but for newbies reading this i just wanted to point that out or else a flood of posts will come in all in confusion.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2185  
Old Jan 13, 2010 5:43am (12 hr ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pippopotamus View Post
Lost four in a row. Using .5 box as SL/35 max. TP 37. Currently watching 04:00-07:15 GMT(entry at 07:15). Entry buffer 1, add spread to buys. No EMA/Slope filters. Pull orders 1 hr 15 min after session open. Close positions 15 min. before NY open. Manually backtested all of 2009. These settings proved best overall. Now they appear a recipe for disaster(In about 2 weeks of trading, already nearing max DD record for previous 52 weeks!!). Starting tomorrow, guess I will 1)ignore time changes from one season to another 2)use non-volatility based micro...
-40 for me as well, however on this occasion if your SL was to the range it would have been +30.

Oh well battle lost today, but as long as you win the war, it'll be alright.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2188  
Old Jan 13, 2010 6:03am (12 hr ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by AlinCairo View Post
Guys,

BE for me today, the UK open to the upside I felt was too close to the monthly pivot and so I added a few pips extra to the buffer (open at 1.6240). Moved my stop to BE at +20 pips and got taken out on retracement.

Scull do you use pivots in looking at setups? I know that yours is a mechanical method (and I have been pretty methodical following it) but I had a little bit more time on my hands this morning and it seems to have worked out okay.

cheers,

al
Hi Al - No i don't, i just trade this particular strategy as mechanically as poss as this is what my results are based on. I may use a bit of common sense now and then for exit levels etc, but generally just trade it mechanically. It's on +30 for the month so far using IG charts.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
  #2204  
Old Jan 13, 2010 3:46pm (2 hr 47 min ago)
Scullmeister's Avatar
Member
 
Member Since Oct 2009
Default

Hi guys i am going to stop replying to questions for a bit as i seem to be getting the same ones everyday, trust you understand. I must have been asked approx 7 times now what my settings are and it's starting to drive me a bit nuts.

Also people are asking why i have a win and they have a loss or vica versa. If you follow the strategy as per my details mentioned many times before and you still get different results then it is simply that your your broker/spread betting company is different to mine and the spread has caused a different result and that is it. I have gone over everything i think i need to re: my strategy and i have helped best i can, but i can't keep answering the same questions over and over again, for my own sanity if anything.

Don't want to sound like an arse, but everything you need is in this thread.

I am currently working on another strategy that since Sept 09 has brought in approx 400 pips per month, trading 0800hrs till 1500rs and +200 pips, trading 0800hrs to 1200hrs, with an SL of 15 and the PT can be anything from say 10 pips to 150 pips per trade depending if the indicators line up. I will be sharing this with the forum soon.

Thanks for your understanding.
__________________
Just go with the FLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply With Quote
Reply

10 Traders Viewing This Thread (2 are members)
flyer415, volcano
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
New Variation on 7 am to 9 am Breakout Strategy lucashammer Trading Systems 162 Jan 8, 2010 4:21am
Breakout Strategy - The Pro's Way Micardo Trading Systems 166 Dec 5, 2009 6:34pm
KISS FX Breakout Strategy Miksu Trading Systems 36 Nov 29, 2009 2:21pm
Breakout Strategy gustav213 Trading Systems 10 Jun 23, 2009 8:20pm
Help: EA for 1-2-3 Formation Breakout Strategy musical88 Programming Discussion 1 Jan 23, 2008 2:31am